Opinions needed! Buy (HTB) or Rent

Associate
Joined
30 Jul 2007
Posts
278
Location
United Kingdom
Hi Guys,

Age old question here and one that's been asked multiple times, but I'm after opinions in my situation.

I live on my own, am 26 and currently renting, and amlooking to buy my first house (2 bed semi) in the near future. I've actually already put down reservation fee, mortgage valuations, searches etc on a new build property and would be using the help to buy scheme (equity loan).

I'm now having doubts due to the long term commitment and location, so am considering pulling out of the sale, cutting my losses (expect >£1k solicitor bill) and moving somewhere closer to town and remaining renting (flat).

My considerations:

Commute:
Where I work is in an expensive area, which I cannot afford to buy. However, I can afford to rent closer by although it is expensive (750+/m). Buying, I would be looking at an increased commute of 15-40mins per day, so a minimum of 2.5hrs extra sat in the car each day, which I despise.

Location:
Buying - on outskirts of town, not able to walk to local amenities, residential area
Renting - towards center of town, able to walk into town, local restaurants, shops, bars etc.
As I'm on my own and would make the most out of waking to local cafe's etc, meeting up with people, renting wins this one hands down.

Flexibility:
I have a stable job, however have always wanted to work abroad if the opportunity comes up.
Using HTB means that if the opportunity came up I wouldn't be able to sublet unless I could prove the move was temporary & could not afford to in parallel pay the mortgage, and even though it is unclear if it would be approved.
Being in early career I have moved around a fair amount (longest I've stayed in one house is 1.5yrs in the last 4 years since uni). Doing the maths, it would take 3.5yrs of living in the mortgaged house to break even in expenditure vs renting if I were to move at that point.

Control:
I would like to buy and have a place of my own, be able to decorate and have the freedom associated with owning property.

Long term / equity:
A lot of people I've spoken to have said that it is best to get on to the ladder as early as possible to start building up equity. Obviously renting will not let me achieve this.

Brexit:
Who knows what will happen to house prices (2018 forecasting lowest inflation in house prices in years)

Money:
Mortgage would be ~£500/m vs £750-800/m renting, however I would have additional costs due to the commute, insurance, etc to think about, plus in year 5 interest kicks in on on the help to buy loan.
If I were to buy, I should be able to save enough to remortgage healthily and take on the HTB loan into the mortgage at the 5 year point.


I'm leaning towards pulling out due to the lack of flexibility & location, and though I would struggle to save due to the cost of renting, try and build up 10-15% deposit to buy without HTB in a few years time and after the unknowns of housing market changes.

However, I have the opportunity to buy now and get onto the ladder early...


Opinions? :)
 
Buy, havent seen a single person who's worse of by buying.

Sounds likes rentings much more expensive and you wouldn't be able to save up a decent deposit anyway.

Sounds like cold feat, rather than financial sense. Doesn't sound like working abroad is that realistic? Surly you would have done it allready if it were.

If you go shared ownership instead. It's always at market value so if houses do decrease in price due to brexit. You might be able to staircase up easier (assuming you can get a mortgage with the country in a mess) also you might be able to afford closer to work.

I've put off buying for so long and am in much worse financial position than all my friends who purchased earlier.
All the what if's, the flexibility etc. All meant nothing just excuses.
 
I can't see house prices dropping anytime soon, they may stagnate for a while, at best IMO.

If you have the finances to cover deposits, setup fees and the monthly mortgage repayments, go for it... Even if you just buy a one bed, you can always put it on the market if your circumstances change.

Things happened in my life that prevented me from having the option of buying at your age in the around 2000, which have had a knock-on effect on my life today. I hate how my partner and I have only recently (last two years or so) slowly been able to start building up a mortgage deposit, when we have rented the same place for nearly 12 years, handing over ~£75k of "dead money" over that time.
 
Read the conditions of the HTB equity loan carefully. My understanding is that if the house increases in value you are paying back the same percentage you borrowed for the loan, not what you borrowed + interest. For example, house is £100k, mortgage £75k and HTB loan £25k (25%). House prices go up and your house is now worth £125k, you'd be repaying £31,250 not £25k. Worth confirming. This is less of a concern if prices stay the same or go down.

Personally, I would say save a bit longer until you can buy without HTB.

I can't see house prices dropping anytime soon, they may stagnate for a while, at best IMO.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-42975261 Just being contrary. They probably will stagnate or go down.
 
Sounds like cold feat, rather than financial sense. Doesn't sound like working abroad is that realistic? Surly you would have done it allready if it were.
I moved to this area of the UK into this job ~9 months ago as almost a third choice, the first choice being a job in Sweden that didn’t materialise and the second a position in Spain that did, but a week after starting here which was unfortunate timing. If the opportunity comes up again, I will most likely take it as I am flexible and with few ties...
EDIT - also it’s the change in lifestyle I’m worried about, being further away from the town centre, additional time commuting etc, all adds up. This is less of a concern for people that are settled as a couple, with kids etc. and would typically go home and stay home after coming back from work, but I have a more active lifestyle (gym daily, drinks on weekends, meeting friends etc which would mean additional trips each 15min per direction, or an expensive Taxi)

Read the conditions of the HTB equity loan carefully. My understanding is that if the house increases in value you are paying back the same percentage you borrowed for the loan, not what you borrowed + interest. For example, house is £100k, mortgage £75k and HTB loan £25k (25%). House prices go up and your house is now worth £125k, you'd be repaying £31,250 not £25k. Worth confirming. This is less of a concern if prices stay the same or go down.

Personally, I would say save a bit longer until you can buy without HTB.



http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-42975261 Just being contrary. They probably will stagnate or go down.
This is true, but I’ve considered that if the house price does go up at least the value I would owe only increases on that percentage (20%) vs the whole house value if I were to wait a few years to buy.
 
Find somewhere to buy without HTB.

In my opinion HTB is for people who want to stretch and buy a house they don't really need and can't really afford.
 
Buy, get a lodger in for a few years. This REALLY helps the finances, money from lodger can be used to build a buffer of savings up and to overpay the mortgage.. Gets it paid off much quicker! :)

I did this for about 6 years, made a MASSIVE dent in the mortgage!

If you work out the compound interest effect the benefit is huge:
https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/mortgages/mortgage-overpayment-calculator
 
I don’t think I’d be keen on having a lodger in such a small house, although this would be the first time I would be living on my own...
 
Back
Top Bottom