Which car would you choose?

[MiNxYyY]

Which of these cars would be your choice given a budget?

Audi A3 1.9TDI 05 - 59000M £3500

MG TF 03 1.6 - 45000M £2950

MAZDA MX-5 1.6i 2dr Convertible - 56000M £ 3900

2005 VOLKSWAGEN GOLF 1.9 S TDI 5dr Diesel - 100000M £4000

Out of these 4 card, which would be the best choice?

 

[Janesy B]

Depends if you want a convertible or a diesel hatchback?

 

[MiNxYyY]

I would like a convertible for the summer, but during the winter i would prefer a hatchback.

Just dont want to be stuck with one car and make the wrong choice.

 

[Participant]

A Golf with the same engine and manufacturing year yet almost twice the mileage as the Audi, for an extra £500...bargain, I'd get that .

If picking only one, of those, the Audi...but then my colleague's MX-5 is a nightmare in the winter.

 

[Aero]

A3 although I would get the mazda if it was a 1.8

 

[ganesh]

Mx5 and buy a hard top for it.

 

[MiNxYyY]

Hmm..

The 1.8 MX-5 jumps from £3900 to £4995

 

[Aero]

Hmm..

The 1.8 MX-5 jumps from £3900 to £4995

Are you looking at mk 2.5's?

 

[MiNxYyY]

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...da/page/6/postcode/b976nw/radius/30?logcode=p

 

[Aero]

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...da/page/6/postcode/b976nw/radius/30?logcode=p

mk2.5 looks nice but would be interested to see what other mod they have done as iirc they didn't come with a front strut brace as standard. Also thats a high premium over a mk2

 

[ryanpetit]

MX5

 

[Matt82]

mx5. wouldnt want the diesels

 

[mysticsniper]

Persoanlly I would go for the Audi

 

[Firestar_3x]

Audi A3 1.9TDI 05 - 59000M £3500

I'm confused how you get a 2005 A3 for £3500?

 

[[TW]Fox]

What an odd thread. Totally different cars most of which are so cheap they must be nicked or something.

What about a Transit or an S type Jaguar?

 

[MiNxYyY]

I'm confused how you get a 2005 A3 for £3500?

Just looking through ebay, seen a few for just under the £4k mark.

 

[[TW]Fox]

Just looking through ebay, seen a few for just under the £4k mark.

You have a lot to learn it seems, you won't get one worth buying for under 4k!

 

[mjt]

Depends on the output of the A3/Golf.
And also whether you want a diesel hatch back or a convertible.

 

[MiNxYyY]

You have a lot to learn it seems, you won't get one worth buying for under 4k!

I know the car wont be perfect, far from it i know, but im just the average worker with a not so good wage and on a budget

 

[Participant]

I know the car wont be perfect, far from it i know, but im just the average worker with a not so good wage and on a budget

You can't afford to buy a crashed A3 then .