• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

5870 or 5830 cfx

Soldato
Joined
3 Aug 2010
Posts
3,898
as the tittle says should i get a 5870 at £194.99 or 2 5830's at around £105 each.

both have same design

dsc0058so.jpg


bear in mind that i will be doing eyefinity with 3 19 inch moniters at 1440x900 per moniter just want to know which will do better for me :)
 
the 5830's in crossfire will be faster than a single 5870 , but the downside is it will have a lower min fps than the 5870 while gaming
 
On the back of my MSI box its says 500w recommended for 1 58xx series card and 600w for 2. It doesn't state which 58 series card so I assume for all of them.

This is a box for a 5850 so I assume if it says 600w for 2, 750w for two 5830's is going to be more than enough! Dont know how many 6 pin connectors you will need off the 12v(i think it is) rail, you need two to run my one 5850!
 
On the back of my MSI box its says 500w recommended for 1 58xx series card and 600w for 2. It doesn't state which 58 series card so I assume for all of them.

This is a box for a 5850 so I assume if it says 600w for 2, 750w for two 5830's is going to be more than enough! Dont know how many 6 pin connectors you will need off the 12v(i think it is) rail, you need two to run my one 5850!

ok thanks, but still dosn't answer my main question im realy stuck what should i get for eyefinity a 5870 or 5830x2?
 
Im not completely sure, both will be fast enough for it. Its the amount of memory you will need that will make the difference. I would go with the 2x5830's, will be faster in any game plus you will have the extra 1gb GPU memory making 2gb instead of 1.
 
Im not completely sure, both will be fast enough for it. Its the amount of memory you will need that will make the difference. I would go with the 2x5830's, will be faster in any game plus you will have the extra 1gb GPU memory making 2gb instead of 1.

actually this isn't true the memory dosn't combine 1gb+1gb = 1gb

but after thinking about 2 5830's will be faster, makes me feel silly because i've being raving about how cheap the 5870's are all week but now im not going to get one :D
 
Im not completely sure, both will be fast enough for it. Its the amount of memory you will need that will make the difference. I would go with the 2x5830's, will be faster in any game plus you will have the extra 1gb GPU memory making 2gb instead of 1.

Unfortunately 2 x 1gb of memory doesn't = 2gb. It will only result in 1gb of usable memory at any one time.


Ahh nvm, someone's already mentioned that.
 
Last edited:
I didn't know that. It was an assumption that I guess I accepted. Any one know why that is? I don't get it, if the GPU's can be used simultaneously how come the memory cannot?

All I know is that the shaders / rops and other architecture on the card is doubled, giving the increase in performance. That's what makes the difference. Why the memory isn't I'm not sure.

When the 4870x2 was released there was mention in reviews of a driver update allowing communication between the two x 1gb memory. Alas it never happened.
 
cheers looks like they scale very well and should be breeze in eyefinity

only just measured my case lol im in luck they fit with an inch left to spare :)
EDIT about half an inch but should be fine (hopes)
 
Back
Top Bottom