2.5 or M.2 reliability

Associate
Joined
27 Nov 2003
Posts
1,926
Hi all,

Looking to get a couple of 4TB drives for data processing tasks. The speed doesn't actually matter too much but the drives will be quite heavily used. Is there a difference in long-term reliability between m.2 NVME drives and 2.5 inch SSDs?
 
The endurance (TBW - Terabytes Written) differences tend to be obvious if you go to any of those the comparisons sites like geizhals/skinflint.
For instance (4TB, from 5PB endurance, set to only show 2.5" and M.2 and SATA and PCIe (there are quite a few 2.5" U.2 enterprise disks out there too):
A8kJhXH.png
so that's 14:4. If you change the TBW to 20PB you only get 5 2.5" drives.

Of course reliability is not only about endurance, but the drive manufacturers certainly mostly build high endurance drive as SATA 2.5". Of course a bigger form factor could allow them to add have more redundancy, but another factor is that for write-heavy drives speed is seldom a factor.

Is your "quite heavily used" write heavy or read heavy? As if it is read heavy then you are probably unlikely to wear out the drives and some of the better NVMe like the Seagate FireCuda, Kingston KC3000 etc., ones are a lot faster.

EDIT: didn't want to link to the spec and price comparers for obvious forum rules, but TPU do have something somewhat similar:
not as detailed though. Lot of U.2 drives which really aren't consumer things. As for the lack of details, I guess while the TPU editors and posters are more technical they are not working to get paid with affiliate link commissions like the price comparers do.
 
Last edited:
for heavy use i go with enterprise drives, my vm drive is a micron max drive with 5dwpd rating and my servers torrent drive is a samsung 3dwpd drive. both are 960gb
for my games drive and data drive i have micron pro drives 1.92tb each and all drives are 2.5 sata.
been looking for a enterprise boot drive for more capacity these days too to replace my nvme gigabyte 500gig one.
 
Another option is drives intended for use in NAS like the WD Red SA500 2.5" SATA and SN700 NVMe as these have much higher TBWs than 'standard' drives.
 
Back
Top Bottom