recipe suggestion for someone that doesn't cook ?

Guanciale can be hard to find at times, and is far less forgiving than pancetta. Bacon was actually suggested to me by an Italian chef and I've not heard any others decry its use. Supposedly carbonara is a WW2 adaptation of cacio e uova, which actually first used bacon and only later guanciale.
Pecorino Romano is the traditional cheese, but parmigiano-reggiano is an accepted alternative, as is a blend of the two...

But the core ingredients and the method remain the same - No cream!!
Arguing about the authenticity of Carbonara is utterly pointless - there is no defined historic 'master' recipe and plenty of authentic Italian recipes use cream as it was fashionable to do so right up until the end of the last century.

Classic myth-based cooking. Many stories, very little proof and some seriously revisionist history behind peoples opinions on what is right and wrong.
 
But criticising an cook for cutting corners or not using "authentic" ingredients is silly.
Come try my "Italian style" spaghetti bolonese, then... Overcooked pasta noodles of some description, with minced beef that's been microwaved in tomato ketchup.
Bish bash bosh, 8 minutes and you're done. Quick, healthy, cheap, sorted!!!

Or my authentic-style "Fish N Chips", featuring barbecued snoek and sauteed sweet potato french fries... and a side of mashed pigeon peas.

If you ignore the fundamentals elements particular to a dish, it's no longer the same dish.

Recipes can and should evolve - use cookbooks for inspiration and to learn basics and then try variations.
You still have to learn what the rules are before you can learn to break them... and the likes of James Martin lean heavily toward exactly that!
Classics get to being classics because so many people have already tried so many variants and generally agree on which yields the best result.
 
Or my authentic-style "Fish N Chips", featuring barbecued snoek and sauteed sweet potato french fries... and a side of mashed pigeon peas.

If you ignore the fundamentals elements particular to a dish, it's no longer the same dish.
I love snoek - can I get your recipe? :cry:
 
The issue with Jamie Oliver is he is a brand, not a cook/chef anymore. The sheer amount of recipes he does per year demonstrates that he does not come up with most of them - it would be impossible.

But criticising an cook for cutting corners or not using "authentic" ingredients is silly. Recipes can and should evolve - use cookbooks for inspiration and to learn basics and then try variations.

One book I go back to is "James Martin - the Collection". It is a back to basic cooking across cuisines.

I mean there's a difference between not using authentic ingredients and calling a dish something its far from. He consistently uses weird ingredients in dishes that have no right being anywhere near them. It stops being that dish when you go that far from what it was meant to be.

I.e his latest korean dish, with literally nothing korean about it at all.
 
Arguing about the authenticity of Carbonara is utterly pointless - there is no defined historic 'master' recipe and plenty of authentic Italian recipes use cream as it was fashionable to do so right up until the end of the last century.

Classic myth-based cooking. Many stories, very little proof and some seriously revisionist history behind peoples opinions on what is right and wrong.

Is there any evidence behind this?

I know cream got introduced during ww2/post ww2 during American occupation but apart from that cream is recognised as not being authentic at all.
 
Just to weigh in on OP's question; I went off cooking for a long time and basically forgot how to make anything more than scrambled eggs.
My saving grace was running Hello Fresh for a few months, keeping the recipe cards that I liked. You can use this thread or this thread or this thread to recreate their mystery spice mixes and you're off to the races. Before long you find yourself tweaking the recipes to your liking and your lady-friend calling you a good cook.
 
Is there any evidence behind this?
I know cream got introduced during ww2/post ww2 during American occupation but apart from that cream is recognised as not being authentic at all.
Cream only became popular as eggs were still under post-war rationing, and persisted in restaurants due to busy chefs not having time for a fiddly egg sauce that would overcook under a heat lamp. It cropped up again in the 80s with microwave meals and hasn't gone away since.
 
Cooking is a lot of things, forget how to julienne some carrots, there are fundamental basic things one should do and learn

Important things

1 – Always be tasting. Add some salt, taste it. Add some soy sauce, taste it.

It is easy to add more, very hard to remove

2 – Remember heat works from outside in (lets not talk about microwave), so picture how the heat transfers through food and how the level of char you like out the outside vs in. Logic dictates slower heat will mean more evenly cooked.

3 – Learn texture and colour changes in food. Watch and remember what certain food looks like when it is cooked.

4 – Right tool for the job, sharp knife, right size pan etc, can you work around it? Sure, but right tool always helps. Don’t be afraid to get some gadgets to help, like a meat thermometer to check the inside temp. Sous vide machine to ensure perfect temp before charring.

5 – Keep an eye on it, don’t walk away!

(assuming you are not baking or roasting for point 1 and 5, in which you can’t taste raw bread or much point watching an oven, perhaps don’t leave the house)
 
Is there any evidence behind this?

I know cream got introduced during ww2/post ww2 during American occupation but apart from that cream is recognised as not being authentic at all.
That Carbonara doesn't have a single defined master recipe or that cream was popular?

If the former, yes. If the latter, also yes - plenty of Italian recipes from the 60's onwards included cream, with the most notable one being in La Grande Cucina which I think was the first to introduce and start the popularisation of guanciale.
 
Back
Top Bottom