Phone call recording legalities

Soldato
Joined
29 Sep 2003
Posts
5,846
Location
Blaydon on Tyne
Hi all

This is purely out of interest, rather than being something I want to do! If you call a company, and you automatically hear the message saying that the call may be recorded, does that entitle you as the caller to also record the conversation? Logically, I would say yes since both parties have agreed that the call may be recorded.

What are the actual legalities?

Many thanks

Michael.
 
Is there anyone in particular you're going to record? If you plan to use the recording in any kind legal capacity the other party needs to be informed that you are recording the call and they need to agree that they are ok with it.

If they are not OK with it you should stop recording out of politeness to the individual you are talking to, you can of course continue to record but you will not be able to use it for anything other than personal use.
 
as a company there are data protection laws to comply with. Not so sure about personal use, but definitely cannot ne used for legal purposes without notification.
 
Is there anyone in particular you're going to record? If you plan to use the recording in any kind legal capacity the other party needs to be informed that you are recording the call and they need to agree that they are ok with it.

If they are not OK with it you should stop recording out of politeness to the individual you are talking to, you can of course continue to record but you will not be able to use it for anything other than personal use.

Let's say I wanted to record a call I had with a mobile network. Since they have already acknowledge that the call may be recorded, can I then also record the call without me warning them, and can I use that recording for a legal purpose?
 
Let's say I wanted to record a call I had with a mobile network. Since they have already acknowledge that the call may be recorded, can I then also record the call without me warning them, and can I use that recording for a legal purpose?

This was answered above - no. You have to inform the person you are speaking to that you intend to record the phone conversation.
 
Let's say I wanted to record a call I had with a mobile network. Since they have already acknowledge that the call may be recorded, can I then also record the call without me warning them, and can I use that recording for a legal purpose?

You can legally record it, but you cannot legally play it to anyone other than yourself, as per the first link. The acknowledgement that the call is being recorded by the company does not negate the need for you to inform them of you recording it if you plan on ever letting anyone else listen to it :)
 
You can legally record it, but you cannot legally play it to anyone other than yourself, as per the first link. The acknowledgement that the call is being recorded by the company does not negate the need for you to inform them of you recording it if you plan on ever letting anyone else listen to it :)

I see. So can you simply reply to the recorded message saying 'and I may record this call for monitoring and legal purposes'?
 
I see. So can you simply reply to the recorded message saying 'and I may record this call for monitoring and legal purposes'?

You have to gain consent, not just inform them if you plan to let any third party hear it. The rules governing companies are slightly different with regards to recording for internal use. Indeed companies don't actually have to inform you the call is being recorded for training and monitoring purposes, it's more a matter of courtesy.
 
Consent? So presumably by staying on the line means I've given my consent? If a company records a conversation i'd presume you have a legal right to a copy of said conversation for a nominal fee as per cctv recording.

Iirc you have the legal right to a copy of your image if recorded on a cctv system and the system owner may make only a nominal charge (ie cost of media / postage) for giving it to you. It's one of the reasons that CCTV notices have to be erected with the name of the system operator. Unless the law has changed or I'm wrong, again.
 
Last edited:
You have to gain consent, not just inform them if you plan to let any third party hear it. The rules governing companies are slightly different with regards to recording for internal use. Indeed companies don't actually have to inform you the call is being recorded for training and monitoring purposes, it's more a matter of courtesy.

Okey dokey thanks.
 
Consent? So presumably by staying on the line means I've given my consent? If a company records a conversation i'd presume you have a legal right to a copy of said conversation for a nominal fee as per cctv recording.

Iirc you have the legal right to a copy of your image if recorded on a cctv system and the system owner may make only a nominal charge (ir cost of media / postage) for giving it to you. It's one of the reasons that CCTV notices have to be erected with the name of the system operator. Unless the law has changed or I'm wrong, again.

See the earlier links. From the business point of view, it is not a consent matter, they don't even have to inform you, provided it is only being used internally for a few select activities.

