What's important when looking for an AiO liquid cooler?

Associate
Joined
25 Sep 2011
Posts
489
Location
Staffordshire, UK
Current setup:
  • Thermaltake Suppressor F51
  • Intel Core i7-6700K (OC'd to 4.4 Hz)
  • MSI Z170A Gaming Pro Carbon
  • Cooler Master Hyper 212 Evo
The temperatures are fine but the cooler is massive.

I am considering an all in one liquid cooler in order to keep the inside of my case "cleaner".

I doubt I'll overclock beyond 4.4 GHz.

I just made this:

4gkbdc.png


What should I be looking for?
 
While I haven't checked it out yet, I'm impressed with the new be quiet! Silent Loop coolers.

Fan specifications are only marginally useful. The CFM & dB is open air, not in use on radiator so not at all how we use them so not at all the CFM & dB with will get. mm H2O is maximum level H2O reaches when fan stops moving air .. again not a point at which we will try using them .. at least not a point I will. :D
I want fans that flow air through radiators, coolers, grills and filters quietly and efficiently. :D
 
While I haven't checked it out yet, I'm impressed with the new be quiet! Silent Loop coolers.

Fan specifications are only marginally useful. The CFM & dB is open air, not in use on radiator so not at all how we use them so not at all the CFM & dB with will get. mm H2O is maximum level H2O reaches when fan stops moving air .. again not a point at which we will try using them .. at least not a point I will. :D
I want fans that flow air through radiators, coolers, grills and filters quietly and efficiently. :D

It's so difficult to choose :/
 
It's so difficult to choose :/
Quick lesson: AIO coolers are not all CLC. CLC are a sub-group of what was originally named and patented as LCLC for Low Cost Liquid Cooler .. and they live up to their name of being low cost .. to the point being almost junk. CLCs are all aluminium radiator with pumps only marginally able to flow enough coolant to keep CPU cool. They are factory sealed disposable systems .. anything but a fan fails and entire system must be replaced.

Because radiators are not good they need high airflow fans, and high airflow fans are noisy even if they are expensive fans.

The pumps being so low flow to start with means as they wear and flow rate drops they can't flow enough coolant though the block to keep CPU cool.

We have seen many many pump failures with some leaking and damaging things. While leaking is not common, pump wear and failure is.

Another problem is no provision for topping up the coolant. These liquid coolers are same principle as cars coolant systems, and occasionally they need coolant topped up, even if there are no leaks, the plastic and rubber loose some coolant .. some electrons / neutrons escape.

Back to the AIO / CLC types;
Some AIOs (like Swiftech Hxxx X & Hxxx X2; and EK Predator series are actually component much better quality components that can be replaced if needed. Higher flow rate pumps, copper radiators, better hoses, better fans, etc. These AIOs are expanded with more components added, like a GPU block and extra radiator. But they do cost more.

But now we have a new group emerging .. These have better pumps that flow more coolant, copper radiators, better fans and have fill plugs to add coolant! .. and best of all they are only marginally more money than normal CLCs. be quiet! Silent Loop is one of these. Some of the others in this group claim to be expandable, but these pumps really don't have the abilty to move coolant against more resistance.
 
Quick lesson: AIO coolers are not all CLC. CLC are a sub-group of what was originally named and patented as LCLC for Low Cost Liquid Cooler .. and they live up to their name of being low cost .. to the point being almost junk. CLCs are all aluminium radiator with pumps only marginally able to flow enough coolant to keep CPU cool. They are factory sealed disposable systems .. anything but a fan fails and entire system must be replaced.

Because radiators are not good they need high airflow fans, and high airflow fans are noisy even if they are expensive fans.

The pumps being so low flow to start with means as they wear and flow rate drops they can't flow enough coolant though the block to keep CPU cool.

We have seen many many pump failures with some leaking and damaging things. While leaking is not common, pump wear and failure is.

Another problem is no provision for topping up the coolant. These liquid coolers are same principle as cars coolant systems, and occasionally they need coolant topped up, even if there are no leaks, the plastic and rubber loose some coolant .. some electrons / neutrons escape.

Back to the AIO / CLC types;
Some AIOs (like Swiftech Hxxx X & Hxxx X2; and EK Predator series are actually component much better quality components that can be replaced if needed. Higher flow rate pumps, copper radiators, better hoses, better fans, etc. These AIOs are expanded with more components added, like a GPU block and extra radiator. But they do cost more.

But now we have a new group emerging .. These have better pumps that flow more coolant, copper radiators, better fans and have fill plugs to add coolant! .. and best of all they are only marginally more money than normal CLCs. be quiet! Silent Loop is one of these. Some of the others in this group claim to be expandable, but these pumps really don't have the abilty to move coolant against more resistance.

So you'd suggest:

  • be quiet! Silent Loop BW002 (2x 120mm) £115
  • be quiet! Silent Loop BW003 (2x 140mm) £130

over:

  • Corsair H100i v2 (2x 120mm) £95
  • Corsair H110i (2x 140mm) £100
  • COrsair H115i (2x 140mm) £125
?
 
So you'd suggest:

  • be quiet! Silent Loop BW002 (2x 120mm) £115
  • be quiet! Silent Loop BW003 (2x 140mm) £130

over:

  • Corsair H100i v2 (2x 120mm) £95
  • Corsair H110i (2x 140mm) £100
  • COrsair H115i (2x 140mm) £125
?
In a word
Yes!
You get
copper radiator instead of aluminum
higher quality pump with highter flow rate
a fill port in pump.
All from a company with a reputation for marketing some of the very best products on the market with outstanding customer support. I have never heard of anyone not getting the support they needed from be quiet!

I don't normally recommend anything I have not tested and used myself or that one of a few select people have tested and used. I have not used the Silent Loop and don't know anyone who has, so I'm sticking my neck out on the chopping block .. and yours along with it. :D

But I believe this will prove to be a good cooler.

Robbie_G of OcUK saids
We have just had our sample units and these coolers are so quiet. We have the CPU running at 4.7Ghz at 1.3v and stressing it with Intel Extreme Utility. Under full load and the CPU temps have gone no higher than 58c.

We are using the 280 version.

How quiet this cooler runs under PWM control is worth it alone and the performance is up there with the best AIO coolers.
https://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=18751097
 
I put a Kraken X61 in my new build and I'm very pleased with it. Keeps my CPU very cool and it's very very quiet to the point of being essentially silent now it's under my desk.The fan control software is good too.

Your biggest risk is the size, a 280mm radiator once you've got a couple of fans stuck on it is massive, mine barely fits in my case - I am using an mATX case though.
 
I put a Kraken X61 in my new build and I'm very pleased with it. Keeps my CPU very cool and it's very very quiet to the point of being essentially silent now it's under my desk.The fan control software is good too.

I just stuck an Kraken X31 on my cpu that has the smaller 120mm rad and fan, very nice, running the silent profile with no issues, easy to install once i had gotten the old air cooler off.
 
I'm going to re-purpose my old gaming PC as a lounge gamer/streaming box and I plan to replace the old CPU cooler with the Kraken X31. Can't fit the bigger alternatives in the new case.

Just waiting for payday at the end of the month before ordering the new case and cooler. My new build came out of this month's salary so I'm kind of on the bones of my arse until next week :(
 
Back
Top Bottom