Britain's fattest woman weighs 40STONE and is so big she hasn't been outside in FOUR years

I'm from Scotland and just shocked that none of these folk are based up here. I user to work with a guy who could eat her for lunch. Every breathe he took sounded like a motorboat
 
Castiel said:
I find it pretty disgusting that people have attitudes like yours....calling for a woman with an obvious health and psychological problem to be killed....

That is what is disgusting in this day and age.
Click to expand...

Whilst she has health issues, and if helped then help should be made available, it was her own decision to go down this path. She shouldn't be posing, smiling, for pictures with lots of awful food adorning her (I struggled to see where she ended and the bed began).

She should be told that she is in the wrong, and it isn't good that she is that size.

I have sympathy for people with many problems, but for her to eat herself to such a state and to not do anything serious about it? No, I won't feel sorry for her.
 
SKYNHEDD said:
Noo honestly..

.
Click to expand...

This woman needs help, not murdering. She obviously has an eating disorder, psychological issues regarding her self-worth and esteem issues....she also doesn't need people like you reinforcing her self-esteem problems and not only are you insulting to her, but to members on this forum that are or have struggled with weight problems.

The world could do with less of you to be entirely frank.
 
Castiel said:
This woman needs help, not murdering. She obviously has an eating disorder, psychological issues regarding her self-worth and esteem issues....she also doesn't need people like you reinforcing her self-esteem problems and not only are you insulting to her, but to members on this forum that are or have struggled with weight problems.

The world could do with less of you to be entirely frank.
Click to expand...

What dont u understand here...

When she was 20 odd stone this would have been valid for sure.

At this stage now, there is NO going back. She will NEVER EVER be of benefit to anyone. Her body is wrecked permanently. When people get this big, even when they "slim" down, they cost us a fortune in cosmetic surgery to remove the hideous left over bedsheet like folds of skin.

What I am saying is that early in the process of becoming a disgusting entity there could have been help, but not now, its too far gone.

I cant help being disgusted by someone so vulgar and fat.

Can you imagine what Africans and other hungry poor people must think when they see unnacceptable sights like this?

I think there should be a cut off.... a certain weight whereby heathcare is NOT free anymore, and see how many of these hideous beings continue to gorge themselves.
 
elmarko1234 said:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error

May be worth a read for a few in here, I'll bet good money she has a history of neglect/abuse or underline mental issues which cause this kind of behaviour.

The fact she is actively killing herself with food is a pretty good indicator of an unstable mind.
Click to expand...

Or she's just a fat cow that likes pizza?

Yes, she may have a health issue but it's also perfectly reasonable that she does. We are far too quick to rule that peoples faults aren't because the person is at fault but because they have some underlying dubious illness.

If we relied less on wishy washy, unprovable, medicine and instead called a spade a spade and instilled a sense of personal responsibility back into society then the country would be a much better place.
 
Ahleckz said:
Whilst she has health issues, and if helped then help should be made available, it was her own decision to go down this path. She shouldn't be posing, smiling, for pictures with lots of awful food adorning her (I struggled to see where she ended and the bed began).

She should be told that she is in the wrong, and it isn't good that she is that size.

I have sympathy for people with many problems, but for her to eat herself to such a state and to not do anything serious about it? No, I won't feel sorry for her.
Click to expand...


Everyone makes choices that can adversely affect their health, that doesn't mean she either understood or realised until it was too late that she was in this cycle....she may have had weight issues since childhood, she may have an eating disorder, she may have a genetic issue, she may have an addiction, she may have any number of problems that both contribute and exacerbate her problems...

This woman doesn't need ridicule and shunning, and she certainly doesn't need the OP calling for her murder.....

She needs help, both medically and psychologically.....the underlying issues on why she overeats need to be addressed, be they depression, addiction, or a combination of issues.

People are overweight for any number of issues, those who are really overweight, generally have an underlying problem....I did, and I dealt with it....but I got help, including from people on this very forum. It is not easy, it is not about simply not eating as much, it is not about being lazy or a glutton....it often has a deep-seated underlying source that needs to be faced and dealt with.

But attitudes like I have read in this thread are disgusting and say more about the prevailing attitudes of those posting than the people they are berating.

This woman needs help, not ridicule.
 
'Cherry picking' health system already exists, SKYNHEDD, as to whether she is of benefit to anyone, well, perhaps that question should be turned around to the questioner.

Anyone can make a presumption based on nothing but newspaper articles yet do you really want to believe the real world is a blissful world when it remains ignorant of facts before making judgement.
 
SKYNHEDD said:
What dont u understand here...

When she was 20 odd stone this would have been valid for sure.

At this stage now, there is NO going back. She will NEVER EVER be of benefit to anyone. Her body is wrecked permanently. When people get this big, even when they "slim" down, they cost us a fortune in cosmetic surgery to remove the hideous left over bedsheet like folds of skin.

What I am saying is that early in the process of becoming a disgusting entity there could have been help, but not now, its too far gone.

I cant help being disgusted by someone so vulgar and fat.

Can you imagine what Africans and other hungry poor people must think when they see unnacceptable sights like this?

I think there should be a cut off.... a certain weight whereby heathcare is NOT free anymore, and see how many of these hideous beings continue to gorge themselves.
Click to expand...



You are talking out of your arse.

read about this chap......he was 40stone....was he too far gone.

http://theamazing39stonecyclist.wordpress.com/about/

You are more ignorant and of less benefit to anyone than the very people you consistently obsess about, if it is not Muslims, it is Immigrants, if not Immigrants, it is people on benefits, if not them it is the Obese.....

get over yourself.
 