With regards to rights to the recording, I am not aware that there is a similar right to CCTV recordings, and can't find anything confirming it either way.
 
Last edited:
You have to gain consent, not just inform them if you plan to let any third party hear it. The rules governing companies are slightly different with regards to recording for internal use. Indeed companies don't actually have to inform you the call is being recorded for training and monitoring purposes, it's more a matter of courtesy.

Companies do have to notify you of their intention to record, it is a legal obligation. Companies do not have to gain consent to play recorded calls to a third party in all situations as a legal NDA and data security document may cover this aspect. Some notes taken from Call Centre Helper:

Recording Employees

In 2003 there were some major amendments to the Data Protection Act**, in particular, in relation to the monitoring of employees and recording of information, be it data, video or voice. Organisations doing this must now let employees know they are being recorded before doing so. Legally you must make telephone lines that are not recorded available for employees to make private telephone calls (these can be pay phones). Good practice guidelines advise that you tell employees why you are recording them.

Recording Customers

The organisation must put in place a process whereby every customer is notified that his or her call may be recorded and what the purpose for recording is, prior to the telephone conversation is taking place.

For incoming enquiries, many organisations insert a notification into the IVR system, as this ensures that every caller is notified. The phrase: “Your call may be recorded for training or monitoring purposes” is most commonly used, because it notifies the caller that they may be recorded and tells them for what purpose. Equally, recipients of outbound calling must also be notified at the beginning of every conversation, to give the person opportunity to object.

Some organisations notify customers through adverts and literature. This is not required or ideal, as it cannot guarantee that every caller will see it before calling.

Record-on-Demand

The same principle applies – the agent must advise the customer that they are about to be recorded, before hitting the record-on-demand button. They should not record any call without notifying the customer first, no matter what the circumstances (i.e. if the customer is irate).

**Recording guidelines are detailed in the 1st Principle of the Data Protection Act, entitled: Fair and Lawful Processing.

and

For any contact centre that intends to record or monitor calls it is strongly advised that they ensure that they are behaving in an appropriate manner, in order to avoid any criminal offences and civil actions that may result from a failure to comply with all relevant legislation. The following provides a general guideline outlining our current understanding of the main legal issues connected with telephone call recording in UK commercial organisations. However, contact centres must always seek their own independent legal advice before proceeding to implement any call recording system.

Preparing your contact centre to record

Every contact centre that plans to record needs to ask itself why it is going to do so, for how long will these recording need to be kept to fulfil this purpose, who will have access to the recordings and for what specific reasons? Once these initial questions have been answered the following safeguards should be considered.

1. Decide and record the intended purpose(s) for which the recordings will be used.

2. Ensure the recordings are protected from misuse. This is a requirement of the Data Protection Act 1998 (DPA).

3. Ensure that the organisation is registered with the Information Commissioner, if necessary (see http://www.ico.gov.uk/).

4. Ensure that users of recorded lines (agents and callers) are informed that they may be recorded for the intended purpose. The DPA requires that data subjects be informed of the purpose for which their data may be processed; the Human Rights Act 1998 implies that users of the recorded lines should be informed so that they no longer have the expectation that their calls are private and the Telecommunications Act, 1984, requires parties to a call to be informed if they might be recorded. This is frequently done via a recorded announcement given at the start of a call stating, for example: “Calls may be recorded for security and training purposes”.

5. Make arrangements to obtain consent to record if this is mandated by the DPA, Lawful Business Practice and Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, for your specific intended purpose. (Your own legal advisor can provide further guidance here.)

6. Arrange to delete recordings when they are no longer required to fulfil the intended purpose. For example, the DPA requires that personal data should only be kept long enough to fulfil the purpose for which it is held. Therefore, if recordings are only intended to support quality initiatives that involve weekly training sessions, then it would probably be considered unreasonable to retain such recordings for a year.

7. Provide an unrecorded telephone line for contact centre staff to ensure the right to privacy is respected.

8. Brief employees so that they understand the scope of your call recording and how it can benefit and protect them in the workplace.

