Is buying gold a good investment?

Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
8,968
Location
UK
Say I had a thousand pounds to spare (I don't currently)

Is that much gold a good investment? Keep it safe for a 2/3 years then think about selling it later, better chance of making money than in an ISA for 2/3 years?

This graph below from moneysavingexpert.com says yes, but if it looks this good why isn't everyone saying 'BUY GOLD BUY GOLD'

gold5yearogbp.png



They might be saying BUY GOLD but perhaps I missed them?
 
I'm also considering this. Harrods do a gold bullion service which I've been reading into a bit. I'll be very interested to hear peoples replies.
 
I strongly advise against it.

Gold is traditionally a safe place which allows you to hold value.

At the moment though it's a great big massive bubble. That graph should explain why it's a bad place to put money.
 
i used to use bullionvault for my gold (not much of it but was nice to have some!)
 
I strongly advise against it.

Gold is traditionally a safe place which allows you to hold value.

At the moment though it's a great big massive bubble. That graph should explain why it's a bad place to put money.

While I agree it probably not the best time to buy, there is no way that it's currently in a bubble, it would have to double before I considered it to be a bubble.

Double bubble...luverlly :D
 
Unless you physically want the gold, you would do better off buying an Exchange Traded Fund linked to gold, so you can buy and sell like shares without the hassle of ownership

I agree with Halk though, I think it's looking like a bubble
 
Nothing but the massive financial criss which the world has been soused in for the last few years.

Hence all of the investment in gold, from what I understand. The financial crisis has done nothing but push the price of gold up.

Perhaps someone else would like to clarify/negate the above point?
 
thepedster - something key to remember is that absolute past performance is not an indication of future performance. Consider the conditions of the past four years that have caused gold to rise in price, and then the other factors that could also cause it to rise, then contrast those with the potential future factors, based on your best predictions of the future global and national economic situations, that could reduce the value of gold, and determine if you believe it will go continue to go up, plateau, or fall.

If you cannot do that or none of it makes sense, you are simply gambling!

In my personal opinion, gold will rise a little bit more, then mostly plateau for quite some years, slowly reducing in value as general economic confidence and confidence specifically in currencies rises. The pressure for the yuan and other currencies of nations with strong exports and developing economies (i.e. Brazilian real) to stop being artificially controlled will potentially cause a surge in demand for those currencies, increasing their value, which reduces the relative potentail return or safety of gold, which reduces it value.
 
I strongly advise against it.

Gold is traditionally a safe place which allows you to hold value.

At the moment though it's a great big massive bubble. That graph should explain why it's a bad place to put money.

+1 it is overly valued at the moment, i.e. the highest it has ever been if my stats are correct. I suspect the only way is down at the moment.
 
As already stated, buy at the bottom, now isnt a good time, as - given the state of the global economy - the price of gold isnt likely to rise much more.

I don't agree with this.

The price of gold is set by a body known as the London Gold Fix. The price isn't entirely affected by the quantity of gold in circulation, but more the level of demand there is for gold, in essence it's purely a psychological thing. The general public are learning fast that savings accounts are useless given the level of inflation 3%+ compared to the interest rates offered on savings accounts and are looking for alternative forms of investment. Given that the housing market is also pretty much at a plateau/decline, there's no investment to made there either. So, from what I can see, there's still a large demand for gold and as a result, the price will rise.
 
While I agree it probably not the best time to buy, there is no way that it's currently in a bubble, it would have to double before I considered it to be a bubble.

Double bubble...luverlly :D

I stand by what I said.

I believe it's a bubble. Just look at the graph in the OP

2006 300
2010 900 (almost)

Three times the price.

Gold is pure speculation. Unlike shares there are no dividends on gold. There are no benefits to ownership. With property you get rental. With cash you get interest (by lending it). With gold you get nothing, other than a medium of exchange and a belief that it will continue to hold value.

The reason why gold has shot up in value was initially because it's always been seen as a good hedge (a safe place). If you were worried about your own currency then you'd fire your money into gold, and it would hold value. Later when you were not worried you could take the gold back out.

The supply of gold?

Well...

Cash for Gold is a new phenomenon. It wasn't happening in 2006 much. It was happening, but not to the same extent. A whole lot of gold has been produced from old jewelery that wasn't in the supply system already.

It's now far more profitable to mine for gold than it was previously. With over double the yield some forms of mining that were not worth doing are suddenly worth doing. That increases supply.

People who traditionally held gold in the very long term have sold it. They held it because it had a static value, and kept up with inflation. Because the price has boomed it cannot be viewed in the same light, and no longer fills the function. They've cashed in. That increases supply.

So supply has increased. This should have decreased prices, but it hasn't. The reason why? Demand has increased farther than supply. So let's look at demand.

It is only fair to say that as the world matures, economically, people who were previously in a subsistance existance are now starting to leave that, and are looking for stores of wealth. Jewellery is one of those, and owning gold on paper is another. It's reasonable to say that there has been both an increase population and an increase in the number of people who are able to and want to hold gold. It goes nowhere near to matching that graph though.

Demand for gold increased because people wanted out of currency and wanted out of stocks. The stock market boomed last year, people are getting back into stocks.

The real reason for the demand on gold, demand so high that it's exceeding the effects of greatly increased supply.... The reason for that demand is just simply demand. People want gold because other people want gold. It's rapidly increasing in price so people like sheep join in and buy more.

So what does all that mean? Massive increase in supply should lower price, but it's been offset by the extreme demand. That demand will disappear in a flash as soon as people realise the boom is over.

When the value of gold starts to go down people will be pushing and shoving to get their gold sold as quickly as possible in order to avoid losses, and to get out of the gold market. So what happens then? Unlike housing or shares there is no real value in the gold, no dividends, no rental so the price has no hard limit.

At some point in the future I believe the price of gold will drop. It'll drop slightly more than normal fluctuations and people will start to get worried. They will sell. The price will crash very very hard. I expect it to go down to 100 £ per ounce, before going back up again to between 2 and 4 hundred.
 
Back
Top Bottom