Optical out vs ARC Soundbar

Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
16,496
Location
Manchester
I have very little knowledge on hi fi systems, and want to sort something for my dad. He's hard of hearing and his new TV isn't great in the sound department.

Question is, how much to spend and what do we get for the money.

Would there be any benefit from buying an expensive sound bar with 2-3 HDMI in with ARC to connect to the TV compared to buying a cheaper sound bar with optical in (so connecting sources to the TV via HDMI) then into the sound bar with an optical cable?

I just can't figure out the benefit of the more expensive ones (connection wise). All that will be connected via HDMI will be 1 X Sky box and 1 X Blu-ray player.

He doesn't care for 7.1 surround, just wants something with decent volume for voice mainly so he can hear things like football commentary (Sky & BT Sport) and normal stereo broadcasts, such as the news etc. He doesn't need extras such as airplay or android cast, or internet radio etc.

I think separate receiver/speakers are out, unless they offer something a sound bar can't and the sound bar is preferable for the smaller size/less clutter aspect.

Can anyone shed some light? Many thanks.
 
Optical can't take master HD audio or true HD, but if you are not bothered about that, which I don't think you are, go for the cheaper optical connection. If that is cheaper, I'm just assuming it is.
 
Optical can't take master HD audio or true HD, but if you are not bothered about that, which I don't think you are, go for the cheaper optical connection. If that is cheaper, I'm just assuming it is.

Yeah there seems to be a lot more in the price ranges we're looking at for optical, it seems it's a lot more money for a sound bar with enough HDMI in and HDMI out (ARC).

You're probably right, for the need a basic thing might be the better way to go. All I have to do then is find a way of reducing 4 remotes into, well less than 4.
 
Logitech harmony for the remote, people go on about them in here. Save money on the soundbar by going optical and put it towards the remote.
 
Back
Top Bottom