Most of the negative comments would apply to any MMO.
People are also talking as if the other P2P mmo's have balanced classes, I really want to know what game they are playing with perfect balance? - because I'm pretty certain it does not exist.
There is plenty of room for improvement I agree, but this game has allot it could offer (all of which isn't too hard to add).
- L50 PVP Bracket.
- High res textures.
- Green glow.
- Improved space combat.
- Swoop/pod racing.
- Pazzak.
- Customisable companion skills.
- More character customisation options.
- AA/texture distance draw distance improvment.
- Guild functionality (Bank/Levels/Capital-ship).
- Arena system.
- More battlezones (Some warzones, other sportzones like huttball, but different sports).
- Free flight space combat - ship visual customisation (this is pretty much player housing)
A fair few of those are in the works, or due in 1.1 or 1.2 - so I'm going to continue the sub.
The PVP is no worse than WoW, the PVE is also as good as WoW (buggier I agree, I recall ICC having a few serious bugs a year after release).
Crafting is no worse than WoW, questing is no worse than WoW.
I'm not sure what game people are comparing it too, only Warhammer on-line had better PVP./