The airline wouldn't pay for the car hire, as far as I know.
So what, I fail to see why it matters. Mooch around the hotel for a bit, get a cab into town, I dunno. That sort of event is so ridiculously rare it isnt even worth thinking about, whatever happened you wouldnt be massively out of pocket.
My travel insurance paid out for the two once in a lifetime events in the past couple of years. Yours didn't. Yours only cost £22, to me that's insurance that doesn't insure.
It's insurance that potentially doesn't insure against natural events based on the words of people on the internet. It depends why you buy insurance - as I keep explaining, a lot of us don't buy travel insurance to cover us against snow or something. A lot of us buy insurance to cover us against the things we genuinelly CANNOT afford to pay for ourselves, therefore cannot afford to take the 'risk'.
ie, medical bills.
I'm glad your insurance 'paid out'. Infact, did it? Did you personally claim for either of those events? If you didnt its a rather moot point, you'd have been in the same financial position with the cheaper insurance
This is what i mean about travel insurance. People insist it has to cover everything. They want volcanoe cover. Wallet loss cover. Iphone cover. Walrus attack cover. Super Massive Ultra Liability cover. Wallaby attack cover. Extreme Ironing in Space cover. Then they pay an absolute fortune for the privilage and never end up claiming anyway.
Most of you live your daily life quite easily without any insurance for the contents of your wallet, or personal liability insurance. Yet when you go shopping for travel insurance you pay a shedload to get cover for that sort of stuff..
Insurance is there to protect you against liability for expenses you cannot afford yourself. People can afford another weeks car hire on a £1k+ holiday to the States. People can afford to drop a wallet because it needn't be full of 'travel money' they've been conned for the exchange rate on at Thomas Cook. People can afford to have the airport shut because the airline will front the costs involved as long as its an EU airline. People CANNOT afford to pay cash for medical bills in some countries, and thats the reason we buy things like travel insurance. Thats what its there for.
All this extra 'cover' is just padding the insurers want you to pay for to increase the profit margin on selling the insurance.
Plus you don't even know the insurers would reject these claims anyway. Seems that on some of those examples you quoted the insurer rejected claims bought after snow had caused choas in the UK - 24th November. Hardly suprising is it, given you can bet your bottom dollar most of those policies were bought as people realised that snow might be a problem...