Regardless of whether it was cleared up in Cleggs favour or not, just by having the story in the papers gives people doubt over his honesty. It's all mind games.
Yes but what makes it a dirty trick? They all "smear" each other, theres nothing dirty about it, and they didn't know it would be cleared up because the details weren't obvious only that he was receiving payments into his bank account which does look decided dodgey.
AS said though where does the quote come from, the information was obtained from his expense reports, the quote is smearing Cameron by saying he got together to give them a story....... they already had but weren't looking into.
Is it not more likely, as several people suggested in Have I got news for you last night, that simply before the first debate no one was really digging into Clegg because the papers didn't give a crap, then after he suddenly emerged as a real possibility reporters all over the country were suddenly digging into everything he said.
The point is, theres no proof AT ALL, that its a Tory "smear" or "dirty tactics" campaign. Even if they did let the press know about the payments, I still fail to see anything dirty about it, and a quote with no source trying to smear the tories with accusations of dirty tactics, seems like the exact same level of "smearing" as what the tories are accused of.
Infact the only link in the OP goes to a page where they are suggesting Mandelson of smearing the Tories by trying to put the blame at their feet for the whole thing.
Theres dirty tactics, smearing, and just plain old news and things that SHOULD be looked into.
If Clegg was guilty of taking party money for himself rather than using his account to pay several people, it wouldn't be seen as smearing, or dirty, but uncovering Clegg's secret's and would be fine. NO matter the outcome, giving the press some info to look into just isn't a dirty tactic and as my original question asked, what about it makes it dirty tactics? A conversation with press people, thats not proven to have taken place? All three candidates talk with reporters, press, editors all day long, who cares.