• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

3D Gaming hazardous to health?

Soldato
Joined
8 Aug 2010
Posts
6,453
Location
Oxfordshire
Nintendo unveils 3DS and quickly follows-up with a statement about dangers to children under 7 playing with the company’s new portable gamer. Samsung releases a line of 3D HDTVs then issues a warning about its potential health risk to certain viewers. What they haven’t told you is that these warnings come after years of industry spin and cover ups. The truth is that prolonged viewing of 3D video may be even more harmful than the consumer electronics industry wants you to know.

Before you bring a 3D HDTV into your house or let a child under seven play with a brand new Nintendo 3DS, you need to understand the fragile development of an aspect of human vision called stereopsis.

Stereopsis: Hunter See, Hunter do
Stereopsis, a result of the frontal placement of our eyes, is the process in visual perception that lets us see depth. Two slightly different projections of the world enter our retinas, which causes us to see in real-3D. Stereopsis made us humans into mighty hunters of prey, builders of civilization and crackers-open of the occasional bottle of beer – but this important process is being tricked every time we watch a 3D movie.

Stereoscopic vision begins developing when we first start using our eyes and is generally considered complete by the time we’re around six years old. That’s when the tiny nerves and muscles behind the eye are fully formed and have learned to work in conjunction with the brain to respond automatically to visual cues that provide seamless depth of vision.

Unfortunately there’s a malaise in children that can prevent full stereopsis from developing, called strabismus. This condition is also called lazy-eye but has nothing to do with laziness; it’s an abnormal alignment of the eyes in which the eyes don’t focus on the same object and depth perception is compromised.

There is treatment for strabismus that involves helping a child’s nervous system to learn stereopsis, causing it to eventually become a natural response. But the ability to re-learn has its limitations, and treatment has been met with limited success beyond a certain age.

In the 1960s, Nobel Prize winning research by Drs. Hubel and Weisel came up with a critical period during which the optic nerves learn stereopsis – the time up to 7 years old. Doctors thereafter used this critical period as the point-of-no-return for treatment of lazy eye. The old way of thinking was that lazy eye can’t be treated after 7 years old.

However, recent medical science indicates that the nervous system never stops learning and re-learning. Doctors today will tell you it’s never too late to try to treat strabismus – or re-teach the optic nerves the trick of binocular vision. The chances of success may be diminished beyond seven, but there’s still a chance.

So, if it’s never too late for the optic nerves to learn correct vision, one can surmise that it’s also never too late to learn bad habits that could create visual problems.

“You Cannot Give This To Kids!”
Pesce says that Sega took the test results and buried them. Fearing lawsuits and consumer backlash over health risks, the VR Headset never made it to market and neither did the truth about the dangers of prolonged exposure to 3D virtual environments - until now.

The results of SRI’s research have been published and there is an unclassified document from the defense department of Australia that says there are a variety of “…unintended psychophysiological side effects of participation in (3D) virtual environments.”

VR Headsets disappeared amid vague rumors of headaches and poor implementation of a technology just wasn’t ready. The Consumer Electronics industry was content to leave it at that and wait for a new implementation of the same visual effects. Now, virtual reality is back but instead of a headset, the same visual effect is being sold through LCD monitors and glasses.

http://www.audioholics.com/news/editorials/warning-3d-video-hazardous-to-your-health/
 
I would assume, without reading the article, that it's about tricking the eyes into seeing different depths at an identical vantage point. For example. You're focusing on a monitor 50cm infront of you, and the pixels will ALWAYS be 50cm infront of you, yet your mind is given two images to create an illusion of depth.

The danger comes from the monitor firing out multiple levels of depth whilst remaining still with your eyes focused.

Just my guess.. I have 3d vision and think it's great fun. I have no negative side effects. Don't wear glasses. Pretty good vision overall.
 
SO what does 3d gaming/viewing do to affect your eyes in a negative way?

Judging by the article kids under 7yrs old are at risk from under-developed perception of depth with prolonged use, kind of like how dogs are only supposed to be able to see in 2D (unless that's a myth).

I wouldn't think teens/adults would have a problem unless they wear one 24/7.
 
Last edited:
SO what does 3d gaming/viewing do to affect your eyes in a negative way?

Affects childrens developement, which may mean they suffer from this.

Strabismus.jpg


For Adults:
"When you take off the 3D glasses, Pesce says, “…it takes time to get your land legs back”. During that lag period where you’re re-learning binocular vision, your depth perception is compromised and you may lack the visual acuity required to perform tasks, such as driving."

&

"However, recent medical science indicates that the nervous system never stops learning and re-learning. Doctors today will tell you it’s never too late to try to treat strabismus – or re-teach the optic nerves the trick of binocular vision. The chances of success may be diminished beyond seven, but there’s still a chance.

So, if it’s never too late for the optic nerves to learn correct vision, one can surmise that it’s also never too late to learn bad habits that could create visual problems."

So in theory adults are much more resistant to Strabismus, but can still suffer similar side effects if exposed for long periods of time.
 
3D is a gimmic especially on a 22inc monitor.

Headache, bad fps, expensive? Nah no thank u! Give me a good surround vision system anyday
 
So how many families have bought 3d tv's with children under 7?

Of the 19 reported sales of 3D TVs, 2 families might be affected. :p




No-one has bought a 3D TV! Most people I have talked to (outside of OcUK, so less techie people) think it's fine, but wouldn't rush out and buy a 3D TV, especially considering the cost...
 
Anything in excess is bad for your health.

Its the same with gaming, regardless of whether its 3D or not.

The tricky part is deciding what is "excess".

Even back to the days of the SNES, the manual clearly stated that you should take a 15 minute break from gaming after every 1 hour of gaming.
 
I think the top and bottom of this is we just aren't built to view objects at different range simultaneously.

If you take an item just out side your focused field of vision its blurred, look at it, and it and you see more detail, but it takes time for your eyes to adjust and fully resolve image. 3D pritty much means your eyes in this stage of limbo, they are stuck permanently adjusting and trying to resolve the images and that cant be good for you.
 
Of the 19 reported sales of 3D TVs, 2 families might be affected. :p




No-one has bought a 3D TV! Most people I have talked to (outside of OcUK, so less techie people) think it's fine, but wouldn't rush out and buy a 3D TV, especially considering the cost...

My boss has one and a 7 year son.
 
Back
Top Bottom