New car time, going sensible this time.

Soldato
Joined
24 Feb 2003
Posts
8,715
Well, it's been just short of a year now with the Jag, will be a year in early August. The car needs some money spending on it and I am disinclined to do so really ...so no more Jags for now, infact no more interesting but costly to run ageing luxury for now, I would rather actually save some money now rather plough it into old cars.

I am still going to buy a newer car but I want it to be a lot cheaper to run and a lot newer, I'd rather avoid 'old' cars and the issues they often bring for now, I know I will have to spend a bit of money upfront ...but bear in mind the Jag needs a full gearbox service and a 100k miles service now ...plus whatever the hell is causing me a vibration sorted ...so unknown potential amount there, anyway I figure I could easily spend £1k on the Jag right now maybe £1.5k even to straighten it out properly, that really depends on exactly what is up.

So what sort of car do I want ... well I want something significantly cheaper to run but I also want it to be comfortable, well equipped and have plenty of space in it. So basically a Ford Mondeo I suppose, which along with the Mazda 6 and the VW Passat (I did look at the Jetta and the Volvo S40 too) is what I have been looking at online the last couple of weeks. Now I am back in the UK I can actually do something about it though. I have ruled out the Honda Accord as I don't like the interiors and I have driven these and they are just so dull it's painful, the Jetta is quite rare here and perhaps a bit smaller than I want. The Passat is the least favoured choice of the 3 I have left as they aren't that well equiped until you get upto the top specs, which carry a fair price premium and I have read a frankly worrying amount about what can can go wrong with the engines, I know the Ford can and does suffer the same sort of issues that all modern common rail turbo diesels seem to have ...but, the VW just seems more prone to them from what I have read ...also on the whole, I like the Mondeo more anyway.

And then the Mazda, the only 6 I am considering is the pre facelift of the current shape, so the shame generation as the MK4 Mondeo, and although they are a bit cheaper to buy new they do seem to be a little more expensive like for like on the used market and there are a lot less of them about, so while I do like them, logic and practicality does point towards the Mondeo.

Firstly, I actually 'want' a diesel this time (like hell do I, I 'want' a V8 Supercharged Jag actually, but in the context of this post at least, a diesel it is :p ), yes I really did say that! ...the reason being is that switching back to a smaller 4 cylinder engine is going to be somewhat irritating for me as it is ...and in the 2 litre 4 pot category I really do 'generally' prefer the way the diesels drive, they have a lot more low to mid end punch and just feel more muscular ...and frankly the clatter at low speed and idle isn't as off putting to me as the sound of a typical 4 pot petrol being driven past 4krpm.

When I was in Canada I had a Ford Fusion (they are crap btw) which had a 2.5 litre engine in it, basically the same unit as Mazda use in the 6 Sport here, had 170bhp or so and it sounded awful and was rough as hell when revved and had no torque ...which I believe is much the same as the 2 litre petrol Ford put in the Mondeo and Mazda in the 6 only they will be even less powerful and torqueless, so diesel it is. Besides this is a money saving scheme in the 'longer' run, so the possibility of replacement fuel pumps, injectors and dpf's aside ...it seems logical enough.

Frankly the petrol engines in the Ford and Mazda seem to be crap, except for the 2.5 turbo Volvo unit you can get in the Ford (very rare).

I don't really want to spend more than £7k at the most, the lower the better though. I figure I should be expecting something like £4.5k part ex for the Jag (can you believe that!). That £7k includes the value of the Jag of course.

I have seen rather a lot of MK4 Mondeos in my budget with fairly high miles on, including a nice black 2.0 TDCI Titanium fairly locally with 120k on the clock, but it's an 08 plate with 1 owner and a FSH and it looks very nice in the pictures so I figure it's got to have been rolling up and down motorways to put that kind of mileage on in that time, the steering wheel and seats, pedal rubbers etc do not look very worn in the pictures either. So that looks like a good place to start, also the Titanium really does have a good spec, better than the Jag in terms of gear.

Does anyone seen any real issues with that?

I suppose other than an info post telling people what I am doing/thinking the whole point of this thread wasn't so much to elicit advice on what car I should buy as I already know more or less what I want so much as generally asking about the sort of 07-08 plate Mondeos and Mazdas I am seeing quite a few of for sale with 100k + miles on and 1 former keeper, I guess they should be a pretty decent place to look for a bargain right ? ...I'm not walking into a world of pain and missery buying a car with as much or even more miles than the Jag that's 4.5 years newer though I hope? ...I know there are no guarentees of course.

I know I can buy a relatively low mileage Mondeo for my money, but only the Edge really and while I am sure it'd be a great way to save money and get a reliable, comfortable car etc ...more certain that buying a high mileage higher spec car anyway ...steel wheels, manual aircon ...no body coloured door handles etc and no front fogs ...that's rather lower than I would like to stoop :p ...although my only 'real' requirements, not likes but must haves, are aircon, cruise control, leather covered steering wheel, auxiliary jack for the stereo and electric heated mirrors ...and more or less every car in the class I am looking at pretty much has those as standard even on the base models, except the Passat. What I would like though is climate control, cruise control and relevant controls on the steering wheel ...full electrics of course, heated windscreen (Ford only in this case I think), electro-chromatic rear view mirror, proper ipod integration, air conditioned glovebox or armrest storage area, heated front seats, bluetooth and a decent automatic gearbox.

Now onto the gearbox, I am not sure weather an automatic in this type of car is any good or not these days, I know they are much rarer but I have seen a few decent looking Mondeos around with the Ford Powershift auto, which I have no experience of at all, does anyone have anything to say about those and what they are like ?

Lets face it though, this kind of car isn't going to be all that interesting to drive, it's a tool really after all, although the Mondeo and Mazda are the best of the bunch in that regard so pretty well all the press guff says. So I am really not bothered about cog-swapping myself. I would prefer an auto ...but only if it's a decent one, I would much rather have the 6 speed manual than a crap auto, I have been driving both my own auto and a manual car on and off for a while now and the only time I can honestly say I really dislike the manual is when stuck in traffic, otherwise it's not a big deal.

If anyone has any other 'sensible' ideas though, feel free to pitch in, I know you will anyway :p

I think that's it for now.
 
Have you actually done the sums to work out how much this will potentially save you for the duration? I'd not want to be picking up a high-milage low end diesel in the pursuit of saving a few £, because in all likeliness, you will lose that saving with a DMF or injector problem.

I'd be loathing the change from a nice XJ to a Mondeo too, as nice as the MK4 Mondeo is, it still "feels" cheaper than a nice premium brand.

If you're not adversed to mileage (which I know you aren't), why not get a much newer, 6-cyl petrol? Most of them are getting incredibly economical now (for their size and power outputs), and assuming you aren't driving multiple tens of thousands of miles a year, the difference in overall running costs won't be significantly different.

Are those 3 (Mondeo, 6 and Passat) the only cars now on your radar?
 
I really rate the 6, we've got a few as pool cars at work and they really are very good cars. They are all 59 reg though and have all had between one and three DPF failures. Shame, as they are good enough engines to drive.

As paradigm says, a newer diesel isn't necessarily a gateway to cheap reliably motoring. Is a middle ground not the best option here? Newer 6 cylinder petrol for less money you say? Have a look at my thread Moeks to see what sort of bargains are out there - a 2005 Lexus IS200 for 3400 quid!
 
I was in a Passat taxi at the weekend. 57 plate. Now I admit a taxi is not the best car to use to judge the model as a whole but it was fairly horrible in there.
 
Alternatively, get a 4-cyl turbo petrol. That way you get the "shove" you are looking for, but can also drive off-boost for that extra MPG.

The A6 2.0T for example will do >40MPG on a motorway with ease.

[TW]Fox;19660528 said:
I was in a Passat taxi at the weekend. 57 plate. Now I admit a taxi is not the best car to use to judge the model as a whole but it was fairly horrible in there.

Let me guess, you though the overall "feel" was quite hard and plasticy, there were strange creakings and squeaks coming from the interior trim, the seats weren't overly comfortable, and the ride was quite crashy?

