Boy, 15, admits causing crash in which five people died

I know what you are saying, but in this case I really don't see how the second part of the sentence lessens the first statement.

Unless you are saying it's a shame that he will be guilty? Why is that a shame?
It's arguably a shame for the guilty party because he will have to live with the guilt for the rest of his life. He may never get over it. He may prefer to be dead, and it's not outside the bounds of possibility that he will kill himself as a result, as some people do in similar circumstances.

That's very different to simply saying that it's a shame he didn't die, as though you feel it would be fitting for him to die for his actions, like some sort of extra-judicial death penalty.
 
It's arguably a shame for the guilty party because he will have to live with the guilt for the rest of his life. He may never get over it. He may prefer to be dead, and it's not outside the bounds of possibility that he will kill himself as a result, as some people do in similar circumstances.

That's very different to simply saying that it's a shame he didn't die, as though you feel it would be fitting for him to die for his actions, like some sort of extra-judicial death penalty.

Thank you. My point exactly.
 
Kids these days. This is very heartbreaking but definitely does not surprise me at all. The kids of today are getting more and more out of control.
 
Yeah I don't buy it either. Fairly sure the majority of 12/14 year olds know that driving around in a stolen car is not a good thing. And yes, they may be easily led, that's why they have these things called parents which are supposed to stop them doing bad things.
 
They were kids and made a mistake with terrible consequences.

At 12 I certainly knew the difference between right and wrong, hell even my 5 year old knows it's wrong to a) steal a car and b) drive it without a licence.

A mistake is doing something accidentally or because you weren't paying attention, it may have been a mistake that they ended up hitting the tree, but don't pretend you're naive enough to think that them joyriding was a "mistake"; they knew exactly what they were doing.

Yes it's a shame they died, but ultimately the road is now a (marginally) safer place for the rest of us
 
Terribly sad for family and friends.

The boy is an absolute idiot for it. We have all done stupid or dangerous things as a youth. Losing control of the car was a mistake but the theft, driving when you can't drive and possibly the speeding in a residential area were all decisions.
 
Back
Top Bottom