Just added SACD capability to my system for £50

Man of Honour
Man of Honour
Joined
23 Dec 2002
Posts
10,355
Location
London
Before I say anymore about my own system, thought I'd give a little history about my daliance with SACD.

First heard one in the Sony building in Ginza back in 2000. Spent half a day in their rather large shop, just playing with various bits of kit. Highlight was their auditorium with a huge system and fronted by what was clearly a rather expensive SACD player. No idea what any of it was, but it was definitely NOT the sort of stuff you'd find in Tottenham court road. Either way, it was clearly a quiet day, and I got to spend nearly an hour in there all on my own, just meadering through a few tracks. Came across very well, but was hard to really understand how good because of unfamiliarity with the rest of the system.

In 2003, borrowed a £400 Marantz SACD capable DVD player for a weekend. Compared it to my Naim CD5i. The Naim walked all over it on CD, but with the same track being played on the SACD player and the Marantz was IMO roughly on par with the Naim, but did so at half the cost. I was quite impressed, but also very conscious about the lack of SACDs and that I'd probably want to buy a better player than the Marantz, and at the time, funds were better spent elsewhere in my system.

Bought a Pioneer 575a for DVD playback in 2004, which happened to have SACD. Unfortunately it was reliant upon it's own DACs/PSU/analogue output sections, and even with an SACD disk was still miles adrift from the CDP I was using by then.


Fast forward to 2012, and a new opportunity has arrisen. Some BD players now incorporate SACD playback and can output DSD converted to LPCM via HDMI. Sure, it IS being converted, but does mean that I can now rely on the decoding by my processor as against some cheap and nasty single box BD solution. In short, all I needed was a BD player to act as an SACD transport. Step forward last years Pioneer BDP140, as part of being discontinued and sold off at nearly 2/3rds discount by a well known seller of CA products.
Tested it in store to ensure no SACD hybrid incompatibility issues (some forums mention this on early firmware versions of the player). All seemed fine, so coughed up the dosh and took it home. Very easy to setup, plugged in the network cable and had the latest firmware onboard within 10 mins of power up.

And how does it sound? Bloody good with SACD. Basically all the good bits of 24 bit recordings that I've bought over the last couple of years, i.e. smoother more analogue mid range, massively better "placement" of instruments and vocals, lower background noise and really well controlled and natural bass. Sure, means I'll need to buy some discs, but there's now a back catalogue of around 8000 disks (shame most are classical, but you can't win them all).
For £50, a real no brainer.

Might also be able to give my PS3 a rest on BD/DVD playback as an added bonus.
 
I only have 4, and I've had my player for 3 years now :o

They're all sat in a box somewhere from my last move, I'll have to look them out :)
 
I've only heard one SACD, and it was absolutely fab.

But SACD is a shame really. It's an excuse to not bother making high quality recordings on standard CDs, and thus promote the format as the cause of the newfound quality :(

But for £50, it's probably not worth the argument / worry!
 
hmm trying to think which ones ivegot now ...not in front of me ...erm

dark side of teh moon - hybrid
war of the worlds - hybrid
heathen - david bowie - sacd
bruce springsteen live in new york - sacd
brothers in arms - dire straits - hybrid
hot rocks - rolling stones - hybrid

avoid the genesis ones .. really bad mixing ive heard .. shame as i wanted them as well

heathen by bowie is awesome
 
Last edited:
avoid the genesis ones .. really bad mixing ive heard .. shame as i wanted them as well

Good point. Yes, the Genesis ones are dreadful. Completely brickwalled. Again, stick to the original CD releases.

I did buy the box sets when they were new and didn't have any reviews out there... :(
 
Slight O/T but I'm heading back that way in a few weeks, is it worth a visit to have a nose around?

Dunno, that was 12 years ago, so might have changed. At the time, I thought it was worth the effort and enjoyed my several hours there.
 
DSOTM is one of the few resmastered albums that makes a good use of surround sound, there arent many of them . Tubular bells isnt bad i guess.

DSOTM had a original mix done in quadraphonic surround - made a pretty simple job to expand to 5.1

The Quad mix is now officially available for the first time on the DSOTM Immersion box set. Well worth buying. The Bluray is impressive.
 
Back
Top Bottom