For me I think there was enough of a release. But hey, I'm not a ref, and I guess I've got some bias! I've seen players get away with doing the same plenty of times. With decisions like this - you win some, you lose some.It was deserved - it was a professional foul. A break was on, and he intentionally tried to slow it down as England was undermanned at ruck. If the ball had come out quickly Scotland would have a had a try opportunity. Anywhere else on the field it would be just a penalty.
)