Costco - membership worth it?

Because the quality of food has been driven down by the mass retailers. And as a result of this the quality of diet has decreased drastically. Take meat as the prime example. Cheap supermarket meat has led to poor quality meat, injected with water and god knows what else to make it look appealing and bigger in size, whilst offering very little nutritional value at all. Take the mighty Tesco's £2 chicken. Yeah you can buy a whole chicken to feed the family, but it's crap meat that tastes dire and offers very little nutritional value.

The amount of waste in a Supermarket is staggering; energy, packaging, refuse, etc. The use of plastic bags.

Sourcing products from this country supports the British economy. Not shipping in massive quantities from overseas because it can be bought in bulk cheaper. And the economic factors of Supermarkets buying power, paying %'s below market rates to suppliers, essentially forcing local farmers and businesses out of business.

Loss of community to a certain extent. Growing your own stuff on the allotment or in your back yard, sharing excess food with the neighbours, and so on.

Lots of reasons really if you think about it.

All very true, but how does this really apply to Costco?

It's a Cash N Carry, not a supermarket. Oddly enough i think you'll find the general quality of the food they sell to be far far higher than the average supermarket. I would even say higher than some local butchers or green grocers. It's easy to forget that some local suppliers (as has always been the case) offer terrible quality food.

Some of the worst meat I have ever eaten came from a "good local family butcher".

I'm not saying your wrong, but I am saying that perhaps the argument doesnt hold for special cases like Cash N Carry style stores. The fact that you have to pay to even go in must tell you its a different type of store to a supermarket.

Coupled with the fact Costco's store is perhaps 50% food and then 50% other goods you simply cannot buy for reasonable prices outside of the internet normally...
 
All very true, but how does this really apply to Costco?

It's a Cash N Carry, not a supermarket. Oddly enough i think you'll find the general quality of the food they sell to be far far higher than the average supermarket. I would even say higher than some local butchers or green grocers. It's easy to forget that some local suppliers (as has always been the case) offer terrible quality food.

Some of the worst meat I have ever eaten came from a "good local family butcher".

I'm not saying your wrong, but I am saying that perhaps the argument doesnt hold for special cases like Cash N Carry style stores. The fact that you have to pay to even go in must tell you its a different type of store to a supermarket.

Coupled with the fact Costco's store is perhaps 50% food and then 50% other goods you simply cannot buy for reasonable prices outside of the internet normally...
Agreed that not all the same arguments apply here, but some still do.

The sourcing of non-local goods, the energy wastages, packaging and so forth still apply.

And yes - they sell more then just food, but thats the portion I aimed my argument at, and indeed was in response to the OP talking about food :).
 
Can certainly backup the Meat Quality argument, we often buy in months worth of Meat and freeze it. It's fantastic quality!

The only packaging you get is either the crate itself, or minimal polystyrene for the meat, or when it comes to spirits, the bottle itself. They don't use carrier bags as far as i'm aware either.
 
<cough> Supermarket/conglomerate vs. Local retailer/sustainable goods argument over that way please ---->
this thread is purely for me to decide whether I should be putting money in the american giants pocket ;)

Thanks for responses so far. Looks like a mixed bag - pretty much along the lines of what I was expecting - bulk buy cleaning/consumables, but food/drink (unless buying/catering for parties) is probably no different in cost to a supermarket.

Hmm - do they still do the thing of allowing you to browse before you sign up? Might try convincing the family we need a "day out" to Reading! I take 'em to all the best places....

....think the attraction of the kids sweets could be a problem too - strawberry laces! :D
 
this thread is purely for me to decide whether I should be putting money in the american giants pocket ;)


Are makro owned by costco?


Maybe try them insted? :p

I find the meat ther to be much better than all the local butchers, and you can buy bacon in packs that can only be described as Epic, in both taste and quantity :p
 
Nice selective quoting :).

Well asking What makes British produce any better wouldn't really have anything to do with how the packaging tastes now would it?


If nothing else, in the current financial climate, our economy needs the boost.

And you think supermarkets buying British products at extortionate prices like they do imports would benefit the farmers more than the higher prices they could get from higher class establishments under the idea that British products are somehow superior?


But you could argue that everyone having more money because they are buying cheaper food, and thus having more money to spend on other products and British services would help the economy more.

Although being limited to seasonal produce and utterly ridiculous out of season prices if most food was sourced in britain alone, would probbaly put a dampener on things too.
 
You can quite happily grow Strawberries all year round. Grow your own, they taste a lot nicer :).

tried it large patch get hardly any and they got ripped to sheds by cats, birds and everything else that could get in the garden even through some pretty strong wire mesh.
 
