• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

From GTX 280 to HD5850

Associate
Joined
29 Sep 2006
Posts
2,164
Location
West Yorks
A friend is selling his HD5850 and has given me first refusal.

I mainly play BFBC2, will I see a big enough increase in FPS.

My GTX280 is overclocked and plan to overclock the 5850 too.

I just don't want to upgrade to find I will only gain 5-10 fps.

.... and I game at 1680 x 1050.
 
Last edited:
If you plan on overclocking then yes, it's worth the upgrade, you can easily get HD5870 performance out of an overclocked HD5850 and a bit extra too.
 
How much is the question? It's not a massive upgrade in terms of absolute performance, but as said, noticeable if you overclock. You could also get good money for the 280 on an auction site.
 
Personally I don't think you'll see worlds of difference at stock settings. They do tend to overclock very well though.

This is my worry, now my 280 is overclocked so if i over clock the HD5850 as well...

If you plan on overclocking then yes, it's worth the upgrade, you can easily get HD5870 performance out of an overclocked HD5850 and a bit extra too.

All gfx cards overclock, by how much is the question. Does it overclock enough for me to see a noticable difference with my current card?

How much is the question? It's not a massive upgrade in terms of absolute performance, but as said, noticeable if you overclock. You could also get good money for the 280 on an auction site.

I reakon I could get £140 for MY GTX280 and I am probably looking at £180 for the HD5850 so thats £40 for the upgrade.

Its a close friend so I don't need to worry about warranty (warranty on electrical items isn't transferable) and his is a warranty relpacement which is still in the selophane.
 
Its worth £50 as upgrade just as it runs cooler and quiter, i went from a GTX280 to 5870 and real world diff nothing....benches and fraps tell a different story but i dont watch the fps meter all the time im playing lol
 
I mean, you may find it smoother and does give higher fps but it's a case of whether you'll notice it or not. I expect the odd game will be noticeably better. However, some folk have overclocked them very, very highly above stock and this could make all the difference.

Perhaps someone who has made a similar jump in upgrades will give their opinion.
 
Its worth £50 as upgrade just as it runs cooler and quiter, i went from a GTX280 to 5870 and real world diff nothing....benches and fraps tell a different story but i dont watch the fps meter all the time im playing lol

Due to the poor airflow in my case I leave the side off, maybe with the HD5850 I can put it back and reduce the overall noise to my system.


Perhaps someone who has made a similar jump in upgrades will give their opinion.

Thats not a bad idea, I only want the difference in BFBC2 though as thats all I have been playing since release. :)
 
Due to the poor airflow in my case I leave the side off, maybe with the HD5850 I can put it back and reduce the overall noise to my system.




Thats not a bad idea :)

most deffo mate, my game load temps on to gtx were 85c the single 5870 was 73c so less heat and noise worth £50 IMO
Like i said i did it and dont regreat it just as long as you realise you will notice very little diff with a naked eye playing your games :D
 
ummm, I was thinking about grabbing a 5850 next but this thread is making me rethink that, I have a gtx260 and recently owned a gtx280 and to my eyes there was practically hardly any difference in performance so I'm wondering if I'm going to notice a big difference jumping from the gtx260 to a 5850, I've recently upgraded my cpu to a Q9550 and hardly saw any different so want to try the gpu route, I mainly want to (try) and get crysis upto a playable speed, I guess that because I'm running at a higher res than the original poster I may notice a bugger jump?
 
Last edited:
ummm, I was thinking about grabbing a 5850 next but this thread is making me rethink that, I have a gtx260 and recently owned a gtx280 and to my eyes there was practically hardly any difference in performance so I'm wondering if I'm going to notice a big difference jumping from the gtx260 to a 5850, I've recently upgraded my cpu to a Q9550 and hardly saw any different so want to try the gpu route, I mainly want to (try) and get crysis upto a playable speed.

My advise is hold your money the next ati refesh is not that far away m8 and the gtx260 & gtx280 are very capable cards
 
All gfx cards overclock, by how much is the question. Does it overclock enough for me to see a noticable difference with my current card?

Yes.

Its worth £50 as upgrade just as it runs cooler and quiter, i went from a GTX280 to 5870 and real world diff nothing....benches and fraps tell a different story but i dont watch the fps meter all the time im playing lol

Went from GTX280 to HD5870 myself and your talking nonsense.

HD5870 is more comparable to a GTX295 than a GTX280.
 
Last edited:
Yes.

Went from GTX280 to HD5870 myself and your talking nonsense.

HD5870 is more comparable to a GTX295 than a GTX280.

If you have a something to say please feel free to do without saying some else is talking rubbish. If you disagree with something try do it in a civil manner please ,you are entitled to your own views as am i!
Sorry for the derail OP, back in track :D
 
Peoples' experiences will vary so the difference detected for one might be very different for others. It's a subjective thing. I have seen people express how pleased they were, with what seemed on paper, just a minor upgrade. Sometimes, and surprisingly, the reverse is noted. Where I might expect to see a greater level of satisfaction for the user, instead the result is bit lacking in certain areas. Maybe even slightly disappointing.
 
Last edited:
I went from a heavily overclocked GTX260 to a 5850 and noticed no difference. That was back in Novemember though, when we were lacking tasty DX11 titles such as Metrosexual 2033.
 
Last edited:
Even so, I think that upgrades from one years round of gfx cards to the next rarely gives much absolute performance increase nowadays, when considering similarly priced models, certainly not a dramatic increase to justify how expensive they are. As such, going from a nvidia GTX2XX (excluding 210 etc - 260 or above) to any new card (radeon 5xxx) seems like mostly a waste of time unless you've got a GTX260 192 and are going to 5970 or similar. Then you'd notice an increase in performance, but almost all today's games are still perfectly playable on med/high settings with the last generation of cards. I think it may take until the 5xxx refresh (5890 anyone?) or even the Fermi refresh to look spending some serious cash upgrading. Of course, that depends on the demands of the new games that come out too, and if you play them! If you're still playing source games only there's little benefit from an 8800GT to be fair, they're still very playable indeed. Changing to a larger monitor may create a need, but it also depends on how much cash you can afford to throw at keeping your rig up to date. Personally, I think the gfx market needs to move in a new, more productive direction, like the CPU market has moved to more cores instead of absolute speed.
 
Peoples' experiences will vary so the difference detected for one might be very different for others. It's a subjective thing. I have seen people express how pleased they were, with what seemed on paper, just a minor upgrade. Sometimes, and surprisingly, the reverse is noted. Where I might expect to see a greater level of satisfaction for the user, instead the result is bit lacking in certain areas. Maybe even slightly disappointing.

This isn't about what users experience differently, all you have to do is read some reviews, but of course according BigBruiserAl there not representative of performance, but I guess that's to be expected as it must be really inconvenient when reviews tell you your wrong.
 
My take on this is 'if you can afford the upgrade do it ' but the upgrades are becoming less and less but i will always upgrade if i can.

I went from a gtx275 to a hd5850 and it is a bit better/sharper and i was a sucker for dx11 & if you wait too long you wont get much for an old tech card
 
Back
Top Bottom