EVGA Classified + Intel i7 975 + Corsair Dominator 2000mhz 7-8-7-20 - Will it work?

Associate
Joined
15 Nov 2009
Posts
6
Okay, I'm not a computer noob by any means, but I am left wondering about this setup due to a youtube video I watch which concerned me.


What exactly is wrong with that setup? Is it specific to his setup? Will it effect me in the same matter when I buy a very similar setup? Can this be corrected? Would isng a C0 I7 solve this problem?

I am planning to run with:
intel I7 975
6gb Corsair Dominator 7-8-7-20
EVGA Classified mobo
1200w ThermalTake PSU
2*ATI XFX 5890(not yet released) Black Editions
6*WD 1TB RE3 HDD's in RAID[5]

To solve the heat issue I will be using a water-cooled solution.
 
I completely agree with 95thrifles. Anyone that spends this much money on a PC purely for gaming is either trolling or a complete and utter idiot.
 
Or an overclock enthusiast who competes at benchmark competitions. Now - anyone going to give me some useful info or are you all going to bitch that you can't get this setup yourselves?

What I mean by what is wrong with it - I am refering to the video, where only 2 were sticks functioning at 2000mhz 7-8-7-20 timings, when 3 sticks were used the RAM timings/clock speed became gimped. I'm not buying a system of this spec only to have it do the exact same thing.

Also it doesn't matter if C0 isn't available anymore, I'm willing to purchase a pre-owned chip solong as it meets my standards.
 
Last edited:
At the end of the video, the guy says he can't put RAM in the last slot and get it to work - he then says be will RMA (return to manufacturer authroisation) the board . Therefore he believes the motherboard is broken and needs replacing. With this in mind, I wouldn't worry about it.



However, unless you want to break some kind of benchmark record I wouldn't suggest going for the spec you listed above. The i7 975 is a waste of time unless you are trying to push 4.5GHz. If you think you will be happy with 4GHz, then look no further than the i7 920 D0. As for dominator RAM, I don't see the point TBH, this stuff is plenty fast enough and works well in overclocked machines.

As for graphics card and PSU, a high quality 750-850W would do the job fine. The graphics cards are not released so I don't think I can pass judgement- but I would suggest just getting one initially then adding a second when it is required.

The EVGA classified is a fantastic board, but only to be used for extreme overclocking with custom watercooling. If you don't plan on doing both of these, save your money and get this.
 
At the end of the video, the guy says he can't put RAM in the last slot and get it to work - he then says be will RMA (return to manufacturer authroisation) the board . Therefore he believes the motherboard is broken and needs replacing. With this in mind, I wouldn't worry about it.
Ahh - didn't know what RMA meant. Well I hope this is the case as I have my mind set on that mobo.

However, unless you want to break some kind of benchmark record I wouldn't suggest going for the spec you listed above. The i7 975 is a waste of time unless you are trying to push 4.5GHz. If you think you will be happy with 4GHz, then look no further than the i7 920 D0. As for dominator RAM, I don't see the point TBH, this stuff is plenty fast enough and works well in overclocked machines.

As previously stated, I'm an overclock/benchmark enthusiast. This is my Aim.

As for graphics card and PSU, a high quality 750-850W would do the job fine. The graphics cards are not released so I don't think I can pass judgement- but I would suggest just getting one initially then adding a second when it is required.
Unfortunately the BE's have a limited quantity, so I will be looking at buying both at the same time, or finding a pre-owned BE laters on down the road, which I don't really want to do.

The EVGA classified is a fantastic board, but only to be used for extreme overclocking with custom watercooling. If you don't plan on doing both of these, save your money and get this.
I do.

Thank you for your time, atleast I am reassured a little bit about the compatibility of this setup.
 
Something you may not have considered is that your system might not run the ram at the rated specifications. The ram will certainly be capable of it, but your particular processor might not be. The integrated memory controller is an unknown variable until you've had a play with the chip in question. Buying a 965 won't help with this, though buying either of the extreme editions does make it slightly more likely that you'll get a chip with a good memory controller.

Now - anyone going to give me some useful info or are you all going to bitch that you can't get this setup yourselves?

You've asked a spectacularly novice question while saying you're going to overclock the system to its limits in the interests of benchmarking. Six 1tb drives in raid 5 is barely appropriate for a home server, and completely inappropriate for a bench. You happen to have quoted the most expensive component in each section. This is the reason for the sarcastic response, not jealousy. It doesn't look like you know what you're doing.
 
I find it a bit strange tbh that you're asking advice about compatibility issues if you're the big overclocker/benchmarking enthusiast??

If you don't know the difference between the D0 and C0 stepping core i7's then may I suggest you're not the big overclocking guru you perhaps think you are.

If this thread isn't complete BS then I urge you to do a lot more research before building your new pc, as it could prove a very costly experience if you get it wrong.
 
Something you may not have considered is that your system might not run the ram at the rated specifications. The ram will certainly be capable of it, but your particular processor might not be. The integrated memory controller is an unknown variable until you've had a play with the chip in question. Buying a 965 won't help with this, though buying either of the extreme editions does make it slightly more likely that you'll get a chip with a good memory controller.



You've asked a spectacularly novice question while saying you're going to overclock the system to its limits in the interests of benchmarking. Six 1tb drives in raid 5 is barely appropriate for a home server, and completely inappropriate for a bench. You happen to have quoted the most expensive component in each section. This is the reason for the sarcastic response, not jealousy. It doesn't look like you know what you're doing.

JonJ678, I'm not asking about the system as a whole, but the system in comparison to that video. I normally do not need to ask, and will know if a system will/wont work. However this one has me puzzled, that system, should be fully compatable. There was nothing in my mind which made me doubt it. The mobo can handle the RAM and the CPU, it can also handle the GPU, and the PSU is sufficient. However - going against everything I thought I knew - the system in that youtube video did not work. Everyone here will agree that the system should work according to the tech specs. I'm looking for someone who owns the same mobo, an I7, and the Corsair RAM to post their experience, if it worked for them, if they got the same problem, if they fixed it. Based upon those posts, I would have concluded for or against the setup to be a working one. I'm sorry I did not phrase my question in a professional manner, however I was unaware I would get such an aggressive response from all of you little 'know it all's'. If you do not have a system similar to above, your input is seemingly useless to me. Ohh - And yes, I did check that the system would run at those specs, I chose the components so that they would run at such a spec.
*is deeply offended by the word novice*

The HDD's are for personal use. I already have 2.5tb used up. I need more. But past a certain point the speed of the hard drives starts to make such little impact to benchmarking performance, unless ofcourse its purely aimed at the HDD's.

I find it a bit strange tbh that you're asking advice about compatibility issues if you're the big overclocker/benchmarking enthusiast??

If you don't know the difference between the D0 and C0 stepping core i7's then may I suggest you're not the big overclocking guru you perhaps think you are.

If this thread isn't complete BS then I urge you to do a lot more research before building your new pc, as it could prove a very costly experience if you get it wrong.

Then you as well have misunderstood me. I am referring to the video's problem - as this problem should never occur, not with that system. I'm looking for people with experience with a similar setup.

I understand what C0 and D0 stepping are, however I was wondering if the new D0 arch was built with flaws in, such as not being able to handle such high speed ram for any reason, maybe such as the stated not being able to handle such voltages.

I am doing my research now - why do you think I'm asking? I know how to build PC's, I've built many. Either all of you have completely mis-understood what I have asked, or you are to enraged by my question to even pay attention to my whole post.


I'm not a 13 old kid wanting to post stupid specs and get a reaction
I work as a Software developer, and have done for the past 9 years.
I have only recently gotten into benchmarking on a quad core system, I have built > 20 computers, for myself or friends, usually high spec.
I am asking about a specific problem with the system, and am looking for someone with a similar system (I7, same mobo, same RAM) to comment on their experience, if they had the same problem, if they fixed it, what they did to fix it

Have I made myself clear enough now? I'm the genuine article. I'm buying this setup, or similar, and want advice from an owner of a similar setup as to what their experience was on this issue. If you don't even own the motherboard - do not even reply to this thread. Enough of the bs posts and give me something which will actually help me.
 
Last edited:
Why not ask the Youtube user directly how he resolved the problem instead of foolishly hoping that someone has got the exact same specs on this forum? Because I can guarantee that the chances of someone with the exact same spec, who is online now, and prepared to answer your questions after your latest outburst will be slim to none.
 
I have your answer, after trawling through the dude's comments, here is the story:

- Initially he thought it was the motherboard
- He sent it for RMA and got a replacement
- Still had the same problem
- Figured it had to be the RAM
- Sent out RAM to corsair and got a replacement set
- Installed replacement set - worked as advertised

I had to rma my gt's to corsair ive got a new set and they work as they should i think the quality control on triple channel memory sucks.

So in the end - this specific guy had a duff set of RAM, there is no intrinsic fault with that setup. You can see this comment by clicking "view all 75 comments" and look for the ones 2 months ago.

Hopefully that answers your question.
 
Back
Top Bottom