I join the 300bhp club next week.

Actually, yes.

I don't dispute that a RWD car will put the power down better, I simply dispute people who say that 300BHP can't be put down via the front wheels.

Isn't it widely known in the motoring industry that about the only FWD car that does it with any real ability is the new Focus RS? Due to the design of FWD in general and suspension too.
 
It depends what you want from a car. If where you want your speed is from 50mph onwards on a straight road, for overtaking or straight line work then fair enough I suppose but I am not aware of any FWD car with that sort of horses that doesn't pull and tug like a beyatch in the corners and the best ones have well sorted front ends which I suspect the VXR doesn't.

Each to their own, but if it's a B car why not try something proper like an Elise?
 
Really? I've driven a 300BHP Focus ST and VXR with an LSD and it handles the power just fine. Just for the record I do have uprated Alcon brakes, RARB and DAP-R springs so I have no worry in my mind that the car won't take 300+bhp.
 
Widely known? By who? You'll often hear of motoring journalists complaining about powerful FWD cars because they expect to be able to mash the "go faster" pedal to the floor and everything to be ok.

This is the same "motoring industry" that thinks torque steer is a real problem - because everyone plants that same "go faster" pedal with their hands off the wheel.

That said, I personally didn't like the Astra with 240BHP, but that wasn't all power related.

It depends what you want from a car. If where you want your speed is from 50mph onwards on a straight road, for overtaking or straight line work then fair enough I suppose

As I've already stated, I can plant the throttle in second from about 10-15 MPH without any wheelspin as long as the road is dry. Where do you get this 50MPH figure from?

I also know how to control throttle and traction exiting a corner, powerful FWD cars are not a problem for me.
 
Last edited:
You've driven in his car and experienced how it drives have you? It will be a damn sight more fun than your car, not to mention quicker. I love the amount of people that put down any FWD car that has more than XXX bhp just because in their little minds on paper it does not compute. Oh no it will understeer and drive horribly. I've driven a FWD car with 300bhp on tap and it was absolutely awesome. Open your mind haters.

May i ask what car you drove with 300bhp? And in what environment?

I don't understand how you can deny that large amounts of power through the front wheels creates understeer, torque steer and compromises the drive?

The new Focus RS, which i would say features the latest technology designed to harness lots of power going through the front wheels, still has problems with torque steer etc. That's even after all the efforts Ford have gone through with designing new suspension and tweaking it.

My point is 300bhp in a FWD car specifically designed to have 300bhp still creates problems.

300bhp through a car not designed to have 300bhp is just going to be.....worse?

I've got an Integra DC5 with about 230bhp and an LSD and tbh i don't think i'd want any more power in a FF car, its crazy enough as it is in the wet.

OMGZ OPENZ YOUR MIND YU HATER!

Whats his car got to do with it?

Seems like a cheap insult towards someone who has a (very valid) opinion.
 
Really? I've driven a 300BHP Focus ST and VXR with an LSD and it handles the power just fine. Just for the record I do have uprated Alcon brakes, RARB and DAP-R springs so I have no worry in my mind that the car won't take 300+bhp.

I can't speak from huge experience on this one, but the power will and does corrupt the steering on the new Focus RS. Of course it depends if that is an issue to you or not and I don't think for a minute it makes them undriveable though I do suspect it makes them more compromised.
 
I can see the "Buy something else" brigades point of view, it sounds logical..

I can also see why someone may wish to mod their existing car to this level..

Each to their own.. I doubt that the OP is hung up on how well it might do against a RWD car on track or how it might suffer on the absolute limit down a b-road, it may just be that having 300BHP in more normal settings, i.e. overtaking down A-Roads etc and just the sheer acceleration warrant it..

