Anyone been on a cruise holiday?

Associate
Joined
30 Sep 2008
Posts
2,102
Some suggestions based on your experiences would be fantastic.
Me & my gf wish to go on a cruise holiday Sept this year but as I’m fairly clueless when it comes to destinations (I've only been to HK & Germany in 28 years of life) & the costs involved (up to £1500pp, 9 day), I want to make the most of it.

In my mind I see a tropical paradise with amazing beaches, lots of fun ship activities, endless eating, drinking & generally lying out in the sun reading a book.


Now I had my sights set on that new ship Oasis of the Sea which travels to:
Fort Lauderdale, Florida - Cruising - Labadee, Haiti - Falmouth, Jamaica - Cruising - Cozumel, Mexico - Cruising - Fort Lauderdale, Florida or.....

San Juan, Puerto Rico - St Croix - Philipsburg - St John's, Antigua - Castries - Bridgetown - San Juan, Puerto Rico. BUT my gf worries it'll be full of American families buying expensive watches, and she would probably be right.
I guess in the end if these cruises are soo much fun it’s impossible not to enjoy then we'll be fine.
 
Hi Ali,

I've been on a few cruises myself, my sister works on ships full time and I'm also a travel agent.

The Oasis and the Allure, are the two biggest ships in the world currently - with a passenger capacity of nearly 5000, they can be very busy in the peak season. However, there is a ridiculous amount of things to do on board. I would be very careful about what you drink though as every drink has an additional 15% service added, some ships offer a drinks package, and it is a massive bonus if you can secure one of these, my bar bill was $900 in 2 days, granted I was smashing it but it can easily get out of hand.

The Norwegian Epic does a Caribbean route in the winter, which is the best time to go - Aug/Sept is the end of the hurricane season, so you might want to go a little later, I usually recommend Jan/Feb to customers for that kind of trip, it's the nicest time for the Caribbean.

I've enjoyed every cruise I've been on, it's a nice way to see more things and not have to backpack between places!
 
I've been on several cruises but none to the Caribbean or on the Royal Caribbean line. I do believe that the currency on board is in $, and they have a compulsory tip system although someone may correct me if I'm wrong. There probably would be a higher % of Americans on board and that is something that would affect my decision to go on them. I know people who have done cruised around the Caribbean, they said it was lovely but it was all very samey unlike cruising the Med. I'm sure it would be lovely if you're happy with the points I've made, and all you really want is sun and relaxation. With it being in term time, there shouldn't be too many little ***** running around screaming and being a nuisance either.
 
What is wrong with rich Americans with superior time keeping devices? They sound delightful, just keep asking them what time it is so they can justify their investment.
 
I went two years ago (April) on a Caribbean cruise with Royal Caribbean (Adventure of the Seas) having gone as a group of 6... SUCH a great holiday.

We went outside of school holidays and it was in fact the last Caribbean trip before their European season started so we weren't 100% sure what the weather would be like but it was perfect.

I would say that during that time of year we did notice there were a lot of Puerto Ricans (given as it set off from there) but the majority were Brits, Germans and Puerto Ricans (50%+) and to be honest they know how to have fun and aren’t as brash as some American tourists (sorry!)

Haven't read all the advice above but here are a few things we discovered/recommend:
- Although we haven’t been with any cruise company other than Royal Caribbean, I simply do not see how they could have done more or done it any better
- Keep a look out for the deals both direct and through travel agents as there are some bargains to be had!
- Drinks – I wouldn’t bother getting their ‘bottomless’ drinks deal unless you’re addicted to coke or similar as there is free everything available in the Windjammer (ice tea, coffee, hot chocolate, various freshly made juices).
- We did get the balcony room and evening dining upgrade which were well worth it if you like something a little smarter (although you don’t have to eat there every evening, we did as it was really quite an event!)
- Excursions... Thomas Cook really messed these up for us and we ended up cancelling the ones we wanted to do before we got there as they simply couldn’t get their act together. The day before we went TC said that all the excursions we wanted to do were not available so were pretty disappointed. Well... arrive on the boat three days later and all excursions are available (granted, some were slightly different times) but it was good to do.
- Just to add on the excursions – depending what you want to do and where you go, you don’t necessarily have to spend silly money on excursions. Five of the Islands we stopped off at we wondered down the quay and there were minibuses waiting to take you anywhere on the Island and pick you up for $30 each (not cheap but much cheaper than boat excursions). We asked them to take us to the best snorkelling beaches or whatever we wanted to do and we were very fortunate in that we had reliable and knowledgeable drivers.
- Alcohol isn’t cheap on the boat but in all honesty, unless you’re on the lash each day it isn’t too bad. We had a bottle of wine with each meal, a few beers and after 12 days I think our drinks were $220 with service charge.

