Repairs more than cars worth

Associate
Joined
11 May 2009
Posts
1,040
Interested to see if its just me being an ass but a friend has recently bought himself a 2004 Suzuki alto for £750 from a mechanic, who claimed it was his mothers. Only 40,000 mileage and cosmetically looked good (if you ignore the fact it's a fugly car and he is 6" 5 and about the same around, its a very comical sight!)

It also has a new engine.... I would have walked away right there , but not my friend.

My alarm bells were ringing already as this friend seems to be able to pick a lemon a mile away. £8k on a rusty P reg land rover defender which caught light and insurance voided, followed by two road legal quad bikes amounting to about £10k only to sold because they kept breaking down.

"Don't just buy the first car you see for the love of God" I plead with him afterr many hours together on autotrader and review sites... But some people just cannot be helped.

The first evening of owning it he discovers the hot air is not working so takes it to the Suzuki garage. Thermostat broken, or "bent" to be accurate, they recon it had a second hand one fitted by previous owner.

£350.

A wheel bearing starts to clunk so gets this replaced.

£300ish

He decides that although he absolutely loves the car, it just isn't big enough for him and his fishing gear so wants to pull a trailor behind it. Problem is, there isn't a towbar and it needs a special swan neck removable version fitted. He finds a mobile mechanic and has it fitted at home.

I think this cost £400ish due to the special fitting of it.

The car starts losing water faster than he can fill it - something about the "matrex" (?) Needs replacing in the radiator. But this isn't a big deal he insists, he just carries around water with him and has to stop every so often.

£££

Electrics inside the car start to act up, in particular the rear window heater and lights. Has this fixed by same garage.

££

The head gasket is suspected to have gone and car is leaking water again as it boils over. The heating has also packed up again and needs yet another new thermostat.
He has now informed me that it needs milling down and will cost atleast another £650.

All this over a space of a few months I finally say something about it and suggest that he sells the car for scrap/find a good part ex offer and find a decent car, only to be met with denial and an overall defensive attitude that the car is brilliant and its just his luck with cars and that I should mind my own business.

Today he informs me that he is looking at entire engines on thebay for £200 to replace the current one as it would be cheaper and fix all the issues.

He has had this car since May. How much more can go wrong with this thing?!

How much would you spend before you finally called it quits? For the value of the car, I just cannot understand his logic when he could buy a decent modern car by saving these frequent bills. Ironically, he bought this small car because the last few "cost too much to run"..

The prices are ones he has given me, which looking back at them, are giving me doubts on their accuracy. I think the mechanics must be laughing whenever they need him.
 
Last edited:
Think I would have not bought it in the first place because of the size issue with the fishing gear. If not, then as soon as I realised my stuff wouldn't fit it would have been sold, rather than go to the hassle of having a towbar fitted + hitching up a trailer every time.
 
£350 for a thermostat? Is it made of solid gold?

Why is he taking it to a main dealer, an indi garage would be a far better idea for an old car.
 
£350 for a thermostat? Is it made of solid gold?

Why is he taking it to a main dealer, an indi garage would be a far better idea for an old car.
Labour on the S3 thermostat was similar because half the engine bay needed to be dismantled to access it.

On a Suzuki Alto I think not!
 
A fool and his money are soon parted. Thermostats are about 6 quid for example plus labour. I don't know what the point of the thread is though as he's obviously not going to listen to reason and nobody here would have gotten into that situation in the first place - what are you hoping to achieve? Or are you just having a laugh about your mate where he can't see it?:confused:
 
It sounds like the problem is not really the car, it's your friend. There is nothing wrong or unusual in spending more than the car's purchase price on repairs - in fact, when you get to anything much below a grand it's something that can easily happen just by replacing consumables like tyres and brakes, let alone things going wrong.

The problem sounds like your friend taking 10 year old cars to main dealers and accepting extortionate quotes for simple repairs, some of which sound highly dubious - a bent thermostat? The only way you can bend a thermostat is by driving over it before fitting it, and how the bill for that could amount to £350 is absolutely beyond me. The heating issues and associated head gasket failure sound entirely like poor preventative maintenence and a failure to carry out repairs when needed. If a component such as a radiator or heater matrix fails, carrying a bottle of water around is not the solution.

Our IT guys say that most issues they deal with are actually PICNIC - Problem In Chair, Not In Computer. I'd say the majority of your friend's issues are caused by a similar fault :p
 
Your friend needs to stop taking a cheap ****box car to the main dealers for repairs and he might save a few quid..
Buy cheap, expect problems, that's why they are cheap.
As for towing something with a Suzuki Alto LOLOLOLOL They don't have enough power to pull your foreskin back, let alone a trailer. What is he thinking!

My advice, stay well out of it and let him learn the hard way. Some people are just born to make bad choices.
 
Or are you just having a laugh about your mate where he can't see it?:confused:

You got me! But seriously, just wondered if it was just me or whether others thought it a huge waste.

Who knows, I might even show him this thread to maybe open his eyes.
 
I guess it depends on the circumstances - there's no problem spending more than the car's worth in repairs, if afterwards you end up with a car that's going to last you several years without needing money spent on it. However in this case it sounds like your mate has bought a car which wasn't suitable for him in the first place, and no amount of "repairs" is going to change that!
 
300 for a wheel bearing lol only cost £90 for my van and the hub had to be sent to a coach garage to be pressed out..... the garage to see him coming a mile away
 
To be fair, anyone who buys a road legal quad bike is probably a bit of a plank. Let alone two of them. :p
 
Back
Top Bottom