Council rubbish bin collection fines to be scrapped

Soldato
Joined
7 Jul 2003
Posts
3,290
Location
Westergate
This is not a discussion for how crap your collections are or how many bins your have, if you want to discuss that make another thread and read no further.

Residents can receive a fixed-penalty notice if they repeatedly break the rules on rubbish collections
Continue reading the main story Related StoriesWhat do you put in nine bins?Weekly bin collection 'to return'Bin charging schemes 'ruled out'
Fines for residents who break the rules on rubbish collections in England are to be scrapped, the BBC has learned.

Environment Secretary Caroline Spelman is expected to announce next month that the charges will be outlawed in all but the most serious cases of fly-tipping.

Meanwhile, ministers have warned councils against "charging by the back-door" for refuse services.

This includes forcing residents to buy "official" rubbish sacks from the council rather than other suppliers.

'Small minority'

At the moment, people can be fined with a fixed-penalty notice if they repeatedly break the rules covering rubbish collections, such as recycling incorrectly or leaving waste out on the wrong day.

But the BBC's political correspondent Laura Kuenssberg said that the government will now remove most of those powers from English town halls.

It follows a promise last year to scrap them.

In another move, Environment Minister Lord Henley and Local Government Minister Bob Neill have written to councils in England after concerns a "small minority" were going beyond their legal powers to charge for refuse collections.

Their letter reminds local authorities they can charge for collecting bulky or garden waste but not regular rubbish.

Councils are also not allowed to impose a call-out fee if rubbish collectors arrive at a property but are unable for some reason to pick up the waste at that time.

Charging by 'backdoor'

The ministers said councils must not force residents to buy "official" rubbish sacks from the town hall in places where people had to purchase their own bags, warning that authorities should not create a monopoly.

They wrote: "In short, councils cannot introduce 'backdoor' bin charging for mainstream waste collections or waste disposal.

"Such stealth taxes are not legal and are contrary to the policy direction of the new government."

Ministers are currently passing legislation to get rid of the previous Labour government's policy of offering councils the chance to take part in pilot "pay-as-you-throw" schemes which charge households which create the most rubbish.

Lord Henley and Mr Neill said the government believed such initiatives would encourage fly-tipping and burning in gardens, and impose added costs to families which were already struggling financially.

Now I am bias I will say from the start as I work in an area that has to manage collections, but I will add I believe we provide a fair service, for 47p a week.

My service provides a wheelie bin for recycling which can take, paper, card, plastic bottles, glass, foil and tetra pak containers, we collect this every two weeks. We do not provide a refuse bin but we take up to 5 bags a week. We offer a paid green waste service for £50 a year.

I have in the past used powers to deal with extreme cases of residents who are causing issue to others, so for example your neighbour leaving waste out all week, which then litters your garden, path or the road. We do not do silly things such as fine for contaminationg bins, after 5 warning we simply remove the recycling bin, or for leaving your bin lid an inch open, I fully agree that charges for bags or bins is not right.

My main beef is if they remove the ablity to tackle people who cause others a nuisence then be prepared to tackle your neighbour, something a lot of people would not wish to do.

Its everyone's individual responsiblity to manage the waste they produce, but sorry to say not everyone sees it that way.

It will be an interesting time ahead for all of us.
 
If people bought their own bin bags, then wouldn't you then have the problem of cheap bags that just rip as soon as you lift them?
What then, do you stuff it all back in and manhandle it to the lorry, or just dump the ripped/overloaded bag back where you found it.
 
The guys use slave bins, so simply pick up the bags and drop them in the bin. If it spills they clear it up, if its constant, like every week then we speak with the resident.
 
The government is not taking away your powers to deal with people who act in the extreme.

This is stopping you and your other council friends charging for bin lids that are 0.002 mm open, or for charging for moving bins that are half an inch outside of the prescribed pick up point.
 
Sounds good, most councils cannot be trusted with the powers to fine people, as parking fines, bin fines and so on have repeatedly demonstrated. They rapidly become a draconian enforced revenue generation scheme rather than an actual benefit to anyone.
 
Good news for some. We don’t get fined, we’re not forced to use official bin bags or read red lines of text.
 