My brother had a VXR Zaf with the Stage 2 (280-285bHP) and an E39 M5 (440BHP with some mods) for quite a while, and I'm sure you can't think of a worse car then a Zafira for putting loads of power into, however, in many ways he preferred the Zaf, mainly for the fact being FWD it was far easier to drive on the limit then the M5 which either over-nannies you with DSC if you leave it on, or would spit it's dummy out at the merest hint of provocation if you switch it off.. When you are 'racing' down a b-road, you are only going to 'win' if your both your car is up to the job and you can actually confidently exploit the cars limit..

I sometimes think people get their jollies from just knowing their car is the 'best' , not from actually hooning around ;)
 
I guess thats some of the appeal of a 300bhp hot hatch is the unruliness of it. But as some people have said earlier in the thread, sure the VXR wasn't designed with 300bhp in mind but I am making the upgrades to help that fact.
 
The new Focus RS, which i would say features the latest technology designed to harness lots of power going through the front wheels, still has problems with torque steer etc. That's even after all the efforts Ford have gone through with designing new suspension and tweaking it.

The only problem with torque steer is the people who consider it to be a problem.

In modern cars it isn't like you need to be a body-builder to stop it careering into the nearest tree/ditch/house. I do have distinct memories of driving a 200BHP+ Fiesta RS which was a handful.

I sometimes think people get their jollies from just knowing their car is the 'best' , not from actually hooning around ;)

Well said :)
 
My brother had a VXR Zaf with the Stage 2 (280-285bHP) and an E39 M5 (440BHP with some mods) for quite a while, and I'm sure you can't think of a worse car then a Zafira for putting loads of power into, however, in many ways he preferred the Zaf, mainly for the fact being FWD it was far easier to drive on the limit then the M5 which either over-nannies you with DSC if you leave it on, or would spit it's dummy out at the merest hint of provocation if you switch it off.. When you are 'racing' down a b-road, you are only going to 'win' if your both your car is up to the job and you can actually confidently exploit the cars limit..

OT - the Zafira VXR is so much better than i thought it would be. Fair enough it has a driving position of a bus (literally), but the handling and grip was much better than i expected. I would even go as far to say it was quite "fun"!
 
Actually, yes.

I don't dispute that a RWD car will put the power down better, I simply dispute people who say that 300BHP can't be put down via the front wheels.
But what is the standard? Today almost every single group of mainstream cars is capable of being driven in a way that allows you to apply large amounts of power without fear of wheelspin. You can drive a 1.6 Fiesta, a 2.0 Insignia, a BMW 330 or an Audi RS4 at near full tilt, and unless you're absolutely mental, you won't be wheelspinning. The cars have been designed to handle their power well.

The only group of cars where this isn't the case is in the current crop of turbocharged high-torque high-power FWD hatches. Driving these cars just isn't the same experience. You have to be constantly aware that your right foot is going to spin the tyres in to a frenzy if you squeeze it.

The fact that there is a problem with these high-powered FWD vehicles is evidenced by the development and investment being made to counter torque steer with LSDs, RevoKnuckle etc.

I'm not arguing that you can't drive a 300 hp Astra VXR without crashing, but they just don't drive like "normal" cars.
The only problem with torque steer is the people who consider it to be a problem.
Have you not thought whether the minority of people who don't consider it a problem.. could be mistaken?
 
Last edited:
Widely known? By who? You'll often hear of motoring journalists complaining about powerful FWD cars because they expect to be able to mash the "go faster" pedal to the floor and everything to be ok.

This is the same "motoring industry" that thinks torque steer is a real problem - because everyone plants that same "go faster" pedal with their hands off the wheel.

That said, I personally didn't like the Astra with 240BHP, but that wasn't all power related.

Hence posing it as a question not a statement. ;)

Torque steer is a problem in cars though when you slam the throttle to the floor, hand on the wheel or not, but it does mean you just don't do it, which is a bit pants really as you can't use the car to it's full potential.
 
I don't quite understand the whole powerful hot hatch FWD thing. As a daily driver they can't be very comfortable and need attention to drive, but as a second car you've thrown £15k+ at it and you could have bought something much more fun and quicker for the same money?!

