• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

5770 or 5850?

Associate
Joined
25 Sep 2009
Posts
297
Location
Durham uk
I am building my i7 rig and can't decide what card to go for. As it stands i am going for i7 920, Gigabyte GA-EX58 ( or asus PT SE) OCZ 6 GB TRI chan 1066.

But what card? about 100 pound dif in price, may not seem a lot in a i7 rig but we have to have limits!

Thankyou for any help
 
It depends what games you play and what you want to achive with your build. I built an i7 920 build recently but couldn't justify £250 (the price then) on a 5850. I went with a 5770 for £120 and sold the Dirt 2 voucher for £15 making the 5770 good value at £105.

The 5770 is perfectly capable for most things.
 
5850

The 5770 is just the same performance as a gtx260/4870 1gb and gets beaten by the 4890 but with lower power consumption + dx11 support.
It's my opinion that the 5770 will be getting low frames in dx11 mode.
 
Last edited:
It depends, imo, i'd have no grudge paying the extra for the 5850 but it's your decision. The performance for me is work it.
 
I will be running games in 1920x1080 and I play all games that are going, I am a game nerd. Will prbs pay the xtra cash for the 5850 with future hopes of xfire :D
 
All these people getting 5770's thinking they'll be maxing out bad company 2 etc in dx11 at high res are in for a shock imo and will be swiftly putting the settings back to dx 9 or 10 where a 4870 1gb gtx 260 4890 will be out performing the 5770 anyway.
The only way to look at a 5770 is to pretend it's a 4870 512mb that uses less power, what good is dx11 if the cards pulling 15 fps.
 
Last edited:
All these people getting 5770's thinking they'll be maxing out bad company 2 etc in dx11 at high res are in for a shock imo and will be swiftly putting the settings back to dx 9 or 10.

Agree, you need to do your homework, which is why I got another one for crossfire.:D
 
So what is the point of 5770 xfire ? you get the potential bugs and games not even working until driver updates microstutter it's a whole can of worms.
And with the extra power draw may as well just have a single 5850 and overclock it slightly.
A single 5850 is piratically neck and neck with 5770 xfire and uses about 70 watts less power so xfire 5770 just doesn't make sense to me at all on any level apart from not being able to afford or wait and save for a 5850.
 
Last edited:
So what is the point of 5770 xfire ? you get the potential bugs the extra power draw may as well just have a single 5850 and overclock it slightly.

No bugs for me, doesn't draw much more than a 5850 and beats the 5850 in most games and the 5870 in some. Initially I didn't have the cash for 2 X 5770 and only had the one and couldn't afford 5850\5870. Got some unexpected cash shortly after getting my first 5770 so got another.
Quite impressed so far with these.:D

Running 35c idle, 55-60c loaded and take all I chuck at them.

But I agree if I had the cash initially I would have gone for 5850.
 
Last edited:
I am building my i7 rig and can't decide what card to go for. As it stands i am going for i7 920, Gigabyte GA-EX58 ( or asus PT SE) OCZ 6 GB TRI chan 1066.

But what card? about 100 pound dif in price, may not seem a lot in a i7 rig but we have to have limits!

Thankyou for any help
I'd go 5850, 5770 is good but it's generally not a good idea to get the first in a series of cards (in a DX range) since it won't run that very well. It's hard to state which is best as 5770 has more upgradability (cheaper so move on later). These being the first set of DX 11 cards I can imagine they won't be running the tougher future DX11 games so I'm getting a 5770 and wating for the 6850 :D But then again getting a 5850 now gives you more fps up until you upgrade. Hard choice but since you're willing to fork out I suggest the 5850.
 
+1 for the 5850, sure the 5770 is a great card for the price, but its DX11 performance is not up to the same standard as the 5850, and it is slightly slower than older tech (4890). The 5850 will give you more mileage in my opinion.
 
All these people getting 5770's thinking they'll be maxing out bad company 2 etc in dx11 at high res are in for a shock imo and will be swiftly putting the settings back to dx 9 or 10 where a 4870 1gb gtx 260 4890 will be out performing the 5770 anyway.
The only way to look at a 5770 is to pretend it's a 4870 512mb that uses less power, what good is dx11 if the cards pulling 15 fps.

think that is very wrong i have owned both cards and the 5770 is way more superior to the 4870 512mb i still get more fps using a 5770 in dx 10 very high than i did with my 4870 512mb using dx 9 high settings
 
No bugs for me, doesn't draw much more than a 5850 and beats the 5850 in most games and the 5870 in some. Initially I didn't have the cash for 2 X 5770 and only had the one and couldn't afford 5850\5870. Got some unexpected cash shortly after getting my first 5770 so got another.
Quite impressed so far with these.:D

Running 35c idle, 55-60c loaded and take all I chuck at them.

But I agree if I had the cash initially I would have gone for 5850.

It does draw more power than a single 5850 about 70 watts more and like you said only reason to get a 5770 is because you cant afford a 5850 or 2x 5770 in one go but plan on adding a second later.

think that is very wrong i have owned both cards and the 5770 is way more superior to the 4870 512mb i still get more fps using a 5770 in dx 10 very high than i did with my 4870 512mb using dx 9 high settings
Here ya go proof that the 4870 512mb is faster
http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/radeon-5770-overclocking,review-31736-9.html
 
Last edited:
It does draw more power than a single 5850 about 70 watts more and like you said only reason to get a 5770 is because you cant afford a 5850 or 2x 5770 in one go but plan on adding a second later.


Here ya go proof that the 4870 512mb is faster
http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/radeon-5770-overclocking,review-31736-9.html

don't need you to try and push proof on a couple of games that were apparently faster in toms hardware tests.. like i said i've owned them both and can honestly say the 5770 gives a better constant FPS than the 4870 512mb ever will. Unless you've owned both cards mate and played the same games with them then don't just beleive a few tests!!!! believe the people that have owned and experienced them.

have you seen the 4870 512mb minimum FPS on some games it utter stinks 5770 is a far more superior card in every way less noise, less heat easily overclockable..

final point being you cannot compare a 4870 512mb to a 1GB GDDR5 5770
 
It's more t han a couple of games and any time the 5770 beats it it's by .1 of a frame.
 
Back
Top Bottom