Cant say for 5700XT, only the previous ati cards i have owned and my experiences.I writing believe everything you read, I've had no issues with my 5700XT. Conversely I've read about many 2080Ti owners with borked cards, one guy on here has had to return a card four times. There's s lot of luck involved and a fair dose of user error. Someone else was having stuttering issues with a 5700XT, turns out he was overclocking it too far and it was getting too hot.
I had an MSI 1070 Gaming X before my 5700XT and to be fair if you didn't look inside the case you wouldn't know, other than the newer card obviously being faster.
I’m sure the hardware is fine but seems there are still driver issues.
There are driver issues with nvidia too, but less from my experience