• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

£400 Gaming PC Spec?

if all he is playing is wow then there isnt a need for a more powerful gpu i would say
also you dont have any extra cooling for the case, another few fans would really help to keep it nice and cool :)
 
When it comes to WoW only an SSD would represent a significant upgrade for stulid's system, and that's another £80+. I'd say the spec as listed is pretty much as good as you're going to get at the price.
 
He should max out the settings at that resolution.

Theres not really a motherboard that has SATA3.0 and USB3.0 for the same price, there are some H61 boards to look at.
 
Wow favours Intel chips and NVIDIA cards in terms of fps, always has done. At that resolution it would be max settings. Would recommend a new monitor for the chap though when his budget allows.
 
Wow favours Intel chips and NVIDIA cards in terms of fps, always has done. At that resolution it would be max settings. Would recommend a new monitor for the chap though when his budget allows.

Already have done. No idea how people can survive with those resolutions. Not just for games, for general work as well.
 
He should max out the settings at that resolution.

Theres not really a motherboard that has SATA3.0 and USB3.0 for the same price, there are some H61 boards to look at.

Will do. Think the 5850 will come down again? It seems to beat the 460 by quite a bit according to anandtech bench.
 
I would still go with the AMD build.

We have discussed the merits of i3 and phenoms plenty of times in low budget gaming builds. the i3 2100 is roughly on par with a 965 and games that wanted a quadcore ran better on the AMD chip. The i3 builds used to win out because the mobo could take an i5 as an upgrade, the AM3+ mobos end that argument with BD support.

I didn't realise the rig was solely to play WOW. I was trying to advise a well rounded system. If stulids build is better for WOW then fair enough, if i was spending out £400 odd quid i'd want a quadcore but my gaming habits are different.

Good luck with the build
 
I would still go with the AMD build.

We have discussed the merits of i3 and phenoms plenty of times in low budget gaming builds. the i3 2100 is roughly on par with a 965 and games that wanted a quadcore ran better on the AMD chip. The i3 builds used to win out because the mobo could take an i5 as an upgrade, the AM3+ mobos end that argument with BD support.

I didn't realise the rig was solely to play WOW. I was trying to advise a well rounded system. If stulids build is better for WOW then fair enough, if i was spending out £400 odd quid i'd want a quadcore but my gaming habits are different.

Good luck with the build

I was also just informed of the WOW requirements. Was news to everybody.

According to anandtech bench, the i3 seems to win on pretty much every test by quite a wee bit except for the video tests... which you would have course expect a dedicated quad core to win. However, as he will never upgrade the processor to an i5 or BD. It makes no difference.

I was under the same impression as yourself. Go for AMD on a budget. I hadn't even bothered to look at the bench tests.
 
I just don't see the appeal of an i3 over the AMD AM3+ setup.

I would take the 955 and do the minor OC to make it a 965 or better still a 3.8Ghz overclock is virtually guaranteed with an aftermarket cooler. Compare the benchmarks of the i3 2100 and 980BE (3.7ghz).

I know you said no overclocking but most mobos now will pretty much do it themselves in minutes. You can't OC an i3, my 880 chipset mobo unlocked my 555BE luckily to a quadcore (955 basically) and then OC'd it to 3.8ghz and it literally took 10mins to do.

When you say your friend isn't likely to upgrade the CPU then the ability to overclock actually makes more sense. I don't believe he could tell the difference between the 955 and i3 at stock, problem being when the i3 shows it's age it isn't possible to ask anymore of it unlike the AMD CPU.

I'm not saying the other guys are wrong, these are just opinions. The mention of WOW has shifted the spec to suit the game. I don't like to disagree with stulid he is excellent at spec'ing parts from OC'ers website, I just know he has stated in previous threads that in some cases the phenom is better than an i3.

I'm not trying to cause a headache. You can check the benchmarks for the CPUs and GPUs yourself. Stulid spec'd a good rig for WOW, let your friend see this thread and the benchmarks and let him decide if he wants the rig dedicated to WOW or for it to be more versatile for other games and being able to be OC'd.

Anywhich way he's going to have a half decent system, it can't be said you didn't do your best weighing out the options ;) Best of luck with it bud
 
As i said on the other i3 vs phenom thread. Those games are OLD they use in the Anandtech benchmarks. I would rather see some newer titles that are optimised for X4s
 
metro.png


f1.png


starcraft.png


farcry.png


metro.png


There's just no contest. Sure you can overclock a 955BE, but why would you want to when you can get a i3 + H61 and be done with it.

...Can't believe I'm saying that! 955BE and AM3+ still an option though.
 
Last edited:
Still old games and that's the 955 at stock. I'd be interested in the 970/980 (955 oc'd) vs the i3 2100. Thanks for making the post though, the OP said no OC'ing so at stock the i3 makes sense.
 
I would still go with the AMD build.

We have discussed the merits of i3 and phenoms plenty of times in low budget gaming builds. the i3 2100 is roughly on par with a 965 and games that wanted a quadcore ran better on the AMD chip.
Not really, even for BFBC2, the Phenom II X4 980 at 3.7GHz is a tiny bit behind the i3 2100:
http://techreport.com/articles.x/20873/2

Let's face it...how many games out there actually using Quad-core FULLY? In any game that doesn't, the Phenom II X4 falls behind..it is that simple. The Phenom II X4 also consume around double the power of the i3 2100 (Phenom II X4 980BE 3.7GHz at TDP 140W vs i3 2100 TDP 65W). People would be crazy to buy Quad-core for quad-core sake, if the PC is for gaming and general usage, and nothing like video encoding etc.
 
Last edited:
It's just my opinion. If I was buying on a low budget I would want the quadcore if possible even if games arent fully using them now they will do. Personally I'd like to get the best core system I could for the cash. If you go by the benchmarks the 970BE tops the i3 2100 in a fair few tests when it loses it's pretty close.

The OP has got a better build than he quickly originally chucked together. He's stated that he wont upgrade or OC etc, stulid took this all into account and spec'd a good build as I already said. I just don't understand the logic of building the rig solely to perform well on one old game WOW.

This build isn't for me. I just wanted to point out the options that's all.
 
It's just my opinion. If I was buying on a low budget I would want the quadcore if possible even if games arent fully using them now they will do. Personally I'd like to get the best core system I could for the cash. If you go by the benchmarks the 970BE tops the i3 2100 in a fair few tests when it loses it's pretty close.
Not really. Phenom II's old K10 architecture is already hitting the wall, and even for games that are well-optimsed for quad such as BFBC2 it is not really performaning better than the dual-core i3 2100 so there's no point.

Another thing you keep overlooking is the cost. Phenom II X4 975/980BE is MORE expensive, not only on the CPU itself, but the electricity to run as well. Let's say we use GTX460 1GB and 6850 1GB as example...they both deliver similar performance, but let's say IF the 6850 1GB consume 80W extra in power...would it make sense to to get it instead of the GTX460 1GB? No! And this is not even a good example for representing Phenom II X4 vs i3 2100, since the Phenom II X4 in only comparable to i3 2100's frame rate in games that use quad-core fully, and its frame rate will ALWAYS be lower in games that uses less than 4 cores, or even in games that use 4 cores, but not using them as fully as can be. It's like...why would you want pay 4 guys who can only lift 30KG £10 each to carry something weight 100KG, when you can get 2 guys who can lift 60KG £10 each and save £20? (the wage represent the electricity/power consumption). Haven't more in physcial numbers doesn't means it is better...another example would be two 500GB HDD vs one 1TB HDD (not talking about RAID)...£60 vs £40...and require more power consumption got carrying same amount of data.

Even if people were getting Phenom II X4 955BE to overclock to 3.7~3.8GHz, they still need to pay the extra for 3rd party CPU cooler to keep the temp at reasonable level, while the i3 2100 would be perfectly fine running on the stock cooler.

So I really cannot understand why spending MORE money on something that offer "comparable performance at best", while delivering worse performance in most most general gaming situation, AND with a worse upgrade path- yes some old chipset AM3 board might "support" Bulldozer, but it doesn't mean it will overclock well on it, if at all.

I simply can't identify ANY pros on going AMD now over Intel SandyBridge...even the entry-level i3 2100; where as cons on not to go AMD, there's a long list....
 
Last edited:
I just don't understand the logic of building the rig solely to perform well on one old game WOW.

These aren't my gaming habits. If he wants to play WOW 24/7 that's upto him. I've been asked to build a system to suit his needs, not re evaluate his lifestyle and force him to play Dirt 3 lol.

I do understand your points and until I seen the benchmarks. I was very much AMD based on it being a quad.

I chose an old i3 at the end of last year over a quad core for my girlfriend as she wouldn't have utilised it and the i3 beat it in all other tests except some games and video.
 
Back
Top Bottom