Castiel said:
Everyone makes choices that can adversely affect their health, that doesn't mean she either understood or realised until it was too late that she was in this cycle....she may have had weight issues since childhood, she may have an eating disorder, she may have a genetic issue, she may have an addiction, she may have any number of problems that both contribute and exacerbate her problems...

This woman doesn't need ridicule and shunning, and she certainly doesn't need the OP calling for her murder.....

She needs help, both medically and psychologically.....the underlying issues on why she overeats need to be addressed, be they depression, addiction, or a combination of issues.

People are overweight for any number of issues, those who are really overweight, generally have an underlying problem....I did, and I dealt with it....but I got help, including from people on this very forum. It is not easy, it is not about simply not eating as much, it is not about being lazy or a glutton....it often has a deep-seated underlying source that needs to be faced and dealt with.

But attitudes like I have read in this thread are disgusting and say more about the prevailing attitudes of those posting than the people they are berating.

This woman needs help, not ridicule.
Click to expand...

While you are correct about supporting her with her obvious issues, I think it's just as important to examine just how she has been allowed to gorge herself to this size.

Also, you can't diminish or ignore personal responsibility simply because the actions have led you to become a victim. Of course it's not a simple issue, but I wouldn't be surprised if it came down to her becoming depressed (not necessarily medically, but just unhappy), gained weight, felt bad about it, ate more - developed an emotional attachment to food, and kept eating.
 
Last edited:
Castiel said:
Everyone makes choices that can adversely affect their health, that doesn't mean she either understood or realised until it was too late that she was in this cycle....she may have had weight issues since childhood, she may have an eating disorder, she may have a genetic issue, she may have an addiction, she may have any number of problems that both contribute and exacerbate her problems...

This woman doesn't need ridicule and shunning, and she certainly doesn't need the OP calling for her murder.....

She needs help, both medically and psychologically.....the underlying issues on why she overeats need to be addressed, be they depression, addiction, or a combination of issues.

People are overweight for any number of issues, those who are really overweight, generally have an underlying problem....I did, and I dealt with it....but I got help, including from people on this very forum. It is not easy, it is not about simply not eating as much, it is not about being lazy or a glutton....it often has a deep-seated underlying source that needs to be faced and dealt with.

But attitudes like I have read in this thread are disgusting and say more about the prevailing attitudes of those posting than the people they are berating.

This woman needs help, not ridicule.
Click to expand...

I agree, she doesn't need ridicule or shuning. I was sure SKYNHEAD was being purposefully antagonistic when he called for her murder, but that's by the by. I'm sure no one honestly feels she should be murdered - I know that I don't.

She may have all of those things, but my point is that she may not. She may just really like the taste of pizza and Irn Bru.

She needs to be told that her behaviour isn't appropriate and it needs to change. She shouldn't be told "Oh, it's OK. You've got a health problem, it's not your fault." It bloody well is, every time she picks up the 2nd slice of pizza or she unscrews another bottle of fizzy drink she needs to know that she shouldn't be doing it whilst at her current size.

I'm unsure if you're saying my attitude is disgusting or not, but I stand by it. This woman needs to be welcomed in by the health professionals and those who can help her get down to a 'safer' weight. But the health professionals need to be ruthless about it, and not allow her to make excuses for her failures.
 
elmarko1234 said:
+1.

I may not agree with you on everything Castiel but this is right on the mark.

Normal happy & mentally stable people don't get that way, she's obviously got more problem than most of us & most likely needs medical help & counselling.

Have people not heard of eating disorders?.
Click to expand...

This.. I am finding more and more the attitudes of some of the forum members here to be juvenile and downright pathetic.

As a matter of fact those attitudes can also be a contributing factor of why people get like this. Too many times do people get overweight due to a various reasons but having people call them a fat **** or someother slur in public will compound the matter.

Grow up, realise that there are a multitude of reasons why people get like this not just because they have a perchant for chips/cake/kebabs/takeaway and realise people like this need help not ridicule.
 
Last edited:
Castiel said:
You are talking out of your arse.

read about this chap......he was 40stone....was he too far gone.

http://theamazing39stonecyclist.wordpress.com/about/

You are more ignorant and of less benefit to anyone than the very people you consistently obsess about, if it is not Muslims, it is Immigrants, if not Immigrants, it is people on benefits, if not them it is the Obese.....

get over yourself.
Click to expand...

Lol what a load of rubbish, he was nothing like the mega fat people we keep seeing in the news.

Just check out the links to the other fatties in the previous pages, and you will see the error of your ways.

These people deserve nothing but contempt when it reaches this stage.
 
Gackt said:
While you are correct about supporting her with her obvious issues, I think it's just as important to examine just how she has been allowed to gorge herself to this size.
Click to expand...

Of course it is important, that is the most important thing to do, to find out why and deal with them.

She may well have just eaten and eaten until she was in a cycle she couldn't get out of......you hit a point that even when you want to do something about it, it is hard, very hard to even reduce the calorie intake.....especially with someone who is enabling that habit.

The issue here is that she needs help, not ridicule, all ridicule will do is reinforce her habit and validate her lack of self esteem....
 
SKYNHEDD said:
Lol what a load of rubbish, he was nothing like the mega fat people we keep seeing in the news.

Just check out the links to the other fatties in the previous pages, and you will see the error of your ways.

These people deserve nothing but contempt when it reaches this stage.
Click to expand...

He was almost 40 Stone. The same weight as the woman you want to murder.

The only person who deserves nothing but contempt is you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom