Upgrade from i5-8600K?

Associate
Joined
3 Jan 2005
Posts
519
Location
Ireland
Hey all, I've had my main gaming PC about 3 and a half years now and would fancy an upgrade. I use it mostly for sim racing and occasionally ARMA3. I would like to keep as much of my existing rig as possible to keep costs down. I currently have an i5-8600K @ 4.8Ghz and an Aorus Ultra Gaming Z370 motherboard. Other specs:

GPU: Evga 3080 FTW3
PSU: Seasonic Focus 750W Platinum
Monitor: Samsung Odyssey G9
RAM: 16gb G Skill Trident Z (F4-3200C16D-16GTZR)

I game at the native resolution of the G9 (5120 x 1440).

Budget about £500 but can be stretched if I need a new PSU.

1) Simplest and cheapest option is to drop in an i9-9900K. I would want to run it at 4.8Ghz at least, so I'm not certain whether my PSU will need to be upgraded to 850W which would add to the cost. I know the VRM cooling has been flagged as a potential issue too with my particular board, but it might not be a problem as I just use my rig for gaming.

2) Change motherboard to X570 and go with Ryzen 5 5600x (thinking of the new MSI Tomahawk x570s board). I'm pretty sure I won't need a PSU upgrade here, so this is a good value proposition. There is quite a bit of work with this option in taking out the old motherboard, figuring out the cabling for the new mobo, reinstalling windows, setting up all my peripherals again etc. However I have to realise this offers an upgrade path and no pain no gain :)

3) Change motherboard to Intel Z490 board and go with i9-10850K (10th gen pricing is very keen at the moment). I feel like I'm getting a significant upgrade here with 10 cores and 20 threads and may offer some kind of longevity. Will definitely need a new PSU though.

I know the FPS gains will likely be small with a CPU upgrade, but it will make the PC generally more responsive. Would welcome any opinions on the above.
 
The PSU would be fine for any of those systems. A 9900K and highend down draft HSF setup would probably solve the VRM issue too.

I’d either go for the drop in upgrade or move to Ryzen. Probably a 5900X
 
Hey all, I've had my main gaming PC about 3 and a half years now and would fancy an upgrade. I use it mostly for sim racing and occasionally ARMA3. I would like to keep as much of my existing rig as possible to keep costs down. I currently have an i5-8600K @ 4.8Ghz and an Aorus Ultra Gaming Z370 motherboard. Other specs:

GPU: Evga 3080 FTW3
PSU: Seasonic Focus 750W Platinum
Monitor: Samsung Odyssey G9
RAM: 16gb G Skill Trident Z (F4-3200C16D-16GTZR)

I game at the native resolution of the G9 (5120 x 1440).

Budget about £500 but can be stretched if I need a new PSU.

1) Simplest and cheapest option is to drop in an i9-9900K. I would want to run it at 4.8Ghz at least, so I'm not certain whether my PSU will need to be upgraded to 850W which would add to the cost. I know the VRM cooling has been flagged as a potential issue too with my particular board, but it might not be a problem as I just use my rig for gaming.

2) Change motherboard to X570 and go with Ryzen 5 5600x (thinking of the new MSI Tomahawk x570s board). I'm pretty sure I won't need a PSU upgrade here, so this is a good value proposition. There is quite a bit of work with this option in taking out the old motherboard, figuring out the cabling for the new mobo, reinstalling windows, setting up all my peripherals again etc. However I have to realise this offers an upgrade path and no pain no gain :)

3) Change motherboard to Intel Z490 board and go with i9-10850K (10th gen pricing is very keen at the moment). I feel like I'm getting a significant upgrade here with 10 cores and 20 threads and may offer some kind of longevity. Will definitely need a new PSU though.

I know the FPS gains will likely be small with a CPU upgrade, but it will make the PC generally more responsive. Would welcome any opinions on the above.
go i9 9900kf for value .... one ending soon on a certain auction website ;)
 
2) only need a mid range b550 mobo for Zen3 so you can save a few quid there.



3) Alderlake releasing in a few months so potential drop in 10th / 11th gen price.
 
Back
Top Bottom