My inlaws have been on several cruises and have insisted they will only ever go with Royal Caribbean in future.

Overall we had a great time, we may have gone through a different travel agent but in all the trip (including flights/hotels etc) cost us £1500 per person (10 night cruise, 1 night stay each way).

My wife and I did agree that having a bunch of friends there did make all the difference, not that we don’t like going away just us but she could go off and do her girly things and the chaps could do whatever as well (usually sat in the hot tub eating free ice cream and bottles of Carib!)

If you’re in the position to afford a cruise I’d say go for it and if you’re unsure where then you can’t go wrong with the Caribbean IMO.

Edited to add: ship set off from Puerto Rico – Barbados – St Lucia – Martinique – Antigua - St. Maarten – US Virgin Islands – Puerto Rico

Barbados – swam with turtles (best thing ever!) and went for a catamaran trip which was superb. We did find what we saw of Barbados as very commercialised and expensive

St. Lucia – nice island, I know a lot of people don’t like it for some reason but we had a great time and some lovely beaches

Martinique – French but nice, again lovely beaches

Antigua – my 2nd favourite place. Great beaches with some lovely places to explore. Great people and showed us great areas of the island. Found a beach that looked over towards Montserrat which was really interesting.

St. Kitts – nice islands, fairly commercialised the parts we saw as it is base to quite a few corporate financial groups. I think it was here we did some whale watching – only saw some false killer whales but is a risk you take with these sorts of trips. Rather have done some fishing here to be honest.

St Maarten – great place, lovely people. We went to the beach that sits as the end of the runway and we were there for 5 hours (felt like 5 minutes). Great fun and our best day for sure. Lovely beaches and interesting history as well.

US Virgin Islands – could have left this one out and stayed on the boat had I know. Beach was OK but just way too commercialised, infact to a point where it was a bit of a culture shock as we were used to palm trees and banana trees by this point.

Puerto Rico – after staying overnight here at the beginning of our holiday it was nice enough but we weren’t hugely impressed (reminded me of Lisbon in Portugal, quite tired looking place, poor) so just chilled out on the boat until we were booted off.
 
Last edited:
Molinari, the med is something i know my gf would be more inclined to go for & did offer it as an alternative. Norwegian Cruise Lines looks cheaper than Royal Caribbean as well. My manager also warned about hurricane season.
Do you pay for all your drinks with card/cash or do you get some generic ID card they 'swipe' at the till?
 
I'm doing a Western Med cruise in a few weeks with Royal, will do a detailed review with pics :D
 
Molinari, the med is something i know my gf would be more inclined to go for & did offer it as an alternative. Norwegian Cruise Lines looks cheaper than Royal Caribbean as well. My manager also warned about hurricane season.
Do you pay for all your drinks with card/cash or do you get some generic ID card they 'swipe' at the till?
You generally use your room keycard/ID card and they charge all costs (drinks, food, spa treatments, excursions etc..) to your account which you then settle at the end of the cruise. Can get pricey if you get carried away :).
 
RC Cruises, drinks/et al are paid for via a card linked to your details, can check it any time in your stateroom. If you get a drinks/soda package they will place a sticker on the card so that the barperson/attendant will be aware of it.

