Also depends on what graphics card you have, if you already have a decent card then you should go for the i5 2500k but if its not so good better of improve that as it makes most of the difference.
i5 2500(K) + GTX 560 seems to be the best price/performance for gaming currently. I'd thoroughly recommend that if you were buying today. Get the MSI 560, as that can easily be overclocked to 1+ GHz and GTX 570 strength on the Twin Frozr cooler.
*Cough*6950 2GB*cough*
*Cough*6950 2GB*cough*
Unlocked to a 6970......