• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

GTX580 Buzing

Associate
Joined
10 Aug 2011
Posts
80
I got a new Asus GeForce GTX 580 DirectCU II 2 days ago. its all set up and running but when i enter a game such as World of Warcraft i get a strange electrical buzzing noise coming from the card. the noise changes in tone, pitch and volume as i move my characters field of view about.
 
Last edited:
Im not 100% but its probably capacitor whine.

My 5870 has done it in the past, but very infrequently and not for ages.

May also be certain games as well.

Try a different game, to see if it does the same thing.

Does the whine dissapear? Not sure, it did in my case.
 
I got a new Asus GeForce GTX 580 DirectCU II 2 days ago. its all set up and running but when i enter a game such as World of Warcraft i get a strange electrical buzzing noise coming from the card. the noise changes in tone, pitch and volume as i move my characters field of view about.

Sure its the card. I've got the same card and whistle. It turned out to be my PSU when under GPU load. Sounded like it was coming from the card though.

Replaced the PSU and whistle gone apart from in Heaven.
 
Is it a sign that the psu is being pushed to it's limit?

I've just upgraded from a GTX 460 to a Phantom GTX 570 (with a medium overclock) and I'm getting the same kind of noise from the power supply. Very occasionally I'd hear the buzz when the 460 was under full load or if I had a pair of them in SLI. With the 570 I get various degrees of buzzing from the psu depending on the game but it happens with every game I've tried so far. Perhaps an overclocked 2500k and an overclocked 570 is too much for the Antec TP 550W.

Do you think a good quality 750W psu would put an end to the buzzing?


Sorry to the OP for hijacking the thread :D
 
In my experience replacing the psu often does not solve the issue. Or even replacing the card, as both can be the part of the cause/receiver of the noise.

What I have found is that good quality PCI-E cable has Always have solved the problem.
in the image shown the PCI-E cable has a ferite inductor coil which attenuates high frequency signals, which is where most noise occurs.

You can find 3rd party pci-e extension cables/surge protectors which also work in the same manner. they should cost approx £10, unfortunately I cant find any on ocuk.

P1020357.jpg
 
Don't worry it's normal and will calm down with more use I found (I have the same card as you). I had the same thing and now don't even hear it. As others have said also use V-sync if the game is throwing out crazy frame rates and it will reduce the noise. As I said don't worry it will calm down I found when it started to break in the componets on the card. You will get the odd program that can trip it to buzz louder then others too and it is very normal on modern cards. Do make sure that the sound is only coming from the card and not the PSU, PSUs can make that noise too when put under stress.
 
Last edited:
I get this while im playing skyrim on my 580 with a 650 psu, and sounds like it is coming from psu rather than the card.
 
In my experience replacing the psu often does not solve the issue. Or even replacing the card, as both can be the part of the cause/receiver of the noise.

What I have found is that good quality PCI-E cable has Always have solved the problem.
in the image shown the PCI-E cable has a ferite inductor coil which attenuates high frequency signals, which is where most noise occurs.

You can find 3rd party pci-e extension cables/surge protectors which also work in the same manner. they should cost approx £10, unfortunately I cant find any on ocuk.

P1020357.jpg

OMG this +1

I had HORRIFIC whine from a 580 I bought from Cleeecooo, however yesterday when moving my rig to a new case, some of my braided PCI-E extensions were loose, a firm thrust back in, silence. I agree with the above consensus. Whine certainly comes from loose pins/poor materials.
 
In my experience replacing the psu often does not solve the issue. Or even replacing the card, as both can be the part of the cause/receiver of the noise.

What I have found is that good quality PCI-E cable has Always have solved the problem.
in the image shown the PCI-E cable has a ferite inductor coil which attenuates high frequency signals, which is where most noise occurs.

You can find 3rd party pci-e extension cables/surge protectors which also work in the same manner. they should cost approx £10, unfortunately I cant find any on ocuk.

OMG this +1

I had HORRIFIC whine from a 580 I bought from Cleeecooo, however yesterday when moving my rig to a new case, some of my braided PCI-E extensions were loose, a firm thrust back in, silence. I agree with the above consensus. Whine certainly comes from loose pins/poor materials.

wow - i did not know that! very interesting!
 
Which makes/models in particular would be good for suppressing noise?

Buying a couple of top quality PCI-E cables would be much more preferable to forking out for a new psu which may or may not solve the issue.
 
The squealing you hear is most likely as others have mentioned is capacitor/coil whine. This is caused by oscillating action in the currents/voltages.

The cause of this noise/fluctuations are hard to pin down, as they could be from various sources, the PSU, the card, other devices, EMI, mains.
High frame rates often cause sequel, as higher frequencies/refresh rates are passed through the card/PSU increasing the tendency for the unwanted high frequency noise to make the capacitors/coils vibrate in such a manner.

Very often inside PSU's it looks like someone has had a accident with a glue gun. With huge splodges of glue on top of capacitors/coils. I suspect that the reason for this is to dampen the noise generated by these vibrations as well as to insulate the components.

See for example this image of a reasonably respected psu.. "Glue" has been dropped on/around the capacitors/coils.
glue.gif


My understanding is that is not necessarily a sign of poor quality components, more just a result of the way components/electricity interact with each other and the resulting effects.

Sometimes a PSU can cause the components on the gfx card to whine, sometimes the gfx card can cause the components of the PSU to whine, sometimes even the motherboard/cpu or dvd drive could have an effect on another component.

Often the part making the noise is not the cause.

So what can you do.. It maybe easier/cheaper to not worry about the cause and try and fix the issue. the end result is the same, no/less noise.

1) Try and filter out these unwanted frequencies that cause the problems using filtered PCI-X/Power cables. Even noise from the mains electricity could be passed on. Some "kettle leads" have these filters, or maybe a UPS/filtered power-strip may help.
2) Locate the "whining component" and slap some "glue" or I have heard people using nail varnish to stop it vibrating. A paper tube held to the ear is a good way to pin point which part is making the noise. (only issue here is that doing so "may" invalidate warranty..
3) It is entirely possible the card or PSU or even another component is just not up to scratch, and replacing it may solve the issue. Or it may just have different tolerances with the other components in the system.. A squealing card/psu won't necessarily behave in the same way when used by another person/system. I'd expect some PSU's have varying tolerances to this, however from experience just because they are high end, has not shown them to be more or less susceptible.
4) Some people can't hear the high frequencies, as we get older this range of high pitch noises should become less of a problem.. try waiting 10+ years.

5) I am no expert, all posted is just from observations. I have little knowledge of the internals of PSU's or capacitors/coils.. The technical terms I have used are no doubt wrong, the meaning however should not be , having had encountered this problem so many times, the above is just my findings. ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom