dodgy car - what to do?

other than being clocked is there anything actually wrong with the car? Guessing service history is lacking also?

hi there. i bought a car from you last week
yes i remember. we agreed a price and you were perfectly happy with the car. you paid for it and took it away
thats the one. well since then i have found out that the six digits displayed on the odo are not correct
oh. i didnt know anything about that
well, those six digits are not correct, i no longer like the car and i want to return it and i want my money back
so you were perfectly happy with the car, you now beleive the six digits to be incorrect, and so you want me to give you your money back
yes, i dont like the car anymore despite there being no difference other beleiving the six digits are not correct

its a pocket money car. its one of the risks. if it was a genuine low mileage minter with every maindealer stamp going then it would have presumably cost you a lot more.
 
If its a car in good condition at this price point then lets be honest, it wont have been that much more expensive with lower mileage.

My question was no different to yours, so not sure why the rest in your post :p
 
Dont buy a car from the side of the road, im guessing thats where you bought it from ? How many times has it been on watchdog and rogue traders and people still do it.
 
[TW]Fox;17823468 said:
There is no such thing as a private trader.

You are either a private seller or a trader.

I think he means he is a trader posing as a private seller, when ever I phone up about a car advertised as private I do the following :

Say ' I'm phoning up about the CAR for sale ' if he asks which one thats a sure sign he is a trader

Ask if the log book has got his name and address on the logbook and how long he has owned the car.

As allready mentioned if the cars basically ok I wouldnt bother taking it back, when you get into the sub £1000 category it's condition more than anything that affects price.
 
Could have had the clocks replaced for any number of legitimate reasons.

And yes, a grand is a lot of money in anyone's books, but it's a small amount of money for a car.

On a sub 1000 quid car, you could double the mileage and not really affect the value
 
If the car he bought is wrongly advertised he is fully within his rights to get his money back. Who gives a crap if it's only £1000?

As already said, ask him, if he refuses then it'll probably have to go to small claims.
 
Is it worth the hassle though? The stress and time of stuff like small claims is worth far more than the 100 quid of difference in value the mileage is likely to make
 
Dont buy a car from the side of the road, im guessing thats where you bought it from ? How many times has it been on watchdog and rogue traders and people still do it.

Where do you recommend one buys a Three figure car from then? A franchised dealer?

Say ' I'm phoning up about the CAR for sale ' if he asks which one thats a sure sign he is a trader

Not really. I've sold two cars at the same time before. I'm not a trader.

I don't quite understand why people put so much weight into this anyway. You can get a second mobile for a tenner - What's stopping a trader having multiple different phones/numbers for multiple different cars? "He answered knowing instantly I was enquiring about the Ford Mondeo, he can't possibly be a trader" :confused:


dal; said:
Ask if the log book has got his name and address on the logbook and how long he has owned the car.

Again, in my book it doesn't tell nearly as much as people tend to think it does - "He's only had it 9 weeks, he must be a trader/it must be a dog". Err, no. Maybe he doesn't like it?

As allready mentioned if the cars basically ok I wouldnt bother taking it back, when you get into the sub £1000 category it's condition more than anything that affects price.

I do agree with this however. As long as the bloke hasn't taken the George Michael and shaved 100k off let it go, perhaps with little more than a "polite" conversation with the seller. Preferably face to face :).
 
If he doesnt respond to that, or that doesnt get you anywhere, local newspapers always like a good 'con man' story.

Good idea, might try that after a few things, this guy needs to be exposed.

Was advised by consumer direct to write a recorded letter to him first asking for refund etc, if that fails (which it will) then will move onto other avenues.

You can tell us the difference surely? :/

the mileage? around 150k or so difference....

Ask for full refund. If he refuses, you'll have to take him to small claims court. You may also wish to inform the police, as what he is doing is criminal

Will contact the cops soon, but not sure if they'll be interested.

How do you know it's definitely clocked? On a car worth less than £1000 I can't see what difference clocking is realistically going to make to it's value anyway.

because the MOT records show it, along with the state of the car, full of stone chips on the bonnet, worn steering, word interior, was probably a cab car. 'Low mileage' on a low priced car will attract buyers and those who dont know an awful lot about cars like my dad will think its bargain, he probably buys these cars from auction for cheap and then sells them for a couple of hundreds more = profit.

Does it work? If so you have done ok for the money.
whats actually wrong with the car?
other than being clocked is there anything actually wrong with the car? Guessing service history is lacking also?

No service history, no past mot paperwork.

Car starts and runs, but clearly has problems at that mileage, tatty bodywork and interior, noisy engine, stiff steering, squealing brakes, clunking noise coming from it, probs bushes, wishbones etc. God knows what else is wrong with it, I had a brief look at the body structure in the afternoon, didnt seem to have any accident damage which is good.

I don't see how mileage is relevant here. As your Dad came away with the car, one can assume he is happy with everything else, so why does it matter?

Regardless of whether the vendor knew it was clocked or not, he can easily plead ignorance.

Also, what legal reasons are there for you not telling us the mileages?

His not happy though, he went and bought the car out of desperation when I broke the news it was a right old lemon, he was devastated, now his stressing which isn't really good at his age and i dont like seeing my father in that state.

There is no way the fraudstar can plead ignorance he makes a living out of doing this. As for the mileage not really legal reasons, but i dont want to give too much away on a public forum, if you get where I am coming from.

I Dont understand when people say 1k is not a lot of money.

In terms of buying a car i guess its not a lot to spend on one but 1k is a lot of money regardless what you spend it on.

The fact he's been sold a car which has been tampered with and sold by a private trader with out this trader doing the relavant checks he should be doing to enable him to sell a car for exactly what it is, the price paid has no relivance of he should just roll over and accept being mis sold a car.

Indeed, it's not just about the money but principles, this guys does this for a living and his conning people out of their money, quite frankly he should be stopped and not allowed to get away with it. Who's to say he won't move onto bigger crimes like stolen cars, crash for cash etc.

The way I read this is that the guy is a private seller but is actually selling cars for profit and money and clocking them back.

I'd be inclined to call the guy and at least ask for some of the money back and to keep the car - if you are happy with the car it's better to try and get it for less due to the clocking.

After all it's gonna be harder to sell in the future.

Yep you got it, he is basically an illegal trader. My guess is he buys the cars from auctions, cheap high mileage cars, he then clocks them, gets rid of any paperwork showing the true mileage and sells on for a profit.

Who's to say he's clocked it, at some point the dials could have failed and someones changed the whole cluster, he's purchased the car not knowing this and not checked the MOT records, hence he doesn't know the car is showing the wrong mileage, you didn't check and now you've been burnt.

Nope it's nothing innocent, he does this for a living i can tell you that as a fact, i've pieced together exactly what he does, i'll give more info in time.

Dont buy a car from the side of the road, im guessing thats where you bought it from ? How many times has it been on watchdog and rogue traders and people still do it.

lol yes he did buy it from some side road! I didn't buy the car, my dad went and bought it against my advice, that type V i posted about a few days ago was miles better!

Say ' I'm phoning up about the CAR for sale ' if he asks which one thats a sure sign he is a trader

Ask if the log book has got his name and address on the logbook and how long he has owned the car.

He doesnt pick up the phones, he could have used a fake name and address, will have to wait and see when the V5 comes back, think his had the car for around a month.

Could have had the clocks replaced for any number of legitimate reasons.

see above.

If the car he bought is wrongly advertised he is fully within his rights to get his money back. Who gives a crap if it's only £1000?

As already said, ask him, if he refuses then it'll probably have to go to small claims.

Aye he falsely advertised the car, i've managed to save his ad's. Will probably try small claims if all else fails.

Is it worth the hassle though? The stress and time of stuff like small claims is worth far more than the 100 quid of difference in value the mileage is likely to make

Will need to look into the whole small claims stuff, but I think it if if everything else fails, if we can get the money back and have the guy prosecuted and stopped from trading then it would be worth it.

Go and pole him in the eye, get it off your chest

I'd like to do more then just that! lol

I do agree with this however. As long as the bloke hasn't taken the George Michael and shaved 100k off let it go, perhaps with little more than a "polite" conversation with the seller. Preferably face to face

Doesn't pick up phone, lives in another city, if he was local, he would be getting more then just a face to face conversation :) Don't think it's safe to go all the way to him either, people like him usually operate in gangs. I have a feeling someone is doing some of the dirty work for him, if only I had access to the MOT of other cars his sold/selling.
 
I think you are now verging on taking this too seriously.

If you are in a position to do it, go and give him a dig if you feel strongly about it, if not wipe your mouth, the police wont be interested.
 
Its not completely uncommon with some vehicles for the odometer to work incorrectly after hitting a certain 6 digit milage so it may or may not be deliberate. I'd be more concerned giving the circumstances tho that it could be stolen or similiar.
 
the mileage? around 150k or so difference....
.

So its a 200k car with 50k on it?

Did it not ring alarm bells when you found an old cheap car with low mileage? I mean seriously, unless you've just bought an immaculate 7 Series how could you not noticed it had 200kish on it?

The problem here is that there is no proof the seller clocked the car.
 
The op is making it sound like the crime of the century, but it really isn't that significant in financial terms. If he's doing it with more expensive cars then I appreciate the desire to see him crash and burn, but it really isn't worth the blood pressure.

Advertise the car for sale with the genuine mileage, say the clocks have been replaced due to a faulty speedo and loose a hundred quid on it. It'll cost you more going down any other route
 
I'd be suprised if it was even him doing it, simply because what is the point? If clocked the car is still so cheap that it isn't even worth 4 figures then where is the profit versus the risk? You'd need to buy really nice condition cars so people didnt notice they were clocked, how many mint condition cars can you get for what, 100-200 quid to make this worth doing!?
 
It's obviously something that will be a peace of mind issue for him, that was the only reason to suggest it
 
I dont know why you even told your dad if you knew it was going to drive him mad, he was happy till that point.
 
It sounds like the bigger issue is that his Dad bought a lemon of a car, not that he bought a clocked car.

Either that or the OP considers it a lemon because of the mileage.
 
Back
Top Bottom