If people bought their own bin bags, then wouldn't you then have the problem of cheap bags that just rip as soon as you lift them?
What then, do you stuff it all back in and manhandle it to the lorry, or just dump the ripped/overloaded bag back where you found it.

In Norwich we put the bags into council supplied bins that the bin men wheel to the lorry, which then automatically empties them. The bin men should not have to touch any bags.
 
In Carlilse we have Wheelie bins for general a green waste as well as a bin for bottles and cans and also plastics. No fines at all, some houses use bags instead of bins and they are provided for at no extra charge.
 
As to the OP, why on earth should we pay another company to collect refuse that we pay councils for already.

Our local council has no fine system, they simply supply two wheelie bins, one for refuse and one for recycling. If you need more then you apply for more.

It is simple, efficent and constructive.
 
Castiel I have no idea what your talking about? Unless its green waste, which is not classed as Household waste.

So if your neighbour makes a continued mess which litters yours and his garden then what action should take place?
 
Castiel I have no idea what your talking about? Unless its green waste, which is not classed as Household waste.

So if your neighbour makes a continued mess which litters yours and his garden then what action should take place?

It's a strange and bizarre concept for those who wish to work within the nanny state, but I find talking to neighbours usually works quite well... If that is ineffective, then there are other options that don't involve random, fixed penalty fines from jobsworth council employees.
 
Dolph please expand on other options, as when ever a resident speaks to me the neighbours are problem neighbours, the ones that people do not like to approach.

I am all for moving calls and work away from the local Council's, but look at how thats worked with Anti Social Behavior or even simple things like trees and bushes overgrowing garden walls etc.
 
Last edited:
Dolph please expand on other options, as when ever a resident speaks to me the neighbours are problem neighbours, the ones that people do not like to approach.

With sufficient evidence, small claims court would certainly be an option for the cost and hassle of repeated cleanup.

I am all for moving calls and work away from the local Council's, but look at how thats worked with Anti Social Behavior or even simple things like trees ad bushes overgrowing garden walls etc.

Anti-social behaviour has never really been within the remit of local councils, it has aways been a police matter.

Simple things like trees and bushes overgrowing walls are again things that should be sorted out between individuals, not require a signficiant state structure to resolve. Indeed, the law already allows you to cut things back to your own borders without issue.
 
Castiel

Note you were talking about this:

Ministers are currently passing legislation to get rid of the previous Labour government's policy of offering councils the chance to take part in pilot "pay-as-you-throw" schemes which charge households which create the most rubbish.

Fully agree, we do not want to move towards this, it would be bad for everyone another utility bill for us all and it wuld far exceed the £50 a year most of us pay towards waste collection.

But on the other hand the government keep on putting landfill tax up and up, they should focus on making shops provide packaging that can all be recycled as at the moment they cant even drive carrier bags out of circulation.
 
Dolph Anti Social Behaviour such as working with the youngsters, repeat offenders has been with the local authority's now for about 5 years, it is to move back to the police neaxt year, who will make a final decision as to who to engage at a local level.

The Police are only interested in 999 emergency calls the other non emergency number which takes 10-20 mins to answer will not make you see a Policeman respond in any quick time limit.

The truth is a lot of people do not like to approach neighbours now, when you try and sell your house it has to be declared etc, so an anoymous call to someone else is often easier.
 
we already have littering laws if the neighbours aren't taking care of their rubbish appropriately then use that law no need to use it as an excuse to create more income.
 
To make it clear in the last 5 years I have been forced to use the powers on 4 occasions, all related to persistant repeat offenders placing bags out away from their property, causing a issue for others and having received 7-8 warnings letters left me with no other option but to go down the legal route.
 
They should focus on making shops provide packaging that can all be recycled as at the moment they cant even drive carrier bags out of circulation.

I like carrier bags, I use them for my food rubbish, they save on buying bin bags which can be recycled if only used for dry waste.

Shops could cut packaging by half right now, they just don't want to.
Why is it only coffee that comes in refill packs and often costs just as much as the coffee in glass jars?
Why can't I buy 5kg of cornflakes in a sack instead of 125.912 grams of the same, with all the associated cardboard.
 
Back
Top Bottom