You can quite happily grow Strawberries all year round. Grow your own, they taste a lot nicer :).

Sorry OP this is de-railing your thread.

To play the antagonist, I love strawberrys too, how do I go about growing my own? I live in a flat in a city centre. I do have a balcony but it hardly gets any sun so its terrible for growing things.

Allotments in the greater manchester area are currently on a 2 year waiting list.

I am not saying growing your own food is not a good thing, it is, my grandparents (who live in a greater manchester suburb) are actually totally self reliant when it comes to food, except recently when they have stopped keeping meat animals and buy from a local farmshop. It's a lovely thing, but totally unrealistic for anybody living in a more normal UK setting. Perhaps this isnt the case in most of the Cambridgeshire area, but it certainly is up here.

Supermarkets are a near inevitable consequence of a small landmass supporting far more human beings than it should be able to.

It's a very nice idea that we could become totally self reliant as a country on British or even just UK grown food, however it's just not going to happen anymore, not unless we somehow cut our current population (and thats not counting growth rate) by at least a quarter, some say more.

Some people will always have the time and more importantly, space to live the "good life" and tbh good luck to them, for the rest of us though who spend 8+ hours a day 5+ days a week sat in an office or in a lorry or whatever, it really isn't feasible it simply isn't.

Neither are locally run small shops. It isnt even always about cost, for many people it would simply be a case of, would a local greengrocer be willing to stay open until gone 8 when I often come home? The only reason I can go shopping is because my local supermarkets are all open at least until 11pm. None of them shut for lunch either...

Food self reliance in this country would require MUCH more than just local suppliers and small retailers, it would require the entire economy and way of life at least 4 generations have now become used to to change entirely. We would need to step away from being a world economic power and host nation to large global corporations, it isn't going to happen.

To the OP (just to try and keep it on track), for the small amount of money it costs, i'd get a membership and see if you use it. Costco is brilliant come christmas time, they tend to have a few of literally everything, but the few things they have are always the best quality at a good price. It isnt just food, for example, I recently bought 8 litres of Castrol GTX car oil for £17.99, which is cheaper than you will find in most places. It's a great place to do a lot of your christmas shopping, and their enormous mince "tarts" (they arnt pies) are great as well :)
 
Because the quality of food has been driven down by the mass retailers. And as a result of this the quality of diet has decreased drastically. Take meat as the prime example. Cheap supermarket meat has led to poor quality meat, injected with water and god knows what else to make it look appealing and bigger in size, whilst offering very little nutritional value at all. Take the mighty Tesco's £2 chicken. Yeah you can buy a whole chicken to feed the family, but it's crap meat that tastes dire and offers very little nutritional value.

The amount of waste in a Supermarket is staggering; energy, packaging, refuse, etc. The use of plastic bags.

Sourcing products from this country supports the British economy. Not shipping in massive quantities from overseas because it can be bought in bulk cheaper. And the economic factors of Supermarkets buying power, paying %'s below market rates to suppliers, essentially forcing local farmers and businesses out of business.

Loss of community to a certain extent. Growing your own stuff on the allotment or in your back yard, sharing excess food with the neighbours, and so on.

Lots of reasons really if you think about it.

Nail, head, supermarkets have killed many farmers off, once they're all gone where am I going to get a good quality bit of meat? Or some veg which hasn't been sat about for days?

I always buy as much as I can locally, and people moan "Oh it's too expensive" well it's not if you don't waste half of what you eat.
A basic example of this would be the amount of people who leave chicken on the carcass or throw the carcass away when it's good to make chicken stock it's unreal. Or people buying individual prepack bits of chicken when butchering a chicken takes 5 minutes and saves you money.
Greengrocers are often cheaper than supermarkets and much fresher too.

What really annoys me is ready meals, those disgusting chemically things people microwave or put in the oven. They taste like ass, can no one cook these days? They're so blooming expensive as well.
 
Gaaahh - please can you carry this conversation out in another thread please? I'm looking for opinions about poeple who use this place - not a discussion about the rights and wrongs of it.


<and breath>
 
Can certainly backup the Meat Quality argument, we often buy in months worth of Meat and freeze it. It's fantastic quality!

The only packaging you get is either the crate itself, or minimal polystyrene for the meat, or when it comes to spirits, the bottle itself. They don't use carrier bags as far as i'm aware either.

Thats what we do, we just buy in the months worth of meat and fish. Its fantasic quality which is considerably better than the supermarket IMO. The meat is also British.
 
Back
Top Bottom