At least that was my overall impression of the 2005-2011 Passat.
 
Let me guess, you though the overall "feel" was quite hard and plasticy, there were strange creakings and squeaks coming from the interior trim, the seats weren't overly comfortable, and the ride was quite crashy?

At least that was my overall impression of the 2005-2011 Passat.

Thats absolutely it, yes.
 
Valid points, as I understand it though the DPF issue has a lot to do with the way you actually use the car, lots of short trips being bad, well I don't really do that too much and I also like to give the engine a good workout when warmed up, run it up and down the rev range at least once a week. My particular driving profile should be fine for a diesel, I have had two before remember, a Citroen 2 litre HDI common rail unit about 9 years ago and a 1.9 PD 130 Seat Leon ...I liked that engine, tad noisy perhaps but strong, had a nice fat wad of torque right where it's useful ...and I never had any issues at all with them, I only had the Citroen for 10 months I know but I had the Seat for 3 years ...the longest I have ever had a car, I did have it brand new though.

If only the 2 litre turbo petrol was fitted to the Mondeo eh ...but I'd have to have the Passat for that and as I said, I like the car less than the Mondeo. The Mondeo is all in all my favourite car of this bunch, luckily it's also the most common and thus there are loads of them about. While buying a 2.5 Turbo may put a smile on my face I'm not convinced it's necessarily a great idea. Having said that there are a whole host of other things I don't have to worry about with these cars, expensive air suspension components that can strand you if they fail, the tyre costs should be lower, insurance ...they wont have a gearbox/torque converter setup that is showing signs that it either needs some serious TLC or will fail in some way and cost a fortune. A lot of things are cheaper across the bored than the Jag or the BMW's I've had. The only real issue are these common rail diesel issues ...which I suppose is why I'm asking, how bad are they really? ...I am aware that there are certain usage profiles that bring them out more quickly and more often and I don't really fit them ...nor am I big on full bore standing starts or labouring the engine ...which done often is a recipe for DMF (and clutch) failure in the end. And if they do fail what do they cost? ...the Dual Mass Flywheel and Clutch had to be replaced on my sisters A4 a few months back, Audi quoted over £3k for that, in the end we managed to get them to do it for £2.7k ...which is insane imo. IIRC the same sort of thing on my ST220 would have cost about £1300 or so, which while still expensive falls short of insanity ...consider the A4 had only done 26k miles too.

I'd like a slightly smaller car anyway, more 5 series sized ...which the Mondeo is. As much as I like big cars ...I do find at times in some of our tighter parking areas ... the Jag is perhaps a bit too big, enough so that it makes things a bit awkward ...the A4 by contrast is great ...feels like a go-cart by comparison, it's that much shorter and narrower. There is actually a multi-story car park in a place not too far from me that I can't even take the Jag, it's too long, the turns to get around the ramps are too narrow, they have crash barriers stick out of the concrete walls and the turn is too tight for the Jag to make and because of the way the cars are parked it's extremely difficult to get in and out properly (I admit I don't go there often, but just an example) without a lot of micro manoeuvring ...now the 5 series was a bit tight but it was small enough that I didn't feel it was a problem ..I didn't find myself avoiding certain parking areas because of the size of the car, I do actually have to do that with the Jag to a certain extent, also the Jag is so wide with the mirrors out I frequently find myself having to be ready to retract them in a hurry when using the lanes around where I live ...which I do a lot, especially if something like a transit is coming the other way, never had that issue with the 5 series as it was quite a bit narrower (didn't have retracting mirrors anyway :p ) ...now if we build proper sized parking areas like they do in Canada I could park a full length Ford F350 dualy in it ...no problem ...alas we do not.

Bottom line is, the Jag has to go. What it is replaced with is a bit open. The Mondeo, Mazda 6 and Passat are my short list, they aren't the only things I have considered though. I have also looked into the smaller VW Jetta, the Volvo S40 and S60, the Audi A4 and A6 and the Jaguar X Type (rather old fashioned now compared to the MK4 Mondeo etc) ...I have not really considered BMW's this time, the pre facelift E90 is ..well I'm not keen on them tbh, the post face-life is too expensive and also don't exactly excite me all that much and the E60 4 series ...err no, I would be buying into the same expensive mess I have found myself before with one of them, I already know that ...yea I might get lucky, but then I might not, it'd also be a bit leggy in my budget.
 
