• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

5870 or a 5850?

Associate
Joined
20 Jul 2005
Posts
322
Location
Herts
Upgrade time is due, and i'm torn between getting either the Sapphire 5870 Vapour X
or a 5850.
On the 5850 front of things, Powercooler or Sapphire seems to be of the few available for immediate order and shipping. Is there a major difference bewteen the 2 brands?
I'm upgrading from a very stable 8800 GTX 768Mb verison, and to be honest the Sapphire model catches my eye better of the two lower bracket cards, but if i'm honest the Vapour X 5870 would easily get me into bed : )

Also, is it worth waiting untill the ne Nvidia set appears before buying? or is the drop in price due to the wars likely to be minimal?

Any advice is appreciated thanks
 
I can't give you a definite answer, but I can however give you something to think about, and decide for yourself.

i) Do I really need 5870, or is 5850 already fast enough for me to play all my current and future games at the highest settings and AA smoothly?

ii) 5870 cost 50% (£100ish) more than a 5850...am I getting my money's worth for performance when 5870 is definitely not 50% faster than 5850?

iii) When nvidia's Fermi arrive, would it outperform HD5850/5870 significantly?

iv) Is my 8800GTX performing so poorly in the current games I'm playing, that I can't stand it to the point that I have to upgrade asap...instead of waiting for a few more months to see what Fermi has to offer, so that the better card can win my money?
 
Last edited:
I can't give you a definite answer, but I can however give you something to think about, and decide for yourself.

i) Do I really need 5870, or is 5850 already fast enough for me to play all my current and future games at the highest settings and AA smoothly?

ii) 5870 cost 50% (£100ish) more than a 5850...am I getting my money's worth for performance when 5870 is definitely not 50% faster than 5850?

iii) When nvidia's Fermi arrive, would it outperform HD5850/5870 significantly?

iv) Is my 8800GTX performing so poorly in the current games I'm playing, that I can't stand it to the point that I have to upgrade asap...instead of waiting for a few more months to see what Fermi has to offer, so that the better card can win my money?
Stop it! You make me wanna cancel my 5870 lol :p
 
General consensus is that the 5850 is the best value. At stock speeds the 5870 is around 20% faster but costs 50% more. Both cards will comfortably play any current game at high res and settings.
 
The 5850 will play everything at max setting on 1900x1200 at least. Minor upgrade for about £100+ isnt work it imo.
 
I can't give you a definite answer, but I can however give you something to think about, and decide for yourself.

i) Do I really need 5870, or is 5850 already fast enough for me to play all my current and future games at the highest settings and AA smoothly?

Not really, as i only play WoW which runs all bar one or two settings on max eye candy @ 1650 x 1080

ii) 5870 cost 50% (£100ish) more than a 5850...am I getting my money's worth for performance when 5870 is definitely not 50% faster than 5850?

Your right there.....5850 is the better value for money, i guess the nice looking fan and the thought of frost bite on my vid card is the puller here

iii) When nvidia's Fermi arrive, would it outperform HD5850/5870 significantly?

That i cannot answer without doing some homework or sums, althogh i've always been an Nvidia guy, although the 5850/70 looks to me to out do the 285GTX. I've not read up at all on Fermi (sounds like a contraceptive pill ! lol) and i do wonder how much the cards will drop by once Fermi is out.

iv) Is my 8800GTX performing so poorly in the current games I'm playing, that I can't stand it to the point that I have to upgrade asap...instead of waiting for a few more months to see what Fermi has to offer, so that the better card can win my money?

I'd agree there, all bar one or two settings as previously mentioned, i run WoW more or less flawlessly. I'm merely thinking of DX11 for BC2 upon it's arrival, a friend has the identical setup to me and says the 8800 GTX will run BC2, but at low settings
 
Thanks for the comments all, i'm still deciding, but from the few posts so far, the 5850 looks to be the good choice, and i'll save a ton of cash (letrally) which will help my Windows 7 fund nicely : )

Thanks all
 
how much do you want for your GTX? - should help you decide what you can get a bit more :)

That's a tempting offer, i'm not sure what they go for 2nd hand, although enay are spouting somne good prices. Not quite the 8800 GTS version but for the 8800 range, i considered it a good card, especially with the extra rammage : )

What do they go for these days? A friend is intersted in it, as an upgrade from his Nvidia 400 odd series ( summit low level anyhow )
 
If money is at all a concern, then the 5850 hands down. Got mine at 1050 / 1200 atm and the sky's the limit. Will be purchasing another this week. :D
 
I used the steps in this guide: http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?p=15021144#post15021144

but that is for the 5870. Just replace with the 5850 BIOS here: http://www.techpowerup.com/vgabios/58225/Asus.HD5850.1024.090925.html

and it's the same process. THIS WILL VOID YOUR WARRANTY so don't do it if you're not confident.

I have MSI Afterburner set up with 2 profiles, stock as my 2D settings so powerplay can work and OC which kicks in automagical for games (so long as Afterburner is running). Setting Afterburner to load at startup causes coloured-screen-of-death so I don't do that and advise against it.
 
Last edited:
I answered my own question. Goes to show you that you should read the entire thread before asking a silly question! (My question was about voiding the warranty.)
 
thanks all for your help guys, a 5850 was procurred just a while ago.....roll on some new eye candy wOOt
 
Back
Top Bottom