• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

3D HTPC Advice

Associate
Joined
9 Sep 2008
Posts
702
Just got a 3D TV for Xmas and been watching a few half sbs videos and wanted to start playing everything full sbs. Came to the conclusion that a HTPC was the only viable option.

I read that the GT430 was one of the best gfx cards to get because it supports HDMI 1.4a

Just a few quick questions. I spotted a GT520 which also supports HDMI 1.4a and is £15~ cheaper than the GT430, would this work well if not better?

Also, I had initially planned to go for this:

cart.jpg


But maybe I should swap the GT430 for the cheaper GT520. Also I'm guessing because the GFX card would be used to output the video that a slower CPU could be used. So would it be viable to drop down to an old LGA775 dual core?

Something is making me think I have an old LGA775 board + cpu around. If I wouldn't notice a performance drop it would be worth using that?

Is anyone else using a htpc or pc to output full SBS 1080p?

Looking for bang for buck and not too fussed about noise either.

Thanks!!
 
That was a pain. I ended up trying to use my old mobo+CPU, had to get some new RAM cus I sold all my old ddr2. Then I finally get it all installed and find out that the mobo only supports certain GFX Cards on the PCI-E, The GTX 520 kept saying malfunctioned.

So I ended up upgrading to a new 775 mobo and some ddr3. I got some a really cheap stick of 4gb ram, however this was my downfall. After countless BSOD I did a memtest this morning. It was full of errors.

Just got some decent/mid-priced ram and now it is working a treat. Just trying to find the right software to play my 3D stuff in now. Anyone got any experience?
 
Attempting this at present, ive bought all my parts, just waitng untill the last few arrive to put it together and check it out. I hunted for parts like a pig after a truffle..saved a lot tho

Im after full sbs and lossess hd audio

I have a 46gt30 tv, 3D av receiver, 5.1 system
 
AMD Llano for htpc best value for money under £150 for cpu/mboard

I don't know who told you to go with that nvidia card but ATI are better htpc cards they support full frame rates the nvidia card have issues with 24p.

If you don't want to switch to AMD build then just swap the i3 for £40 less g620 and look at getting something like 6450 at around £30 mark.
 
Last edited:
AMD Llano for htpc but for some reason the prices have gone up.

I don't know who told you to go with that nvidia card but ATI are better htpc cards they support full frame rates the nvidia card have issues with 24p.

I have a gt 430 too
 
I went with the gtx 520 in the end, mainly because it was cheaper and seemed just as good at 3d/hd. I haven't experienced any problems yet, but need to do a lot of tweaking with it still. Been using Stereoscopic player and it keeps decoding the sound instead of sending it to my amp.

I also had really bad audio sync problems with windvd and tmt 5, it was almost 1 second ahead of the video. But now with Stereoscopic player it seems only slightly out. I probably need to configure the audio settings a bit better.
 
I went with the gtx 520 in the end, mainly because it was cheaper and seemed just as good at 3d/hd. I haven't experienced any problems yet, but need to do a lot of tweaking with it still. Been using Stereoscopic player and it keeps decoding the sound instead of sending it to my amp.

I also had really bad audio sync problems with windvd and tmt 5, it was almost 1 second ahead of the video. But now with Stereoscopic player it seems only slightly out. I probably need to configure the audio settings a bit better.



Would be nice to see how you get on, not sure what to expect
 
I have run 3d blu-ray on multi machines but I have a soft spot for my llano htpc

Software I have used is Powerdvd 11 and TotalMedia Threate 5 (best one)
 
GT520, GT430 and HD6450 all passive. (different rooms)

Did you grab a 430 in the end?

yes i did, i got confused as to what would work on my tv, the AMD supported list did not support it but the nvidia did, i dont really like nvidia but kind of thought i had to go for it. Think my spec is a bit overkill tbh

silverstone gd06 - exactly same size as my receiver
i3 2120 - good price on it cheaper than a new 2100
asus p8h61-m le usb3
scythe cooler
4Gb Kingston hyperX 1333 cl7 ram
Corsair m4 64GB SSD
evga gt 430
corsair tx650 PSU - because at low loads it is only 22dB
 
Last edited:
It could be classed as over kill, but it means you can do more than just play movies, you can run some old-school retro games on some emulators, and also the i3's have rock bottom idle power usage.
I wasn't too sure about the HD6450 and my Samsung as, like you said, their list is kinda small. But it works just the same as the others.

Love the styling on the GD06 - my only reservation with it was no easy way to connect a remote (Most run through IR) without keeping the front cover down 24/7. But a wireless solution would be possible - phone/tablet.

TotalMedia Threate 5 (best one)
+1
 
I tried out TMT5 but I had a problem with trying to play FULL SBS mkv, 3840x1080. It was outputting in the wrong aspect ratio. I couldn't find a way to change it. I'm not sure If I was being stupid but couldn't find it anywhere. when I right clicked most of the options were disabled. So I gave up with it.
 
I doubt it would, side by side's aren't normally @ that resolution. They are natively made so both angles are made to fit a 1920x1080 screen.

Changing the ratio of 3840x1080 would shrink the width and keep it @ 1080p which would look silly - as I'm sure you found.

TMT5 can play 3D BluRay ISOs though, which is what I do. much easier.
 
Last edited:
I doubt it would, side by side's aren't normally @ that resolution. They are natively made so both angles are made to fit a 1920x1080 screen.

Changing the ratio of 3840x1080 would shrink the width and keep it @ 1080p which would look silly - as I'm sure you found.

TMT5 can play 3D BluRay ISOs though, which is what I do. much easier.

Is it possible to strip everything out of a blu ray and recreate the iso? If it is may just go iso route
 
Back
Top Bottom