Last edited:
No, all it has cost me so far is a set of tyres, but I dearly regret getting rid of the black V8 one I had in favour of the 540i. I really do wish I had never done that, live and learn though eh. I also regret selling my ST220 so soon, that was a perfect all round car really, fantastic balance of ...everything really. And yes I have been looking at those aswell, but really ...18" wheels, dual exhausts, 25mpg ...it's day to day running costs are are much as the Jag, the other stuff isn't as bad though and they are pretty reliable. I still don't think it's really the best idea though.

I don't have the same disposable income I used to have anymore, things have gotten more expensive, my earnings have not increased though and I have some significant costs that I didn't used to have, i.e. living costs. I used to just live with my Mum rent/keep free when I had the black Jag. I just can't practically afford this kind of car anymore, also I have a plan now ...I am determined that I will live in Canada, I want to be there within 5 years ...and to that end I would rather save money for that than throw it at cars. I do like cars though and I do need a decent and reliable car. Obviously no matter how 'sensible' I try to be, I am a car person at the end of the day and I can only go 'so far' the other way.
 
Last edited:
Provided the service history is all there and everything works properly, then that car would probably be quite a bargain. The black Jag I mentioned, was an '04 3.5 V8 ...it was lovely, very smooth engine, much better than the Ford V6 that my XJ6 uses.

Here is a link to the thread I showed it off in for the first time, arhh it was damn nbear perfect that can was, it's pains me to look at it now.

http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=18030537&highlight=Jaguar+XJ8+3.5+V8
 
Provided the service history is all there and everything works properly, then that car would probably be quite a bargain. The black Jag I mentioned, was an '04 3.5 V8 ...it was lovely, very smooth engine, much better than the Ford V6 that my XJ6 uses.

Here is a link to the thread I showed it off in for the first time, arhh it was damn nbear perfect that can was, it's pains me to look at it now.

http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=18030537&highlight=Jaguar+XJ8+3.5+V8

Wants £4k for it...but something is telling me to get the 4.2 V8 :D I'm not in desparate need to change, but something is pulling me toward it
 
Moeks i think your mad changing car for the sake of spending a grand on that, you knew a grand service could happen when you went into it, in fact it probably wont even be a grand, its 250 for the gearbox flush and 4 or 5 hundred quid for the biggest service i cant remember off hand.

The Dean, the 3.5 or 4.2 are both very good its those 2 extra cylinders over the 3 litre. Not knocking the 3 litre mind.
 
Having swapped an e38 7 & Series for a newer Mondeo in the past, I for one would not advise ditching the Jag.

Put it another way, I reckon if I'd kept my e38 until this day, I would not have spent as much on keeping it on the road (and running it) as I have cumulatively spent buying & fixing its "Cheaper" replacements.

The idea sounds good, the reality is in my experience, somewhat different.
 
If you have to I'd get a Mk4 Mondeo, sod the spec you're trying to save money here, see the car as a white good, to get you from A to B.

Buy the best condition Mondeo you can, which will probably mean FSH, 1 owner, newish and low mileage.

Still I'd check your figures first and make sure this would actually save you money. No point doing all this to save £1k over a year or something.
 
Tesla has a minty mint Titanium X estate, 2008, diesel and he was looking at about your budget. Looked absolutely superb at the RR day :)
 
Moeks i think your mad changing car for the sake of spending a grand on that, you knew a grand service could happen when you went into it, in fact it probably wont even be a grand, its 250 for the gearbox flush and 4 or 5 hundred quid for the biggest service i cant remember off hand.

The Dean, the 3.5 or 4.2 are both very good its those 2 extra cylinders over the 3 litre. Not knocking the 3 litre mind.

and for the software update on the gearbox? ...another £250 I reckon.

No point doing all this to save £1k over a year or something.
Actually, there is, if it was £250 I might agree.
 
Back
Top Bottom