• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

6990m vs 580m

Associate
Joined
20 Feb 2012
Posts
562
Hi guys

Now i now this must have been discussed before but i think its good to ask as these have been out a while now.

So what do you prefer 6990m or 580m? I understand that the 580m overclockers better as it runs cooler, but would i need to overclock either? I'd be playing on a monitor (at work :D) @ 1680x1050, games like BF3, BFBC2 and any future battlefield games mainly.

Also does 1600mhz ram make much difference over 1333mhz, will be 8gb. Would i notice any improvement while gaming? Will be with an i7.

Thanks
 
I can afford either:

6990m with 2.4ghz i7, 1600mhz memory, 500gb hdd

or

6990m with 2.2ghz i7, 1333mhz memory, 120gb SSD, 320gb hdd

or

580m with 2.2ghz i7 with 1333mhz memory, 500gb hybrid hdd

I just can't decide :confused: Kind of swaying towards the 580m as it runs cooler apparently, and can be overclocked to pretty much a 560 ti speeds.
 
Don't buy now, already several gaming laptops announced for April with Ivy bridge etc.

I don't know if i can wait that long, its going to be a work laptop...

Will ivy bridge make that much difference over a decent Sandy i7 ? Don't think any games max out a cpu yet do they??


The hybrid HDD will be a Seagate Momentus XT, iirc is has a 4bg SSD chip built in.
 
I'd get the 580M with the hybrid seagate

Any particular reason?

made a bit of a boo boo, the laptop can only support one hard drive and the ssd's are too expensive for the size i need. 500gb hybrid it will have to be.

Yes, i do like overclocking. And i like the fact that both gpu's are close at stock speeds, so i guess the 580m overclocked will come out on top. Are the temps safe at at 560 ti clocks though?
 
Ah well since you were talking about 2 HDDs I thought you were looking at the MSI... so I don't know if the cooling on the Sager can handle the high clocked stuff.

You could still get an external ODD and put the 2nd HDD in the optical bay....
 
having experience of all this ill give you my opinion.

ive just come from a laptop alienware m17x r3, i had a 6990 and it was a beast. there were two problems though, drivers and heat.

drivers for amd are a bit cumbersome and fiddly and never tend to install right most of time id have 75% performance i should have had, installing caps would even give me a blue screen, i had to stay with the stock dell drivers which were first drivers ever released.

the heat problem was that, having it on my lap/knees/table, when the card spun up it got warm and if you didnt give it good ventillation it would scorch your leg, the card would then throttle and youd get 30% you should

imo if you had to go laptop choose 580, better driver suppport, physx, bettter aa, they seem to clock better. it seems the 6990m is at its pinnacle of frequency where as i get the impression the 580m could have been faster hence the room for better oc headroom.

long and short of it, i got fed up, sold laptop, got a pc that was nearly twice as fast for 75% of price.

id wait for ivy bridge, the die shrink would be a VERY big godsend for things like gaming laptops, less heat, less throttle, more frequency head room means bigger leaps in performance, id wait it out myself if i was you.
 
having experience of all this ill give you my opinion.

ive just come from a laptop alienware m17x r3, i had a 6990 and it was a beast. there were two problems though, drivers and heat.

drivers for amd are a bit cumbersome and fiddly and never tend to install right most of time id have 75% performance i should have had, installing caps would even give me a blue screen, i had to stay with the stock dell drivers which were first drivers ever released.

the heat problem was that, having it on my lap/knees/table, when the card spun up it got warm and if you didnt give it good ventillation it would scorch your leg, the card would then throttle and youd get 30% you should

imo if you had to go laptop choose 580, better driver suppport, physx, bettter aa, they seem to clock better. it seems the 6990m is at its pinnacle of frequency where as i get the impression the 580m could have been faster hence the room for better oc headroom.

long and short of it, i got fed up, sold laptop, got a pc that was nearly twice as fast for 75% of price.

id wait for ivy bridge, the die shrink would be a VERY big godsend for things like gaming laptops, less heat, less throttle, more frequency head room means bigger leaps in performance, id wait it out myself if i was you.

I've had a HD6870, desktop gpu and that seemed fine to be honest, hence me thinking about the 6990m.

The laptop will be used on my desk at work, so heat isnt an issue. That is heat being transfered to me i mean, of course though i can't have it over heating and throttling all the time.

I have read a lot of people having issues with 580m's throttling, and at 70 something degrees... But i'm not sure if that's an Alienware 'thing'?

Do you know at what temperature does the 6990m throttle back?

Ah well since you were talking about 2 HDDs I thought you were looking at the MSI... so I don't know if the cooling on the Sager can handle the high clocked stuff.

You could still get an external ODD and put the 2nd HDD in the optical bay....

Its a Clevo 15.6" so i'm not sure what the cooling is like on those, can't really go for an external ODD either :(
 
as soon as i noticed the 6990m was hot it started acting up tbh, the 580m does throttle but theres a bio mod to take the 70 upto 89 i think. something around the 80 reigion anyway. i think the driver problems were because i had a dell and the drivers were specifically wrote to make the igp and everything work together, if i just installed any old driver from amd then nothing would even happen. clevos are apparently like jet engines, the more powerful your hardware at this moment in time the louder and hotter its going to be, i cant stress enough how you would extremely benefit from waiting for the node shrinks. even on my new desktop 3820 with 32nm compared to my old 40nm i now get 23 degrees instead of 38. my laptop cpu always hovered around 57degrees idle
 
I do agree about waiting, but the big question is when will a 6990m replacement be available.

Correct me if i'm wrong but AMD have released 7xxx mobile gpu's but nothing in the same league as the 6990m. Will the replacement come later but be much better? Who knows..... I'm pretty eager to get something sooner rather than later, but anything over a month is a bit too long. I hate waiting, i just wish release dates would be announced :(

Then i also hear Clevo are refreshing their laptops soon also.... i can't find any dates though.
 
youl see the 7970m around march/april like desktop parts. the 7990m will be a mid year update its not usually anymore powerful than the 7970, itds just a refresh, like laptop sandy bridges 2620>2630>2670 so your looking at april for ivy bridge 22 nm in laptop with a tdp of about 30 watts and 7970m in april too with 28nm shrink
 
laptops with 635Mare already out. But that's basically an improved 555M. Nothing close to a 580M. If I were you I'd just go with that. The GPU is the biggest bottleneck and heat output source on a laptop. Having the best GPU is the best choice you can make with a laptop.
 
laptops with 635Mare already out. But that's basically an improved 555M. Nothing close to a 580M. If I were you I'd just go with that. The GPU is the biggest bottleneck and heat output source on a laptop. Having the best GPU is the best choice you can make with a laptop.

I agree ;)

Thats why i'm thinking do i wait for the new gpu's. If anything that comes close isn't coming out for another 4-6 months then i'll pull the trigger now. These gpu's do suffer with heat so 28nm would be nice, but i cant wait anymore than a month really.
 
Back
Top Bottom