Can't fault Royal Carribbean, been on 4 cruises with them, 2 med, one West Carribbean and a few months ago a 12 day Med cruise. Was bliss.
 
Celebrity is even better, fewer families, and more 5 star and 4 star (ratings aren't directly comparable to hotel ratings).
 
Been on a few Disney cruises and cant fault them tbh.

Although if you hate Disney then you probably wont like them.

Apparently their the best ships in the world :)
 
I've done plenty of Cruises and Mariner of the Seas with the Royal Caribbean was by far the best. They really have an idea on how to build ships with entertainment vs say MSC cruise lines, they are also more full of younger folk.

I think go for what you put in the OP, Oasis of the Seas 9 day Caribbean and you will find it awesomeballs!
 
I've done plenty of Cruises and Mariner of the Seas with the Royal Caribbean was by far the best. They really have an idea on how to build ships with entertainment vs say MSC cruise lines, they are also more full of younger folk.

I think go for what you put in the OP, Oasis of the Seas 9 day Caribbean and you will find it awesomeballs!

Out of curiosity, what are the age ranges of passengers on cruises? Both Med and Carib?
 
Out of curiosity, what are the age ranges of passengers on cruises? Both Med and Carib?

Varies more by brand and seasonality than by location.

Royal is very much family orientated, and marketing has been done down that route (they have a contract with Dreamworks), but families will be more prevalent during school holidays (duh).

20/30s without kids are the smallest demographic, but there has been a gradual upward trend over the past decade.
 
How much do these things cost? Especially the Carribean ones... I like the idea of seeing a load of different places. I get bored staying in one spot and have done the backpacking thing already - I'm older now and need my creature comforts. :p

Has anyone done one on their own or does it tend to be more a "couples" thing?
 
How much do these things cost? Especially the Carribean ones... I like the idea of seeing a load of different places. I get bored staying in one spot and have done the backpacking thing already - I'm older now and need my creature comforts. :p

Has anyone done one on their own or does it tend to be more a "couples" thing?

Rooms are intended for up to 4 people, but you can pay a single person supplement.

Provided you pick the larger ships, there is plenty to do on them, more than enough for a 7 nighter. Prices vary.

Celebrity are currently doing a flash sale. Eclipse for 14 nights from Southampton to the Canaries and back, in October.

Interior: £999 per person
Ocean view: £1099
Balcony: £1299

So for a balcony, that's £93 per person, per night, which includes food and basic drinks (water, squash, teas). Not shabby.
 
What's people view on the rooms? My manager said you def need a balcony but then how much time do you spend drinking/admiring from it? The med is cheaper thus upgrading is not a massive decision but the Carribean ones can push it quite high.

We spotted one the ships at Southampton last weekend while visiting IOW, was gutted not to be on :)
 
Last edited:
The ability to get fresh air, and generally relax there (you can get 24 hour room service, so breakfasts on the balcony can be preferred to getting dressed for main dining) are apparently worth it. Very handy if you get seasick, or get claustrophobic.
 
Out of curiosity, what are the age ranges of passengers on cruises? Both Med and Carib?

What krooton said really, when I did Mariner of the Seas around Caribbean (3rd largest ship at the time) it was late Sept there were TONS of 20-30s on board the first week, mostly American (which doesn't bother me in the slightest - make for great conversation actually). The second week not so much. So hit and miss.

I did a Greek cruise and stay on the Emerald which was enjoyable as I was with my wife (pre-children) but the ship was a very small one and we were probably the youngest on board.

A few weeks back we came back (with 2 toddlers) from a week of a Norwegian Fjords cruise on the MSC Opera (MSC are an Italian cruise line). And it was a heavy mix of ages, plenty of young families plenty of 20-30s couples and of course a heafty dose of the oldies.

My advice would be to stick to the Royal Caribbean cruise line and aim for the biggest ships. Old folk don't want too much on board entertainment or like the largest ships, it is us younger people that don't want the old traditional cruising experience we want a big ass floating 5 star hotel and interesting places to get off and explore.
 
Back
Top Bottom