What's your degree in? Harry Potter? Uh ..?

Caporegime
Joined
29 Aug 2007
Posts
28,767
Location
Auckland
So it seems that Durham University will be offering Harry Potter studies as part of it's BA Education Studies course.

Really? Durham University? The one with the pretty good reputation? Seriously? I don't know what Education Studies is supposed to cover - it sounds a bit Mickey Mouse for my tastes - but what are they thinking of? What's next? A BA in Vampire Studies?

:mad:
 
[FnG]magnolia;17191782 said:
So it seems that Durham University will be offering Harry Potter studies as part of its BA Education Studies course.

Really? Durham University? The one with the pretty good reputation? Seriously? I don't know what Education Studies is supposed to cover - it sounds a bit Mickey Mouse for my tastes - but what are they thinking of? What's next? A BA in Vampire Studies?

:mad:

:D
 
They need to do a BA in Chuck Norris.

(No wait that would never happen. You don't study Chuck Norris, he studies YOU)
 
Last edited:
Its things like this that have devalued real degrees.

Do you actually know what the module is built around or are you just jumping the gun? It's a name for a module, that's all. What's at the heart of the module is what counts, and from reading around I gather it's a module designed to help understand contemporary society (something which in an Educational Studies degree is actually quite relevent). They're not going to have questions on the exam paper such as "How old was Harry when he got his wand touched?" or "How many rooms are there in Hogswart?"

It's a module using Harry Potter as a case-study and a window into the real world. Off the top of my head, they could for example be looking at and discussing why exactly the story is so universal and popular, which could include looking at psychology, collective culture and shared history. It could also be looking at universal aspects of all storytelling, etc. Then of course, we could also be looking at how the story was sold and marketed to the world and how exactly the world reacted to such dissemination. It in turn could then turn to look at the unanticipated fantasy tourism it's created and the new economies as a result. There's a lot of genuine complex issues and processes which can be explored.

Just because the module's got a stupid name, does not mean it's banal. It's a fancy name to grab cheap attention. An institution such as Durham is not going to have a module or a whole degree devoted to the ins and outs of the story of Harry Potter. It's easy marketing, that is all.
 
Isn't marketing supposed to make people want to go rather than put them off, thinking "this is a really crappy uni for offering a degree in harry potter" etc.?

You're looking at it from a cynical adult's point of view. The marketing isn't aimed at you, it's aimed at the young and those who absolutely love Harry Potter. Indeed, it'll probably be seen as somewhat of a novelty as part of the course and hence popular from that. If it is aimed at the cynical adult, it is for the very same reason this thread exists and everyone's clicking their tongues and shaking their heads. With all the potential institutions out there, this one suddenly jumps to the fore through novelty.

If the module isn't banal and is infact useful to the course, is there any point in lambasting it? Nothing is permanent, that's just an illusion we trick ourselves with. Courses, education and the people undertaking it will forever be evolving. To expect higher education to forever remain static is naive at best, and at worst a foolish attempt at tradition worship.

Now, as for wether I'd personally do the module? No. I don't believe in any attention being good attention. It's bad press whatever spin we can try to put on it. I think it would've had more luck by naming the module something less gimmick such as 'Understanding Contemporary Society through Mass-Media' or something similar and also throwing in other cultural phenomena; Twilight would be an interesting one for example. We all hate it, but there are reasons why it's got so big. That is another good window into contemporary society. The module and course would then avoid such vitriol and even have an aura of legitimacy.
 
Do you actually know what the module is built around or are you just jumping the gun? It's a name for a module, that's all. What's at the heart of the module is what counts, and from reading around I gather it's a module designed to help understand contemporary society (something which in an Educational Studies degree is actually quite relevent). They're not going to have questions on the exam paper such as "How old was Harry when he got his wand touched?" or "How many rooms are there in Hogswart?"

It's a module using Harry Potter as a case-study and a window into the real world. Off the top of my head, they could for example be looking at and discussing why exactly the story is so universal and popular, which could include looking at psychology, collective culture and shared history. It could also be looking at universal aspects of all storytelling, etc. Then of course, we could also be looking at how the story was sold and marketed to the world and how exactly the world reacted to such dissemination. It in turn could then turn to look at the unanticipated fantasy tourism it's created and the new economies as a result. There's a lot of genuine complex issues and processes which can be explored.

Just because the module's got a stupid name, does not mean it's banal. It's a fancy name to grab cheap attention. An institution such as Durham is not going to have a module or a whole degree devoted to the ins and outs of the story of Harry Potter. It's easy marketing, that is all.

Well put. Refreshing to read a considered viewpoint, instead of comments from bandwagon-jumping folk who are eating up the cheap sensationalist headlines.

As for the subject matter, they have left themselves open to ridicule by naming the module as they did. But presuming it to be worthless (and to make the entire degree worthless) only shows a lack of understanding.

"OMG a degree in David Beckham! Burn the Sky!"
 
Last edited:
You're looking at it from a cynical adult's point of view. The marketing isn't aimed at you, it's aimed at the young and those who absolutely love Harry Potter.

I'm a university student myself, the exact age range of people that they are trying to entice.
 
I'm a university student myself, the exact age range of people that they are trying to entice.

But you're not studying Educational Studies are you? Again, please re-read what I wrote above, as your perspective still isn't the same as a naive young person or Potter fanatic. You're approaching it as a cynic. The closest you would ever come to doing said module would be to enterain a curiosity of an novelty. The name of the module has done it a disservice, I'm not disputing that.
 
Extensive parts of Hogwarts Castle we're filmed in Durham Cathedral. Perhaps they wanted to use the link with the Harry Potter brand name to market a course on Modern Literature.
 
I grew up in Durham and locally the students have a terrible rep for being snobby, up themselves, public school toffs...

While this stereotype is far from being 100% accurate they do seem to have more than their fair share of annoying dicks.

Stuff like this is going to give the locals hours of fun mocking the student populace.
 
Back
Top Bottom