The capture of 100% of customer interactions, and the ability to analyse this data to gain valuable insights into customer and agent behaviours, puts call recording at the very heart of a contact centre that is able to perform as a ‘smart centre’, feeding valuable knowledge to the entire enterprise. By taking legal advice and implementing some simple safeguards, all contact centres can benefit from this valuable technology.

Further reading

For specific information regarding current legislation for telephone recording in the UK visit the following pages of the OPSI website:

http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1998/ukpga_19980029_en_1
http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1998/ukpga_19980042_en_1
http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts2000/ukpga_20000023_en_1
http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2000/20002699.htm
 
and

Recording and monitoring telephone calls or e-mails

A general overview of interception, recording and monitoring of communications

The interception, recording and monitoring of telephone calls is governed by a number of different pieces of UK legislation. The requirements of all relevant legislation must be complied with. The main ones are:

* Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 ("RIPA")
* Telecommunications (Lawful Business Practice)(Interception of Communications) Regulations 2000 ("LBP Regulations")
* Data Protection Act 1998
* Telecommunications (Data Protection and Privacy) Regulations 1999
* Human Rights Act 1998

It is not possible to provide comprehensive detail of that legislation here. Any person considering interception, recording or monitoring of telephone calls or e-mails is strongly advised to seek his/her own independent legal advice and should not seek to rely on the general information provided below. It should be borne in mind that criminal offences and civil actions may occur when the relevant legislation is not complied with. Accordingly, Oftel accepts no liability for reliance by any person on the following information.

Can I record telephone conversations on my home phone?

Yes. The relevant law, RIPA, does not prohibit individuals from recording their own communications provided that the recording is for their own use. Recording or monitoring are only prohibited where some of the contents of the communication - which can be a phone conversation or an e-mail - are made available to a third party, ie someone who was neither the caller or sender nor the intended recipient of the original communication. For further information see the Home Office website where RIPA is posted.

Do I have to let people know that I intend to record their telephone conversations with me?

No, provided you are not intending to make the contents of the communication available to a third party. If you are you will need the consent of the person you are recording.

Can a business or other organisation record or monitor my phone calls or e-mail correspondence with them?

Yes they can, but only in a limited set of circumstances relevant for that business which have been defined by the LBP Regulations. The main ones are:

* to provide evidence of a business transaction
* to ensure that a business complies with regulatory procedures
* to see that quality standards or targets are being met in the interests of national security
* to prevent or detect crime to investigate the unauthorised use of a telecom system
* to secure the effective operation of the telecom system.

In addition, businesses can monitor, but not record, phone calls or e-mails that have been received to see whether they are relevant to the business (ie open an employee's voicemail or mailbox systems while they are away to see if there are any business communications stored there). For further information see the DTI website where the LBP Regulations are posted.

However any interception of employees' communications must be proportionate and in accordance with Data Protection principles. The Information Commissioner has published a Data Protection Code on "Monitoring at Work" available on its website here. The Code is designed to help employers comply with the legal requirements of Data Protection Act 1988. Any enforcement action would be based on a failure to meet the requirements of the act - however relevant parts of the Code are likely to be cited in connection with any enforcement action relating to the processing of personal information in the employment context. Accordingly this Code of Practice and the Data Protection Act must also be considered by any business before it intercepts employees' communications.

Do businesses have to tell me if they are going to record or monitor my phone calls or e-mails?

No. as long as the recording or monitoring is done for one of the above purposes the only obligation on businesses is to inform their own employees. If businesses want to record for any other purpose, such as market research, they will have to obtain your consent.

What do I do if my calls have been recorded unlawfully?

Under RIPA it is a tort to record or monitor a communication unlawfully. This means that if you think you have suffered from unlawful interception of your phone calls or e-mails you have the right to seek redress by taking civil action against the offender in the courts.
 
Does this mean that when the automated machine tells you your call may be recorded you can reply back to the machine that it too may be recorded and then be legitimately able to use the recording in law... :p
 
Back
Top Bottom