Alternative medicine strikes again

Soldato
Joined
12 Sep 2012
Posts
11,698
Location
Surrey
Article:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-38650739

Ridiculous people can promote this crap without consequence until someone dies from it.

What annoys me the most is people seem to think that knowing what food is considered healthy or unhealthy, gives them some sort of insight to medicine.

The guy who wrote the book studied nutrition then fake medicine and now sells his delusions to vulnerable cancer victims calling himself a doctor. If anything, his qualifications discredits his medical knowledge.

On patient request even doctors in this country prescribe alternative medicine because the patient has been fooled by silly books and miracle stories. Normally i would have little sympathy for idiots doing idiotic things and lending themselves to proving Darwin right but the trouble is that alternative medicine often preys on the desperate and vulnerable. With the evolution of social media and the internet it is even easier to come across something that has been written to fool you into believing it works. For thousands of people who have used one form of alt-medicine or another, there may be the odd person who recovered naturally through no help of the medicine but it will end up inspiring many to rely on a medicine that treats nothing.
 
Conmen have existed since forever, this one happens to have sold an illusion of medicine is all.

Reminds me, wish phage therapy would be allowed and encouraged in this country. Effective anti bacterial treatment which couldn't care less about MRSA? Been around for decades. Guess antibiotics need to become totally useless against the strains of bacteria that survive before money and effort is put into it.
 
10 dead kids 400+ with seizures and other side effects from a homoeopathic tablets in America too.

Company says it cant understand why FDA has issued warning against its sale.


It seems that giving babies small doses of poison isn't sensible, especially when the manufacturing of the doses is inconsistent and varies from almost nothing to well beyond lethal dose.
 
Con-men have existed since forever but it is only in recent times have they manage to target so many people so easily.

I would be in favour of having medical books published and sold in the UK to require approval by an official body or face having a horrible logo on the cover saying 'not recognised by xxx'

Alternative medicine companies should be more heavily restricted and monitored, require all treatments sold be documented and sent to an organisation for approval prior to selling. Admin paid for by alt medicine companies of course.
 
Last edited:
in the old days it was snake oil

now its a luxury ranch and bicarb injections

desperate people can be talked into anything it seems
 
Read this earlier, shame someone was so desperate for alternative treatment this conman did their family out of 60 odd grand.
 
gotta love the line "this is the cure doctors wouldn't give you", no **** sherlock it's because it doesnt work, if it did work then it would either be medicine, or in r&d on the way to becoming medicine
 
it doesn't help when nhs offers homeopathy and that homeopathy and other stores despite legislation are not targeted and shut down.

thankfully Merseyside Skeptics Group took Liverpool trust to court and won, which means other trusts should now follow and ban homeopathy, which costs the NHS millions.

The other thing that didn't help in this country, is bbc had to give the opposing side, how ever insane, thankfully that was also changed a year or two ago.
 
It's viable but not in the way that will make pharmaceutical companies a stack of cash.

Someone I work with studies phage therapy: the main issue with it is that if you try to treat an internal infection with it the immune system recognises it as a foreign substance and destroys it.

It could be worthwhile as a topical thing, but they're nowhere near replacing antibiotics. It doesn't help that microbes do evolve resistance to phages, so you'd have to constantly adjust the composition of the cocktail and hope that they don't lose effectiveness against some of the strains you're trying to target in the process.
 
Delusional treatments have been used for centuries and I can't believe some people in this day and age still don't know any better.

Rhino horn anyone?
 
Lots of these fantasy doctors around now :/

Like it says in the article, that diet just will not work because the stomach uses strong acid to break down foods. By the time they reach the intestines anything you eaten is acidic, that can't be changed.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom