Soldato
- Joined
- 16 Nov 2010
- Posts
- 16,513
- Location
- Swimming in a lake
Ok guys. Let's have a bit of fun.
What do we reckon is the greatest all round fitness sport?
By this I mean, a combination of strength, strength endurance, flexibility, cardio, skill etc....
I'm going off of my short list of say 5.
This is what I have (organised alphabetically)
Ice Hockey
Gymnastics
MMA
Triathlon
Rugby
Water Polo
So interesting set of choices here, but let me justify each, and this may explain a few of the shortcomings.
Ice Hockey - Skating around, hitting things hard, including people often.
Gymnastics - incredible strength, stuff they do on the dips etc.. They also have huge flexibility. Endurance is arguably not quite as impressive as some of the other sports though.
MMA - Any list that has looked at fitness has always included Boxing. For obvious reasons. Now take that, and throw in more skill, and arguably more brutality.
Triathlon - arguably the king of endurance sports. Supposedly it was invented because cyclist, swimmers and runners couldn't decide who was the fittest. Hence triathlon was created.
Rugby - Arguably obvious, men running around the field hitting each other. Kind of. A lot of fitness and strength required here, and much harder than any other field based sport in my opinion.
Water Polo - I feel people may laugh at this one. But here me out for something that is relatively unknown as a sport and not what you think as your hotel pool fun in real life. Swimming in general is seen as a great sign of fitness. So try treading water for fifteen minutes. Add swimming up and down the pool constantly into that with no breaks, and no touching the bottom of the pool. Add into it the fact that you're constantly, pushing, kicking and trying to get away with whatever you can without the referee seeing under the water, and I'd argue it's one of the greatest all round fitness sport in my mind.
I'll add a poll in once we've had a few more opinions and ideas.
kd
What do we reckon is the greatest all round fitness sport?
By this I mean, a combination of strength, strength endurance, flexibility, cardio, skill etc....
I'm going off of my short list of say 5.
This is what I have (organised alphabetically)
Ice Hockey
Gymnastics
MMA
Triathlon
Rugby
Water Polo
So interesting set of choices here, but let me justify each, and this may explain a few of the shortcomings.
Ice Hockey - Skating around, hitting things hard, including people often.

Gymnastics - incredible strength, stuff they do on the dips etc.. They also have huge flexibility. Endurance is arguably not quite as impressive as some of the other sports though.
MMA - Any list that has looked at fitness has always included Boxing. For obvious reasons. Now take that, and throw in more skill, and arguably more brutality.
Triathlon - arguably the king of endurance sports. Supposedly it was invented because cyclist, swimmers and runners couldn't decide who was the fittest. Hence triathlon was created.
Rugby - Arguably obvious, men running around the field hitting each other. Kind of. A lot of fitness and strength required here, and much harder than any other field based sport in my opinion.
Water Polo - I feel people may laugh at this one. But here me out for something that is relatively unknown as a sport and not what you think as your hotel pool fun in real life. Swimming in general is seen as a great sign of fitness. So try treading water for fifteen minutes. Add swimming up and down the pool constantly into that with no breaks, and no touching the bottom of the pool. Add into it the fact that you're constantly, pushing, kicking and trying to get away with whatever you can without the referee seeing under the water, and I'd argue it's one of the greatest all round fitness sport in my mind.
I'll add a poll in once we've had a few more opinions and ideas.
kd
Last edited: