Am I being 'tight' not wanting to share my broadband with a mate?

Joined
27 Jul 2005
Posts
13,321
Location
The Orion Spur
As some of you may know I moved into a new flat recently, my Broadband gets activated on the 5th of Jan, now I've had Broadband since the first trials began and I've never really liked to share my internet connection, it's my most favoured luxury, I use it for just about everything, I haven't watched TV for 5 years now, I've only ever shared my internet once which was in my old place as my landlord kinda forced me into it as he said he let me have a phone line installed in my room and it was nothing but problems with buffering on videos and poor pings etc due to limited bandwidth at times.

Now since moving into my new place coincidently an old friend of mine was living in the front flat who I have been out of contact with for quite a few years, he is a good guy who has had a lot of problems, dad died of cancer last year and now his mum has it, I thought this information was pertinent as I don't want him to be made out as just a bum, he helps look after his mum atm, now the thing is he is knows I'm getting BB installed which is costing me £130 for a new line and £30 a month, but he is expecting me just to hand over a wi-fi code, now I'm really not keen on doing this but I feel compelled to due to his personal circumstances, now he is not working, granted he is helping his mum although his brother and sister still manage to work and he was not working long before his parents got ill anyway, he 'smokes' everyday which I told him would easily pay for a decent BB package if he cut down or gave up.

Now am I being an arse not wanting to share my BB?, BB is the only thing I really have in my life and I'm only working part time atm and have given up drinking to help pay for it as my new place is more expensive, I've emphasized the cost to him a few times now but he hasn't offered to chip in.

UPDATE -

Just a small update, I decided to tell him I'd prefer not to share my connection, I thought he took it ok until today when I spoke to him and he basically said we're not friends any more and to make sure I stay out of his way, <sigh>, he said that because he's my friend I should let him use it and by not doing so apparently "I think very little of him" and "I'm a selfish person".

You see this is why I don't like doing stuff like this, I knew not letting him use it would create a problem, that bugged me, I've spent far too much of my life being a people pleaser, doing things I don't want to do to appease others to disable potential threats or issues, I've had enough living like that, it's my stuff and I quite simply would prefer to not share, especially with people that get aggressive if I choose not to.

Partly what got him riled up was when I mentioned his 'smoke', I said I don't see why I should share my connection with you when your wasting your money on that 'stuff', that would pay for his own phone and BB package 5 times over, probably more, he don't work, his behind in rent, never really pays off any of his bills, council tax, tv license etc, if I share my connection with him I become an enabler, tbhfh he needs to grow up, if he wants BB then he's going to have to sort his priorities out, I'm not giving in on this one.
 
Last edited:
I do not think so.

But if you wanted to you could get a router with QoS and prioritise your traffic and throttle his download/upload speeds or guarantee a minimum rate for you.

I run this setup at home on a 20Mb connection and do not notice any difference, even when family are hammering iPlayer etc.
 
I don't think so. He doesn't sound like a great 'mate' and shouldn't just expect you to hand over a wifi code.

Ask him to chip in or tell him no.
 
Check if your router has QoS (Quality of Service) controls, it could be that you could rate limit his usage, or prioritise your traffic over his so it wouldn't affect you.
 
As with the above - see if you can afford a modem/software which can prioritise traffic or limit access.

You should also know that you'd be held accountable if he was caught downloading anything he shouldn't.
 
Meh, I would, as long as he knows he can't be using on demand services all day long etc.

If it's for just using now and again, I wouldn't have a problem with it. As soon as it impacts my service, I'd change the key
 
Would him chipping in make you feel OK about sharing your BB? I think it is the done thing to share your BB with a flat mate and sharing the bill, however asking on this type of forum will likely get you skewed answers. I think you'll find most of us are protective over our bandwidth.
 
I don`t think its mean at all If this guy smokes and hasn't offered to pay, then no don't share. Personal circumstances aside he could do anything and you would foot the bill (yes i know u can block sites etc). If he wants internet then he needs to pay for it or chip in.
 
Last edited:
If he wants to use it then he can pay half, he wouldnt ask to use your car all the time would he?
 
I wouldn't with another flat, you haven't seen the guy for a while and I believe you would be responsible for what he does online.

If you don't want to cause a fuss just hide the SSID so it looks like he can't get a signal.

Flatmates / Good friends I would obviously share with but this guy sounds selfish just from the way he asked. Will probs be on it all day downloading stuff.
 
It depends entirely on the type of usage. If he's a sometime browser and would usually be using it when I'm not around I wouldn't mind. If he's going to be hammering it then he'd be paying or not getting access.

The good thing is it's easy to change it if he's taking the mickey.
 
Stand firm! He needs to chip in! If you are going to throttle his connection then maybe £10 a month would be fair. It is also right that he contributes to the installation. Maybe not half but at least £30-£40

Trust me if you make concessions now he will just scrounge more and more off you. If he tries to guilt trip you then tell him to give up the smokes. In fact tell him if he gives up the smokes you will let him use the boradband free for 1 month
 
Back
Top Bottom