Depends what you are looking at - take a closer look at the treatment of migrant workers or some of the arbitrary laws, etc. from that perspective it certainly isn't leading the world.
British man arrested in Dubai for carrying anti-depressants
- Thread starter dowie
- Start date
Depends what you are looking at - take a closer look at the treatment of migrant workers or some of the arbitrary laws, etc. from that perspective it certainly isn't leading the world.
I'm sure he'd be out by now, but I certainly wouldn't want to enter the US with what he had. The hassle you'd quite possibly receive may well still involve a back room and possible incarceration for at least a short period.
Soldato
- Joined
- 21 Oct 2011
- Posts
- 22,495
- Location
- ST4
There's also a lot of sand in which to bury one's head.
He’s been under treatment for 21 years. He’ll know how he’s doing day to day and month to month better than a doctor. I doubt he’s seeing a doctor about this condition very regularly at all, unless he’s a danger to himself or others.
I’ve been on antidepressants in the past and could just order 2 months worth at a time without seeing a doctor. I probably did that for a year or so at a time.
Someone on prescription medication for depression and/or anxiety being given access to weapons. Sounds completely safe to me.
Totally this. I don't fly their airlines as i don't want to give those countries a penny of my money
Just having a prescription is not a get out of jail card. There may be maximum quantities allowed in the relevant country. If the authorities think you may be intending to distribute then the prescription means nothing. Who knows what other evidence they may have.
Would 12 months supply with prescriptions be okay with you? 2 years?
There is always a threshold where it becomes suspicious. These are widely abused drugs.
6 months for example would be suspicious to me for a controlled drug. However my opinion doesn't matter and nor does yours.
This wouldn't even be a story if it was Australia or somewhere like that. However, saying that the UAE should have dealt with this far more quickly and established that it was likely for personal use. I think that is the issue. I would personally get permission from the host country first or get it prescribed there.
Last edited:
http://uae-embassy.ae/Embassies/uk/Content/678
UAE Embassy Advice which the Independent have linked to in a separate article:
So a prescription doesn't let you bring in any quantity you want without prior permission.
5 weeks to process this offence is excessive in my opinion. Then again the law isn't about opinions.
UAE Embassy Advice which the Independent have linked to in a separate article:
So a prescription doesn't let you bring in any quantity you want without prior permission.
5 weeks to process this offence is excessive in my opinion. Then again the law isn't about opinions.
Here are the UK rules for comparison. Seems to be directed at expats but I guess applies to everyone.
https://www.gov.uk/travelling-controlled-drugs
https://www.gov.uk/travelling-controlled-drugs
Millions of people go through Dubai yearly and something like 99.99999999% have no issues.
Probably got more chance of arrest/harm doing things you already do in day to day life.
To someone suffering from mental illness theyre literally life savers. So yeah, worth it.
How did he manage to get 6 months in one go? These days repeat prescriptions only allow a month a time to be requested, plus an additional month for holidays. My surgery will supply a full 12 months worth of prescriptions, but they can only be used one at a time. If I try collecting them too quickly the pharmacy get twitchy and check up.
He works offshore for extended periods. He can't exactly nip to Boots to pick up a prescription.
Someone on prescription medication for depression and/or anxiety being given access to weapons. Sounds completely safe to me.
Would you prefer it was someone with depression/anxiety who wasn't on medication for it?
How about we just shoot all people with mental illness as soon as they are diagnosed, because quite frankly with that kind of disgusting close minded attitude we may as well just write them off completely eh?
surely it depends on the reason for needing that quantity... why would you need 2 years etc..? If someone is going to be at sea for close to a year then 12 months supply could well be justifiable
yeah it does seem the rules are for up to 3 months, which the article didn't specify and also doesn't make clear whether he sought prior permission or not, regardless the way he is being treated is ridiculous all the same
Yeah you can get away with a lot over there. There are Russian hookers in all nightclubs, there are gay westerners over there, there are people using drugs etc... chances are you'll be fine if you keep it to the hotels and don't draw attention to yourself in public.
However plenty of people (including people who've been there a few times and will happily trot out the mantra about "different culture, stick to their rules") are still pretty naive re: the actual rules and these can be enforced arbitrarily.
Perhaps you take some tourist pictures, you see a nice palace and take a picture of it... ah but you didn't realise it belonged to Sheik XYZ ... you get arrested for taking a holiday picture... perhaps the palace/embassy/govt building was just in the background of your picture... still a risk.
Your hotel serves alcohol, as a tourist it is illegal for you to drink alcohol, this isn't something the travel advice or hotel will generally tell you.. and 99.9% of the time you'll be fine so long as you're not wandering around drunk outside the hotel... you're still breaking the law though and you could still be arrested for consuming alcohol.
I've spent a bit of time in the region, I've never personally had any issue at all.. I'd not however play down the risks there... you have got more chance of being arrested there IMO and plenty of times it could be for something trivial that you didn't even realise was illegal or even for essentially no reason at all.
Would you prefer it was someone with depression/anxiety who wasn't on medication for it?
How about we just shoot all people with mental illness as soon as they are diagnosed, because quite frankly with that kind of disgusting close minded attitude we may as well just write them off completely eh?
How about the third option. They aren't fit for he job.
He probably couldn't be a pilot for an airliner for example.
What other jobs would be excluded then? Teachers, nurses, anything involving driving?