At first silica seemed to be the magic elixir tire engineers longed for, but they soon realized it too offered no free ride: its lower rolling resistance came at the expense of lower durability, decreased traction in wet weather...
And low rolling resistance doesn't have that much to do with grip, nor is it necessary for a tire with low rolling resistance to resist deformation (and that's not how the high silica tires are doing it):
As much as 90 percent of a tire’s rolling resistance can be attributed to hysteresis--the dissipation of energy that occurs when the tread, sidewalls, and carcass of a tire are deformed as the tire rolls. The remaining 10 percent of resistance results from aerodynamic drag and the friction between the tire and the ground and between the tire and the rim.
Tires with low rolling resistance are ones which give back the energy which is put into them when they are deformed in the first place, as a good steel spring would, say-- a property known as low hysteresis.