• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Best sub £200 Card

PMSL at you trying to convince a 570 owner, and Battlefield 3 player, that it uses more than 1.25GB of VRAM in multilayer at 1080P.

That's news to me because at 1200P in Ultra/High (mixture of settings) I use less than 1.25GB.

Anyway the VRAM argument is old and boring and Danzal doesn't want his thread trashing anymore than you have done already so you can have the final say and I'll more on to something more interesting (and factually correct).

I see 1453mb -/+ vram usage in bf3 at 1080p
 
I hate to tell you this but you're the one sounding touchy and anal. You say Spency is hypocritical but that is the exact same trait you're displaying.

I said you were wrong to suggest a 570 (as you say this is an opinion based thing) and you started getting all funny by basically saying that anyone that disagrees with you is anal when all they're doing is giving an opinion. You flew off the handle about VRAM and haven't calmed down since.

All that happened from what I can see is people giving their opinions which is itself your own defence for saying what you're saying. Fine. So why all the bloody drama?

I think Cagerty summed it up best.

The reason I'm posting though is I can't understand why this thread has turned into an unpleasant slanging match. The OP posted a thread asking for advice on what GFX card to get. One guy advised to get a 570, the other a 7850. It is up to the OP to make an informed decision and do his homework by reading reviews, benchmarks etc. There is no need to shoot the other guy down in flames just because he recommended a 570! He is entitled to his opinion as much as the next man. He did also mention that both were very good cards. Let's keep this thread a little more positive and constructive as I'm sure the OP originally thought it was going to be. :)

Opinions are opinions, we're all allowed our own. I wasn't the one throwing childish "fanboyism" accusations about however (not saying you were either) so I think it's a tad unfair, and inaccurate, to say I created "the drama". Everyone, yourself included, is at least partly responsible for any drama that ensued.
 
Last edited:
In fairness to Griff. Anandtech give the 570 the lead "on stock". The trouble is and I say this with gritted teeth....VRAM. I am staunch or was tbf in the fact that 1GB was plenty and 1.25 was more than enough but with games like BF3/Skyrim (modded)/Max Payne 3, we are seeing that amount of VRAM being used to the max and sometimes even a little over. Future games could be the telling point and I recommend the 7850 purely for a little more future proofing.

For the OP's sake, lets advise him to the best of our knowledge :)

570 v 7850
 
In fairness to Griff. Anandtech give the 570 the lead "on stock". The trouble is and I say this with gritted teeth....VRAM. I am staunch or was tbf in the fact that 1GB was plenty and 1.25 was more than enough but with games like BF3/Skyrim (modded)/Max Payne 3, we are seeing that amount of VRAM being used to the max and sometimes even a little over. Future games could be the telling point and I recommend the 7850 purely for a little more future proofing.

For the OP's sake, lets advise him to the best of our knowledge :)

570 v 7850

I'm always willing to learn, more so from my mistakes, and I'm of an age where I'm happy to admit my wrongs so tonight I changed my BF3 video settings to "Ultra" (and the associated settings that go with it).

Playing on a 32 man server (hardcore not that I guess it makes a difference) we played Seine Crossing and another map that escapes me for now (the one with the carrier, and the animation of a beach being carpet bombed for want of a better expression, at the start). Edit - Khargh Island (SP?!)

While Afterburner showed VRAM usage close to the limit of my 570 if didn't reach the 1250MB point in over an hours worth of play. Maybe Afterburner wasn't reporting accurately or there's another explanation but, and in good faith, I can only base my opinions on what I see in front of me.

I also agree though that future games will have an increased impact on VRAM.
 
Last edited:
Were you using 4xAA as well? HBAO?

Yeah, sorry I should have elaborated but that's what I meant by associated settings. When you select the "Ultra" preset it automatically turns AA to "4x" and turns on "HBAO".

Normally I'd run custom settings as I prefer a higher framerate but I selected Ultra to test the VRAM usage for myself.
 
Yeah, sorry I should have elaborated but that's what I meant by associated settings. When you select the "Ultra" preset it automatically turns AA to "4x" and turns on "HBAO".

Normally I'd run custom settings as I prefer a higher framerate but I selected Ultra to test the VRAM usage for myself.

I did the same with my 1GB 560TI but it went over the 1GB and it turned into a slideshow. I always suspected that 1.25 was enough but was never sure. Good to see it is :)

On a side note, I could player the SP on ultra with no probs. IIRC I was getting around 40fps which wasn't bad for a 560.
 
Yeah, sorry I should have elaborated but that's what I meant by associated settings. When you select the "Ultra" preset it automatically turns AA to "4x" and turns on "HBAO".

Normally I'd run custom settings as I prefer a higher framerate but I selected Ultra to test the VRAM usage for myself.

Hmmm, strange, I wonder if it uses more on AMD cards as mine can touch 1.5GB when I run ultra. I know this is probably a ridiculous idea as it should use the same when using either brand card.
 
Hmmm, strange, I wonder if it uses more on AMD cards as mine can touch 1.5GB when I run ultra. I know this is probably a ridiculous idea as it should use the same when using either brand card.

Mine will show as much as 1.8GB usage. This is because it stores data in the spare VRAM for later use. 7970's can report over 2GB being used.
 
Hmmm, strange, I wonder if it uses more on AMD cards as mine can touch 1.5GB when I run ultra. I know this is probably a ridiculous idea as it should use the same when using either brand card.

Not wanting to add fuel to the fire but if it helps I'm happy to take screenshots tomorrow showing Afterburner running.
 
surely at stock neither card is powerful enough to run BF3 with everything cranked up at a decent framerate on a multiplayer map.

for the OP I would wait, if your not in a hurry, in a couple of weeks the 660 will arrive and it at least should shake up the midrange market.

of course all the advice in the world doesn't help when we don't really know anything about your system, what your going to be using it for, if you will be overclocking ETC
 
Not wanting to add fuel to the fire but if it helps I'm happy to take screenshots tomorrow showing Afterburner running.

I've seen reports of 1.25GB cards running out of VRAM in 64 player servers with full maxed settings.

I do however believe that cards are more efficient with their VRAM when they're closer to the limit. It's true that VRAM is overplayed a lot (I am one of the biggest anti "get more VRAM" posters on here) but the truth is that if you're buying a card now there isn't any reason to run 'close to the wire' when you can get an equivalent (arguably better considering overclocked performance) card with more VRAM for the same money.

Andybird123 ran out of VRAM in BF3 MP with a 1.5GB 580 so the evidence is there.

The whole 2GB vs 3GB VRAM debate is more clear cut though. My two 680's can't run out of VRAM even at 5780*1080. This is because they run out of GPU power (20-30FPS) long before they get can close to actually using the settings that would cause them to run out of VRAM.

Edit: I say long before, 2xMSAA is borderline unplayable in parts (mostly fine though) but no MSAA and FXAA is fine all the time with averages of around 80-90.
 
Back
Top Bottom