BF, MW2, L4D2 are all under this category and you don't think they compete?
Entertainment - Video Game - FPS - Key Multiplayer Component
Theres no way I'm gonna spend time on some budget game if I have bought either of the AAA releases..
if by FPS 'same catagory' yes, but to assume the game is not worthy simply because its classed as a 'budget' game then i dont agree.
gameplay is what counts first and foremost, single player content is of no concern for me as i buy purely for MP mayhem... L4D2 brings me nothing new (Borderlands will get my cash instead) and MW2 will probably be the same game with new clothes(not a bad thing).
BF1943 has 4 maps, it has destructable scenery, vehicles and tanks , artillery and best of all old school WWII dogfighting !!! 'ratatatatataaa ..
@ Thegoon84 : bring it on bud !
!

, so anything less just wont fill the larger maps. 
