Im in the same boat, been playing a bit of LOTRO but i got to 40 and then found i had to buy quest areas to continue so i have since given up, downloaded Tera again, got as far as the character select screen and decided i couldnt even bring myself to login.
Path of Exile isnt my thing either, i got burnt on D3 and now i wont go near another of that type of game for a while lol. Taken to installing NWN2 again to pass the time.
Secret World is an odd one, i bought it at release, couldnt really get into it, i think i done all of the quests in that first area with the bay etc, then moved onto the next area through the tunnel but found i couldnt handle the mobs there so gave up, ive gone back a couple of times but just cant seem to get into it, i dunno what it is, cos it looks gorgeous and runs really well on my PC, i like the skill system and stuff and quite like the setting tho im normally a pure fantasy type player.
Something about TSW just doesnt gel with me, cant put my finger on it cos i really want to like it.