A Rant About PWM (in general) & Z97 MBs
- Thread starter Nuluvius
- Start date
At RPMs that actually do something >500-600, I have not heard ticking. If it happens at 300RPM, it is a different thing. If the motor has some sort of noise it is not due to the PWM. My F14s make noise from the motor at any RPM and my Fractal 14cm fans make noise as well, first are PWM controlled, second are 3 pin voltage controlled. This is just bad bearing that is too quiet to be heard when the fan is at full speed. It has nothing to do with the PWM.
Soldato
- Joined
- 18 Oct 2012
- Posts
- 8,352
solutions:
wear headphones
move computer out of the room so you cant hear it at all [also keeps room cooler]
ignore the tick/be less sensitive to noise
passive cooling
listen to loud heavy music until you partially lose hearing
get a different hobby
never heard a tick from any of my pwm fans [all corsair units], either i cant hear it or it aint there.
wear headphones
move computer out of the room so you cant hear it at all [also keeps room cooler]
ignore the tick/be less sensitive to noise
passive cooling
listen to loud heavy music until you partially lose hearing
get a different hobby
never heard a tick from any of my pwm fans [all corsair units], either i cant hear it or it aint there.
No mate i do not control them the 120mm's run full speed inside my Z77 build from the Asus 4 pin PWM motherboard slot of which i disable al controls in bios. Only the 140mm hoover on the side was controlled as it is flippin awful. But if you have the case anywhere but under the desk the buzz click will drive me insane as my ears can hear it. Akasa apache are just awful there is a thread here about the ticking.
I cannot remember if i started it but i know i had a complaint to OCUK about Apache "Ultra Silent" claims. I now have that whole build for sale and have the rig in my sig with Corsair. I really need to fire it up and test for clicking but i will bet i can hear it from them too.
Last edited:
You can't base the overall tick no tick down to one reference, that's just the guy from Noctua's opinion. I have always used PWM and have never heard any ticking, ever. I use the Akasa Viper 120 / 140, and as far as I'm aware they are the same as the Apache's apart from the colour, and no tick, I've tried them at full / 75 / 50 / 25, and a mixture of in between and lower, and to me and 6 other people I have had listen to them still no tick.
You might be right, they might be on to something but that sounds like a hair conditioning advert. "Now with revitalisit, the special compound that adds... stuff... THAT NO-ONE ELSE HAS!!"
I have one PWM fan. It ticks at lower rpm. It also stalls when run on too low a voltage.
PWM control is great for the fine control it gives you but really it is so much better with a bit of smoothing, like my PWM converter provides.
PWM control is great for the fine control it gives you but really it is so much better with a bit of smoothing, like my PWM converter provides.
Permabanned
- Joined
- 12 Sep 2013
- Posts
- 9,221
- Location
- Knowhere
Good to know, I was considering changing my fan set up and did not know about this.
PWM fans are not meant to be voltage controlled. It should always be 12V, the control is by changing the PWM signal.
I agree, I do not think someone is that naiive that a small PWM controller can create a perfect square wave. It will always be with slopes so their "solution" is purely marketing. And as I said, if the speed of the motor was regulated as you suggest - by turning it on and off - they do not need a PWM signal at all, just modulate the 12V power supply and you will get ticking, vibrations and a hell of a lot other nasty effects of this nonsense. The PWM is one of the simplest and most reliable forms of signal modulation so it is a great translation of a simple percentage number from digital to analogue sent via a wire, nothing else. You might hear single ticks as the voltage goes up and down rapidly on RPM change but if the RPM is constant, there is no change - signal received is the same, voltage supplied to the motor is the same, RPM is the same, no ticking. The noise everyone describes is just bad bearing and it does not sound like ticking but more like squeaking from the friction somewhere in the bearing. As I mentioned, my fans have bad bearing too, as they are cheap Arctics, and they have a low tone squeaking noise that is present at all RPM but is heard only on low RPM. However, this does not mean they tick because they are PWM controlled.
P.S. If I am wrong and all the manufacturers are using the PWM in such a mindless way, I should start a company that makes proper PWM controll PCBs for fans... I highly doubt that every engineer in this industry but me is an absolute moron.
P.P.S. I just saw the same thread and first post into several other forums. Why? Troll?!?
Last edited:
You mustn't read the forums much them, PWM tick is well documented/complained about, and a 140mm @800RPM will be moving the same air as a 120mm @1000-1200RPM so of course you can hear that across a room that doesn't make your hearing good just not deaf.
I have used various Corsair SP, Akasa, Noiseblocker, etc PWM fans and every one ticked. It was extremely evident when the other fans were running at low speed (800RPM slipstreams at 500RPM via voltage control so no PWM tick).
Last edited:
As I said, even if there are ticks, fans do barely anything both from airflow and static pressure aspect at 500RPM so I see no reason using my fans at those speeds. I use mine at about 650-700RPM at idle and I neither hear them nor the ticking. Give me some footage material with this ticking as the ones I've found are not ticking as I would describe the sound from spinning up fast a DC motor.