rage against the x-factor - Outcome: RATM is the Christmas Number One!

I see what you're saying, but we've shown what we can do. Don't you think we could finally be back on track to getting charts with half decent music in them? If that's the case then why stop now?
 
I'm assuming that 40K must be mainly people that have bought it off the back of airplay.

I don't really think the singles chart will ever really be about music again. Surely music fans buy albums?

I would normally only buy singles for B sides or as an album 'taster'. Downloads have pretty much killed that.
 
I see what you're saying, but we've shown what we can do. Don't you think we could finally be back on track to getting charts with half decent music in them? If that's the case then why stop now?

Question is though - why do you care? I'm sure you buy the music you like irrespective of the charts anyway!

Even though I like RATM, and have no time for X-Factor stuff - or 'pop' in general, I can't really see that this campaign makes any sense at all. I'm sure the charts will revert to their normal status next week, and most of the people that bought the RATM single will just go back to not listening to it (or caring about it)!

I gave up being a musical snob a long time ago, and understood that people could like whatever they wanted - their choices being just as valid as mine!
 
I'm assuming that 40K must be mainly people that have bought it off the back of airplay.

I don't really think the singles chart will ever really be about music again. Surely music fans buy albums?

I would normally only buy singles for B sides or as an album 'taster'. Downloads have pretty much killed that.

Music Fans buy albums? what do people buy a single for then to eat it?
 
I think music is something you need to vote with your wallet for. Musicians need to make money. Just think of the quality drop if they all just did it in their spare time.
 
I think music is something you need to vote with your wallet for. Musicians need to make money. Just think of the quality drop if they all just did it in their spare time.

I think it'd be better actually, if musicians were paid for with donations instead of a wage packet. If they were all doing it in their spare time then we'd have sincere musicians and not just those who get into it for the money and fame.
 
if it wasnt for the RATM campaign he wouldnt have sold as many copies of his carp.
That doesn't change my position. I wanted to make a point and it was made (with the help of a lot of people). I wanted to see my choice on top for Christmas - it shook some people up and showed that there's hope for this country yet :D - and somehow, I still feel sorry for the guy. He's just a kid, taking advantage of the opportunity provided by Simon Cowell and those who adore the X-Factor. It's not him whose the problem. Plus if I **** him off, I'll get a smack around the chops - this campaign has already gotten me into bother :D

I see what you're saying, but we've shown what we can do. Don't you think we could finally be back on track to getting charts with half decent music in them? If that's the case then why stop now?
In general, I couldn't give a crap about the charts. I haven't looked at the charts results for years - what I did object to was the amount of drivel that people in this country accept as art. I took the opportunity to get behind something I believed in, waved my arms in the air and extended a digit towards the pop culture I see all around me. For now, that's enough :D

That said, perhaps there is scope for taking it forward, but it should be considered and have a plan to reach a desired target. Merely continuing to purchase the same song is not well-considered or likely to really prove anything. To be honest, I'm not sure I feel the need to bother with the charts any more - until next Christmas.... :D

I also wonder how many of those sales for RATM this week are just people who were too thick to understand that sales after midnight on Saturday don't count? :D
 
The only thing I disliked about this campaign is the sheer snobbery of some of the people who bought RATM as if their musical taste was right and everyone else wrong. Great to hear RATM on the radio, not so great to hear some of the snobs who sound as bad as the kids who play their rap and call people who like (any) rock 'goths'.
 
The only thing I disliked about this campaign is the sheer snobbery of some of the people who bought RATM as if their musical taste was right and everyone else wrong. Great to hear RATM on the radio, not so great to hear some of the snobs who sound as bad as the kids who play their rap and call people who like (any) rock 'goths'.

Yep, it made me cringe at times. Also the hatred and abuse toward Joe is pathetic, since the campaign was originally to overthrow X-Factor as number 1, not Joe. Heck, Joe hadn't even won when the whole thing started!
 
Joe said:
"I will be really disappointed if it doesn't go to No1 after all the effort I've put in to this and winning the show."

Yea, all that effort writing the song and music, playing instruments, singing it, working hard to get a record deal by pimping demo's out to record companies...

Oh, wait... :rolleyes:
 
That doesn't change my position. I wanted to make a point and it was made (with the help of a lot of people). I wanted to see my choice on top for Christmas

Yeah!

To be honest though, I'm really surprised we won with you on our team Luw!

Haha Zing!
 
I surprised by how much my interest in RATM has been rekindled since this started.

I used to listen to them loads, and hear them in rock clubs etc but pretty much forgot about them for the last few years.

Been playing them non stop for over a week now and I've been loving it. That's made this whole thing worth it for me alone. :)
 
screenshot20091221at181.png


Gilly is now Rage obsessed i fear.

:/
 
Back
Top Bottom