It's just my opinion. If I was buying on a low budget I would want the quadcore if possible even if games arent fully using them now they will do. Personally I'd like to get the best core system I could for the cash. If you go by the benchmarks the 970BE tops the i3 2100 in a fair few tests when it loses it's pretty close.
Not really. Phenom II's old K10 architecture is already hitting the wall, and even for games that are well-optimsed for quad such as BFBC2 it is not really performaning better than the dual-core i3 2100 so there's no point.
Another thing you keep overlooking is the cost. Phenom II X4 975/980BE is MORE expensive, not only on the CPU itself, but the electricity to run as well. Let's say we use GTX460 1GB and 6850 1GB as example...they both deliver similar performance, but let's say
IF the 6850 1GB consume 80W extra in power...would it make sense to to get it instead of the GTX460 1GB? No! And this is not even a good example for representing Phenom II X4 vs i3 2100, since the Phenom II X4 in only comparable to i3 2100's frame rate in games that use quad-core fully, and its frame rate will ALWAYS be lower in games that uses less than 4 cores, or even in games that use 4 cores, but not using them as fully as can be. It's like...why would you want pay 4 guys who can only lift 30KG £10 each to carry something weight 100KG, when you can get 2 guys who can lift 60KG £10 each and save £20? (the wage represent the electricity/power consumption). Haven't more in physcial numbers doesn't means it is better...another example would be two 500GB HDD vs one 1TB HDD (not talking about RAID)...£60 vs £40...and require more power consumption got carrying same amount of data.
Even if people were getting Phenom II X4 955BE to overclock to 3.7~3.8GHz, they still need to pay the extra for 3rd party CPU cooler to keep the temp at reasonable level, while the i3 2100 would be perfectly fine running on the stock cooler.
So I really cannot understand why spending
MORE money on something that offer "comparable performance at best", while delivering
worse performance in most most general gaming situation, AND with a worse upgrade path- yes some old chipset AM3 board might "support" Bulldozer, but it doesn't mean it will overclock well on it, if at all.
I simply can't identify
ANY pros on going AMD now over Intel SandyBridge...even the entry-level i3 2100; where as cons on not to go AMD, there's a long list....