• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

5870 = hot & loud?

Associate
Joined
19 Jul 2008
Posts
443
Location
Lincoln
Hi,
Just got a Powercolor 5870 today and concerned/annoyed by it. I bought it to replace a 4870x2 which I thought was dying and it turns out the 4870x2 is just fine :rolleyes:

I've reinstalled Windows and installed Cat 10.2. Playing BF:BC2 the GPU hits 88°C which is alrightish but in GPUz 'GPU temp #2' hits 102°C <- is that not a bit too hot? My old card sometimes hit that with auto fan speed.

Second problem is the noise, its louder than the 4870x2 but its more noticeable due to the fan constantly reving upto 44% then dropping back to 30% every 10 seconds. Are there any BIOS's with decent fan profiles that could fix this problem?

Is this behaviour typical of 5870's? I don't recall seeing it mentioned anywhere.

Jason.
 
Assuming you have got decent air through your case it sounds a bit 'hot' to me & the revving up and down is not something mine suffers from.

Am using 9.11 drivers rather than 10.2 .... if that makes any difference??

Am running xfx 5870 - runs 27c idle and fan speed (on auto) runs @ 21% - under load fan speed goes up to 30% approx. (did try it at 40% which I thought was too loud and running auto have never heard it as loud as that !).

In saying above am assuming that your not clocking the card
 
Idle is 36°C at 21% fan speed. Under load it trys to stay at 30% fan speed but gets too hot so shoots up to 44% to cool it down then it just keeps repeating this cycle.
 
Just ran a 5min Furmark stability test to see how mine ran. Summary:-

Max Temp. GPU 78c
Max Fan . 31%
Max GPU#1 82c
Max GPU#2 85c
Max GPU#3 81c

And after 2mins idle

45c
21%
44c
48.5c
45c

Currently
31c
21%
32c
37.5c
34c
 
Thats not right if you have good airflow

My 5870 (XFX) idles at 31C and load if around 50 - 55C so I would say thats way too hot for a 5870
 
Mine used to idle mid 30's and load mid 70's
didnt have any noticable fan noise apart from when first booting ..

Stock fans in the bin now and it hasnt gone over 36c with the EK block :D
 
OK just run a quick furmark for 10 mins. Temp topped out at 76 fan usage 33%. I'm using stock cooling and no overclock on the card. Also its very quiet. Much less noise the my 8800gtx that it replaced.
 
I have the 5870 Vapour-X and I have never seen it go much over 70C even this last week or so with the warm weather.
 
I feared I might have to return it. Had to wait long enough to get the thing, was lost in the post (different etailor).

Will do some more testing when I'm back from work.
 
Just ran a 10min Furmark and mine hits 85C after 2 1/2 minutes and sits there for the rest of the time with the fan hitting a max of 40%. It's definitely audible but nothing too distracting and far better than I was expecting.

I know my case isn't the coolest as it's built for quietness but I never get any problems with overheating, the card idles around 40C with the fan at 21% and hits about 75C and about 30% fan when gaming.
 
Hi,
Just got a Powercolor 5870 today and concerned/annoyed by it. I bought it to replace a 4870x2 which I thought was dying and it turns out the 4870x2 is just fine :rolleyes:

I've reinstalled Windows and installed Cat 10.2. Playing BF:BC2 the GPU hits 88°C which is alrightish but in GPUz 'GPU temp #2' hits 102°C <- is that not a bit too hot? My old card sometimes hit that with auto fan speed.

Second problem is the noise, its louder than the 4870x2 but its more noticeable due to the fan constantly reving upto 44% then dropping back to 30% every 10 seconds. Are there any BIOS's with decent fan profiles that could fix this problem?

Is this behaviour typical of 5870's? I don't recall seeing it mentioned anywhere.

Jason.

I sold a card to a friend once which was a dual slot cooler. He rang me complaining that the card was throttling and the fans were spinning up and cutting out.

I went round to his house and removed the card to find that his previous card was a single slot 8800GT and he'd forgot to remove the extra sot cover from his case so it was blocking his new cards vents.

Much laughing and calling him a tool then happened.......

My 5870 is silent, and the coolest card I've owned for years so this is the only thing I can think of as a suggestion, its worth a look.
 
...he'd forgot to remove the extra sot cover from his case so it was blocking his new cards vents.

How is that even possible? Wouldn't you have to force the top DVI port through the bracket somehow?

All my previius cards have had dual slot coolers so I doubt this problem is likely ;)
 
Second problem is the noise, its louder than the 4870x2 but its more noticeable due to the fan constantly reving upto 44% then dropping back to 30% every 10 seconds. Are there any BIOS's with decent fan profiles that could fix this problem?

Don't think so this is the reason that I watercooled mine, the fan was up and down all the time.

If you can enable V-sync it should help but not all games have the option and the ATI CP option is as much use as a chocolate fireguard.

I'm not sure what "GPU Temp 2" refers to it could be PWM which would be within specification I guess.
 
Last edited:
How is that even possible? Wouldn't you have to force the top DVI port through the bracket somehow?

All my previius cards have had dual slot coolers so I doubt this problem is likely ;)

There was a gap for the DVI ports, but not for the exhaust, he said it took him ages to get it to "fit." :D
 
Don't think so this is the reason that I watercooled mine, the fan was up and down all the time.

If you can enable V-sync it should help but not all games have the option and the ATI CP option is as much use as a chocolate fireguard.

I'm not sure what "GPU Temp 2" refers to it could be PWM which would be within specification I guess.

I always use vsync. The temps I mentioned i mentioned were with vsync. Will test with furmark later. Still stuck at work!
 
Back
Top Bottom