Hot hatches should just be left alone if you ask me. They're improved by the manufacturer for people who need comfort, space and practicality but also want a bit more grunt, so why try to turn a perfectly set up vehicle into an underachieving performance car?

I had some rude boy in an Astra VXR try to outdo me when I first bought my 220 Turbo. He had Courtney stickers plastered all over it and it made a loud noise...but he soon realised he'd wasted his money.

Silly silly silly. Sell it and go RWD if you want something quick and enjoyable at the weekend.
 
As a daily driver its fine as the map can be switched off with the sport button so you can pootle along at the pace of a normal 2.0 Astra.
 
But what is the standard? Today almost every single group of mainstream cars is capable of being driven in a way that allows you to apply large amounts of power without fear of wheelspin. You can drive a 1.6 Fiesta, a 2.0 Insignia, a BMW 330 or an Audi RS4 at near full tilt, and unless you're absolutely mental, you won't be wheelspinning. The cars have been designed to handle their power well.

The only group of cars where this isn't the case is in the current crop of turbocharged high-torque high-power FWD hatches. Driving these cars just isn't the same experience. You have to be constantly aware that your right foot is going to spin the tyres in to a frenzy if you squeeze it.

The fact that there is a problem with these high-powered FWD vehicles is evidenced by the development and investment being made to counter torque steer with LSDs, RevoKnuckle etc.

I'm not arguing that you can't drive a 300 hp Astra VXR without crashing, but they just don't drive like "normal" cars.

Have you not thought whether the minority of people who don't consider it a problem.. could be mistaken?

I see your point, but disagree - there are so many tuned "good" cars out there that cannot be simply floored the moment you pass the apex.

I'm not mistaken, torque steer, at least on my ST, and also true for my old Corsa VXR, is not a problem, it doesn't restrict how I drive, but as long as I'm aware of it, and can counter it, its ok. RWD has its own characteristics that are a problem for some people too, but, many people (myself included) would argue that as long as you understand those characteristics, and know how to use/correct them, then they become a non-issue.

Hence posing it as a question not a statement. ;)

Torque steer is a problem in cars though when you slam the throttle to the floor, hand on the wheel or not, but it does mean you just don't do it, which is a bit pants really as you can't use the car to it's full potential.

I can floor my car with 325lbft through the front wheels, and easily counter what little torque steer there is - so easy in fact, that I don't even think about doing it anymore, its just natural.

Like I say, with "equal length" driveshafts, and various chassis/bushing/arb/suspension improvements over the years, torque steer isn't a huge issue any more. a 200BHP FRST was a problem, a 275BHP Focus ST is not.

I don't quite understand the whole powerful hot hatch FWD thing. As a daily driver they can't be very comfortable and need attention to drive, but as a second car you've thrown £15k+ at it and you could have bought something much more fun and quicker for the same money?!

Hot hatches should just be left alone if you ask me. They're improved by the manufacturer for people who need comfort, space and practicality but also want a bit more grunt, so why try to turn a perfectly set up vehicle into an underachieving performance car?

I had some rude boy in an Astra VXR try to outdo me when I first bought my 220 Turbo. He had Courtney stickers plastered all over it and it made a loud noise...but he soon realised he'd wasted his money.

Silly silly silly. Sell it and go RWD if you want something quick and enjoyable at the weekend.


When pootling along as a daily driver, I never exceed 3000RPM, the car doesn't feel much, if any different - no extra attention is needed, and it feels like I'm driving a Focus. Hell, my girlfriend can drive it regularly without issue, and she's used to a 1.0 Yaris.

As for the Astra VXR, how do you know he was trying to outdo you? Maybe he just wanted some fun - I'll quite often try it on against cars I know that are faster than me, because I'm curious/up for a laugh, and I don't really care who wins, because I already know I have a small penis (albeit big enough to fill a pram ;) )
 
Last edited:
I'm in it which is nice, except it should be in the 400bhp club.

MORE POWER!!11

morepower.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom