Bahrain, media spinning the story yet again

Soldato
Joined
3 Aug 2003
Posts
15,921
Location
UK
Admittedly most of the "storm" has moved over to Libya at the moment but My boss has a brother working in Bahrain and it comes as no great shock to learn that the media, yet again have put a spin on the ensuing uprising story rather than just reporting the facts.
What a surprise..

He wrote this to my boss sometime over the weekend, naturally when we received it and had time to fully digest it, it was promptly sent off to Sky news and the BBC news.. :D
No replies yet... :(


Contrary to popular calls for me to be tear gassed I have not been. In fact all is OK in Bahrain.

What has happened is very sad and lots of people I know are involved in one way or another. However with common sense it is not difficult to avoid the trouble spots and keeping safe is not an issue.



Please don’t believe everything on the news these reporters have been in Bahrain for five minutes and most are clearly not well briefed, in fact Sky reporter Alex Crawford is a silly sensationalist cow who will get a swift kick in her arse if I (or a whole bunch of other people) ever meet her.

To be honest most Bahraini’s are not represented by the extreme protestors, there is democracy (not a European democracy but more than any other country in the region), this is an open society where dissent and discussion are allowed, parliament is voted in by the people (67% of the Bahraini population took part in the last election), unlike surrounding countries we have Churches, Mosques and Synagogues in Bahrain.



The same opposition members of parliament voted in are involved in the protests and are generally religious clerics with some pretty extreme views. If they were to be leading this country then foreign investment would die, the F1 would be lost, alcohol sales would be banned (very bad!), tourism would stop, churches and synagogues would be persecuted, women’s rights would be reduced and general religious freedoms and expression of opinions would be curtailed. When questioned as to the damage to Bahrain’s business and tourism that their changes would cause their answer is one of God will find a way....... great! These are not politicians as we know them, they are religious zealots who see the more extreme views of Islam being the way forward. Read Iranian backed hardliners rather than pro-democracy leaders when you hear of the so called leaders of this movement. Yes many who want more freedoms than are currently available have joined the demonstrators, but to balance that the largest demonstration to date has been a Pro King one, surprisingly this was hardly reported in the western press nor were the several other pro government and pro King gatherings involving thousands.

Our western press seems to want to influence rather than report accurately and that is sad. To tar Bahrain’s rulers as a despotic regime is very, very wrong and this country is a million miles different from Egypt or Tunisia in the way it is run.

Bahraini’s enjoy social security, free housing, unemployment benefits, food supplements, free healthcare, no income taxes and an average wage not far off European standards at $24K per head.

Bahrain is on the route to a full democracy that started in 2000 with the national charter but these things need time of adjustment and education. Democracy immediately and with no checks and balances could mean a very detrimental effect on this country. The aim of the rulers is to bring more freedoms and democracy as time went on, easing the transition so that a balanced and political structure matured that could be relied upon to operate in the countries best interests. Not to hand out all the power to political parties that can’t be separated from religious views.



I am proud to say Bahrain is the most truly multi culturally integrated society in the region, it is a true melting pot of differing people, religions and cultures. The Royal Family are the custodians of this and to date I don’t think they have done too bad a job considering Iran’s attempts to destabilise the region and the attempts of such influences to drive a sectarian divide between Shiite and Sunni.



A final point, it is Pearl Roundabout it is not a bloody square, never was never has been, if they can’t get their geography right then what chance of reporters reporting the facts????



So there you have it, my rant of annoyance and trying to tell you all not to believe everything the press says, where have we heard that before?????
 
I've done a lot of work in Bahrain and we've had similar messages from our colleagues there saying it is being totally over blown.
 
Sounds like a bit of propaganda coming from an unknown source (government). What ties does this guy have with Bahrain? Is he on a jolly nice little earner and a big contract from the government (Royal Family)? I suspect that he’s the one not giving us the big picture.
 
nobody is saying nothing is happening but there are people in bahrain saying that our press is over-egging it to the detriment of their outlook/economy etc.
 
Sounds like a bit of propaganda coming from an unknown source (government). What ties does this guy have with Bahrain? Is he on a jolly nice little earner and a big contract from the government (Royal Family)? I suspect that he’s the one not giving us the big picture.

The only ties he has with with Bahrain is the fact he is living there.
What are you on about "unknown source" I've just said, it's my bosses brother. :confused:
He's just a dude with his eyes open to the real situation.
Propaganda Lulz :rolleyes:
 
The media are parasites. I found it very difficult to be bothered when they were being lynched in the streets in Egypt. They exacerbate the problems by ****-stirring and making natives' lives a ****ing misery reporting on depressing news with round-the-clock coverage.

Even my grandfather, who was a writer for the News of the World back during the 50s, 60s and 70s can't stand what modern media has become.
 
I wonder how the doubtless quite neutral and well informed guy suggesting that there is nothing going on will spin the deaths of at least four people?

As I understand it, King Hamad has promised political reforms - whilst doubting that he will willingly actually implement them, I do wonder how come he has been so taken in by the foreign media spin :confused:
 
The only ties he has with with Bahrain is the fact he is living there.
What are you on about "unknown source" I've just said, it's my bosses brother. :confused:

You haven't said what he does there and who he works for. So he could be a loyal supporter.

Propaganda Lulz :rolleyes:

The last paragraphs sound like government propaganda to me. "Look at our wonderful democracy and our wonderful country". They have a parliament with limited power and most of the cabinet are royal family members. That sounds like a real democracy to me. I suspect all we are getting is the view from his side of the fence.
 
Come on they need us to see (think) that the whole region is about to destroy itself, the only way to save the poor defenceless people is for the USA and us to take over the oil wells, sorry nations to stabalise them. You know just until free democratic elections can be had (until the oil runs dry)
 
There is a guy on another forum (motorsport related) that I'm on and his account is totally different to that in the OP, he's been in the thick of the action and from what he's been saying it doesn't seem overblown at all.

Is your friend an ex-pat living in a nice comfortable hotel scubascorpion?
 
There is a lot of truth in the first post, though I think it goes just a smidgeon too far in its praise of Bahrain. I've been to Bahrain a few times myself and it is indeed the most liberal country in the region in my view. I think a lot of the over-hype about Bahrain has been as a result of reporters actually being able to get into the country, which already makes it obvious that Bahrain is not the same as the real dictatorships elsewhere in the region. Frankly I think journalists have been overcompensating for their inability to give decent coverage of Libya.

It's not at all perfect in Bahrain though. The Shias are indeed repressed, and the government is corrupt. The prime minister is nicknamed "Mr ten per cent" by some (disclaimer: I heard that a while ago, the percentage might be wrong :p) for the fingers he has in the pie of any large project that takes place. There is a democratically elected parliament but it can be (and is) overruled when it pushes an idea which the king doesn't want - the prohibition of alcohol being one example.

Like many middle eastern countries there is mass nepotism. Most good jobs, especially senior ones, are gained more (or rather, almost entirely) as a result of who you know than whether you are clever or hard working. Personally I suspect that the decision to violently kick the protesters off the pearl roundabout the first time they camped there was taken by one such jobs-for-the-boys plonker in the higher ranks of the police or army - without being given an order from the very top to do so. It was just such an obviously stupid thing to do that it smacks of the kind of incompetence I've heard stories about before.

But it is an increasingly democratic island and the movement towards further democracy looked set to continue before all this kicked off. And I do think it's true that an uncomfortably large portion of the political opposition are religious zealots, who would probably make Bahrain a more restricted place that it currently is if they had their way.

People I know in Bahrain tell me that, aside from the protesting in particular places in the city, life has been pretty much carrying on as usual. Dustbins collected, water bottles delivered etc. etc.. One day last week there was some panic-buying of basic groceries in supermarkets but that hasn't happened again since.
 
Last edited:
"The Bahrain Grand Prix has been called off because of anti-government protests in the Gulf kingdom."

That Bernie Ecclestone huh??? You would think that he would know better than to fall for a media feeding frenzy . . . he must be going senile ;)
 
I'm not sure, exactly, who or what you are responding to with that comment. I'll offer a reply in case it's me.

There are protests going on in Bahrain because of a lack of democratic representation and because of Sunni minority in power who give jobs to their (Sunni) friends and relatives at the expense of the rest of the population. Those protesting would seek to disrupt the Bahrain Grand Prix. The fact that they would is not a matter of right or wrong, it's just obvious that they would do so. In that case, why would the organisers of the grand prix choose to go ahead with the event?

Regardless, Bahrain is somewhat democratic and was steadily, inexorably (in my view) becoming moreso. That is not to say that there aren't MANY murky issues with any question of a dictator (whether king or president or general) witholding freedoms. It's to say that a person in Bahrain has considerably more freedom and considerably more of a voice than a person in Libya, and yet the two countries are being portrayed as equally repressive.

I don't suppose it's necessary to add this, but to spell it out further: It is being suggested that the media are misrepresenting, exaggerating, giving a bizarrely large profile to, what is happening. Not that they are making it all up.
 
Last edited:
your bosses brother doesnt really care for democracy in bahrain though does he ? why would he care when he is happily making money how it is now. im guessing its the poor locals that are being treat like crap who care... he probably in a nice and safe part of the country with the other well off chaps , not on the streets trying to express an opinion and being shot for it!

ive seen the videos of police/army shooting protestors dead from a distance and without warning shots. they wherent being violent they where just walking up a street with flags , no stones , no guns , no weapons

everything is NOT ok

and as for libya well fighter pilots dont defect in jets when everything is ok
 
Last edited:
your bosses brother doesnt really care for democracy in bahrain though does he ? why would he care when he is happily making money how it is now. im guessing its the poor locals that are being treat like crap who care... he probably in a secure and safe neighbourhood with the other well off chaps , not on the streets trying to express an opinion and being shot for it!

ive seen the videos of police shooting protestors dead. they wherent being violent they where just walking up a street with flags , no stones , no guns , no weapons

everything is NOT ok

and as for libya well fighter pilots dont defect in jets when everything is ok

Gordon Bennett.

The last line of this post I've quoted is exactly what I was concerned about. Somehow Bahrain and Libya have been put on an equal level in the public perception. Which is just wrong.

Who said what was happening in Libya is OK? Nobody.

I don't think that Bahrain not being a full democracy is OK either. I don't think it was OK that the protesters on the pearl roundabout were attacked and killed. Though in my view it was done by an over-zealous police force (which is a very bad thing but not uncommon even in democracies) ordered forward by an incompetent lazy idiot who has his job because he is or knows a relative of someone important - rather than a choice taken by the highest echelons of the government. It's just my opinion that that is what happened, I might be wrong, but the inconsistency and stupidity of the decision leads me to think so.

Many little comments, references and events related to or resulting from the reporting of the protests in Bahrain have annoyed me simply because they are out of proportion and out of touch with reality. For what it's worth I hope the protests lead to some positive changes, an acceleration of the handing of power to the people. I think wholesale revolution is unlikely and would not result in an improvement for the people of Bahrain***.

***(Which is NOT to say that there isn't a place for it - the dangers involved in a total upheaval of government may be far less bad than the dangers of the continued operation of a frankly evil government, as is obviously looking to be the case in Libya)

I think, for example, that the Foreign Office advising against all but essential travel to Bahrain is disproportionate. At the very least you can say that Bahrain is not a dangerous place for UK citizens to be. The protests have taken place in very limited specific areas (that is the whole idea, surely, to concentrate your numbers when protesting?) and the entire rest of the island has remained peaceful and orderly. Quiet, if anything. Regardless, Bahrainis have always seemed friendly towards foreigners as a matter of mutual respect so I am not sure what the threat is. I can assure you that expats in Bahrain don't live in "secure and safe neighbourhoods"... I don't know how you would define such a thing but the phrase puts me in mind of the large walled "compounds" that expats invariably lived in in Saudi Arabia when I was there as a child. They had high walls and armed guards at the gates. Bahrain isn't like that. For starters it's a small island and nowhere is terribly far from anywhere else, so neighbourhoods can't practically be separated off in any real sense from one another. There are more and less affluent neighbourhoods, like in Britain, but expats are fairly spread around from what I can tell. Though I'll grant you that some do live in hotels! Mostly if they are temporary workers because it's bad value for money to stay in a hotel long-term.

I think that the tone and prominence of the reporting on Bahrain's protests has been disproportionate. That's why I wanted to post as I have. It's not a black and white thing, just a relatively minor and tangential objection to count against the much louder voices we have been hearing. (I wouldn't presume to speak for the original poster or his boss's brother's.)
 
Last edited:
Gordon Bennett.

The last line of this post I've quoted is exactly what I was concerned about. Somehow Bahrain and Libya have been put on an equal level in the public perception. Which is just wrong.

Who said what was happening in Libya is OK? Nobody.

did you completely ignore the 'and as for' part of my comment ? the part that separates what i said about bahrain from what i was saying about libya.

the last comment (that i obviously should have put in a new post) was more a reply to the people who seem to be suggest that the media are making up this whole 'thing' for some kind of political reason.

by safe neighbourhoods i mean nice areas , everywhere has nicer areas and when you live in a nice area you tend to ignore what goes on in the bad areas because it never effects you, im suggesting that thats what OPs contact is doing. why would he be effected by the protests if he doesnt live/work/go near where they are happening or doesnt care for democracy?

the reporters whom he says aren't telling the truth are actually there in the thick of it , holding cameras while people next to them get shot at. i wouldn't call that 'media spinning' or 'overblown' or 'not fact' like he has done.
 
Last edited:
I've done a lot of work in Bahrain and we've had similar messages from our colleagues there saying it is being totally over blown.

That's what I'd heard from people there too :). Only real issue was the causeway being shut and stopping them from commuting over to Saudi.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom