Achilleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees
Well, I thought of putting him in too, But you only have to kick the guy in the ankle and he goes down!
For me I think, although he's badass in the movie, King Leonadis wouldn't be as great without his soldiers beside him. Spartans fight best as a unit.
it's a close one between Spartacus and Maximus, They have similar backgrounds, Both Leaders taken into slavery and made to fight for freedom.
Thracians were more savage fighters, or atleast they were seen as such from the Romans point of view, where as Maximus was a trained strategic Roman soldier.
1 was fighting to free Rome, the other was fighting for love.
I'm going to give it to Maximus (oo err) Reason being, His training. To be a general, He'll have trained most his young life. Where as spartacus only began training once he was captured ( he could fight, Just not with much sense, it was instinctual )